Contrary to what many a Grammar Nazi the world over would have you believe, language is constantly
evolving, occasionally extremely rapidly, and there is nothing wrong with that, despite
such individuals lamenting that fact pretty much as long as we have documented reference
of people discussing language.
For example, when the earliest use of some form of punctuation started to be introduced,
many, like the famous Roman orator Cicero, scorned such, noting things like when and
how long to pause “ought to be determined not… by a stroke interposed by a copyist,
but by the constraint of the rhythm.”
It's noteworthy here that at that point even spaces between words wasn't a thing.
Those weren't around until approximately the 7th and 8th centuries (and are said to have
been invented, or at least popularized, by Irish and Scottish monks of this era who were
tired of wrestling with separating unfamiliar Latin words).
It was also around the end of the 8th century when Charlemagne helped to introduce lowercase
letters to the masses after requesting that the monk, Alcuin, develop a unified alphabet,
which ultimately included these.
Summing up this seemingly never ending evolution and just as never ending groaning by those
who strictly adhere to more of a prescriptive mindset, Betty Birner of the Linguistic Society
of America notes, “The speech patterns of young people tend
to grate on the ears of adults because they're unfamiliar.
Also, new words and phrases are used in spoken or informal language sooner than in formal,
written language, so it's true that the phrases you may hear a teenager use may not yet be
appropriate for business letters.
But that doesn't mean they're worse - just newer.”
And that's not to mention accents and how those change over time.
Pertinent to the topic at hand today, if you were to travel back to Shakespearean times
and listen to the bard speak, he would have actually sounded much more like one of the
pirates on the Pirates of the Caribbean than the refined Received Pronunciation accent
that is so often associated with his work in modern times.
(More on this in a bit.)
So with all that in mind, let's look at the scenario in which you, as an English only
speaker, have invented a time machine and wish to take a little jaunt through history
to observe first hand all the moronic things we humans have gotten up to over the centuries.
First, I hope you remembered to make your time machine a space ship as well.
Remember, along with orbiting around the Sun at 66,600 miles per hour., the Earth is also
rotating on its axis at about 1,070 mph.
On top of that, don't forget our whole solar system is rocketing through space around the
center of the Milky Way at around 560,000 mph.
On top of that, our galaxy is hurtling through space at around 670,000 mph with respect to
our local group of galaxies.
So, bottom line, even if you went back in time just a few seconds, you're going to be
in a VERY different place than when you first achieved 88 mph with your DeLorean.
Go back several hundred years, and you are going to need an extremely fast space ship
and some good star chart data to find your way back to Earth.
But let's say you've figured all that out.
After a quick stop to murder baby Hitler and a few of his top cronies (or at the least
bring a wizened Mister Rogers back to give their parents some life lessons to instill
in their children), how far back could you go and still be able to communicate effectively
in the English speaking world?
To begin with, it would depend on who you were talking to.
There are a shocking number of dialects of English in England alone despite being a relatively
small area.
Some of these dialects are even difficult for a general modern English speaker to understand
fully if the people that are speaking them aren't interested in modifying their speech
so you can understand them.
I mean, have you heard Karl Smallwood of FactFiend speak?
Barely intelligible…
Go back further in time and it would only
get more difficult, with much less standardization as you woosh back through the centuries.
That said, if we restrict ourselves to more of what the upper class of England spoke,
it turns out a modern English speaker could go back quite a ways before things become
too difficult, and you'd do mildly better if you also spoke German and/or Dutch.
On that note, English as we know it today more or less developed from a series of invasions
to the mother island, most notably the invasion of Germanic tribes known as the Angles, Jutes,
and Saxons around the 5th and 6th centuries.
Along with a smattering of Latin, this mix ultimately gave us a large percentage of what
is Old English.
Pertinent to the exact original question, note here that the 6th century or so is when
A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court is set and around when, legend has it, King
Arthur lived.
As an example of what you'd be facing trying to talk to someone in the ballpark of this
period, consider the Anglo-Saxon Chronicles (late 9th century) and the following (and
note here that the "sc" makes the "sh" sound, which helps in understanding slightly):
“Brytene igland is ehta hund mila lang and twa hund mila brad, and her synd on þam iglande
fif geþeodu, Ænglisc, Brytwylsc, Scottysc, Pihttisc and Boclæden.”
In modern English, this translates to: The island Britain is 800 miles long, and
200 miles broad.
And there are in the island five nations; English, Welsh, Scottish, Pictish, and Latin.
As you can see, it wouldn't be a wholly foreign language.
In fact, it's estimated approximately 50% of the core of the modern English language
derives from words in Old English.
However, meaningful communication would be mostly an effort in futility, especially when
accounting for accents and something else we'll get into shortly.
After this, the Vikings would also invade for a few hundred years starting in the 8th
century, lending some words to Old English from Old Norse.
Much more significantly was the Norman Conquest around 1066.
They firmly established a version of French (Old Norman) as the language of choice for
the elite of the country.
The language of the Normans trickled down to the masses and vice-versa, adding a whole
host of words to English, which starts to give us more of the vocabulary we are used
to today.
This and some other changes to the language that occurred at this time all combined bring
us to Middle English, which spanned around the 12th through the 15th centuries, the latter
of which is also generally considered to be when the so-called "medieval times" ended.
Noteworthy here is that during the 14th century, while the upper class still spoke Anglo-Norman,
as this century progressed, it was almost completely displaced by English.
This brings us to the latter half of the 14th century when Chaucer was writing Canterbury
Tales.
As an example of what English looked like at this point, or at least a poetic form of
it, consider these lines from that work: “A KNYGHT ther was, and that a worthy man,
That fro the tyme that he first bigan To riden out, he loved chivalrie,
Trouthe and honour, fredom and curteisie.
Ful worthy was he in his lordes werre, And therto hadde he riden, no man ferre,
As wel in cristendom as in hethenesse, And evere honoured for his worthynesse.”
which translates to: “A KNIGHT there was, and what a gentleman,
Who, from the moment that he first began To ride about the world, loved chivalry,
Truth, honour, freedom and all courtesy.
Full worthy was he in his sovereign's war, And therein had he ridden, no man more,
As well in Christendom as heathenesse, And honoured everywhere for worthiness.”
While you might think from this example you'd be able to be mildly conversational if you
and a native of the time talked slowly enough, it wouldn't be quite that easy owing to the
way the words would have been spoken.
One of the principal problems is that while a lot of the words might at this point be
somewhat familiar, this pre-dated the bulk of what is known as the "Great Vowel Shift"
which occurred primarily from around the mid-14th century through the 16th century or so.
In a nutshell, this is where the pronunciation of various vowels in English changed considerably.
For example, in Middle English the word "bite" would have been pronounced "beet" and something
like the word "meet" would be pronounced like "mate".
This could get really awkward, for example, if a native of the time were to ask you if
you'd like to "Meet later."
As an interesting brief aside, because some of the spellings for English words were beginning
to be standardized before the Great Vowel Shift had completed, we still have many English
words whose spellings don't really match the way we pronounce them because of this.
In any event, from all this, you can start to see why it would be extremely difficult
to understand anyone before this Great Vowel Shift occurred.
Given a little time, you could probably start to figure out those vowel sound differences,
but in the meantime you aren't likely to recognize a lot of words that you otherwise know.
You might at this point be thinking you could get around the problem by reading and writing
as a way to converse.
But even if you were to find such a well educated person to write back and forth with, a quick
perusal of surviving text from this era in its original form would quickly dissuade you
from the notion that this would be an effective way to communicate.
The way they wrote their words and letters wasn't exactly Times New Roman.
Over the following century, however, you would start to make some rapid progress in communication.
For example, consider this text from the play Gorboduc, written in 1561:
“A pestilent plage, a poysonous ill Hath sowen sores in certaigne now of late:
A wood sprited hart : with a wayward wyll :
A stubborne stomache, to nourishe debate : Blered, yea blynded eyes; a brasen brest:
A leden brayne: I recken not the rest.”
This brings us to around the turn of the 16th/17th centuries.
As you might have guessed from the fact that you probably have little trouble reading Shakespeare's
plays and the King James Bible, which were written during this period, at this point
you would very solidly be able to grasp a reasonably large percentage of the vocabulary
of English.
Just as importantly, the Great Vowel Shift was more or less wrapped up around this time,
meaning as long as someone wasn't speaking a particularly peculiar dialect, you'd finally
be able to communicate conversationally with a reasonably large percentage of the English
speaking world.
Speaking of dialects, you also wouldn't have quite as much trouble with that at this point
either, as the language was starting to become somewhat standardized, with London more or
less functioning as the epicenter of that standardization.
As for the exact accent you'd encounter, this could vary in the melting pot that was London
at the time, but, as alluded to previously, if you were dealing with the more affluent
and educated in the area, you could expect something akin to Original Pronunciation or
OP, which is usually described as a mix of an Irish and American accent, or otherwise,
as noted previously, somewhat similar to the stereotypical way pirates speak in movies.
This, perhaps, isn't that surprising as another accent OP is often thought to sound like is
the West Country English accent, which in turn directly inspired the way Hollywood has
pirates talk.
More on why this is the case in the Bonus Facts in a bit.
(And if you want to hear OP for yourself, check out this great video by David and Ben
Crystal where they demonstrated the accent and briefly discuss how linguists know reasonably
well how Shakespeare and those performing his plays talked.)
But to conclude, while certainly there are many words you and a person from this era
would trip each other up on, at this point in history you'd have little trouble communicating
at a mostly conversational level.
Thus, so long as you didn't set your time circuits for too far before the 16th century,
you'd be reasonably fluent in the English of the age, leaving the culture shock to be
the bigger problem, such as the extreme racism, sexism, religious extremism, rampant disease,
poor hygiene, etc. etc.
And don't even get us started on the god-awful smell in places like London in particular.
(See our video The Great Stink of 1858.)
Speaking of something that is GREAT, but in this
case DOESN’T stink….
The Great Courses Plus!!!....
;-) Bonus Fact:
As noted, the West Country accent directly inspired the way pirates stereotypically speak
in Hollywood productions.
This is all thanks to one man- Robert Newton, and the 1950s version of Treasure Island,
which pretty much set the standard for the modern conception of how to speak like a pirate.
In the film, Newton, who played Long John Silver, just so happened to be from the same
area of England that the fictional Long John Silver was from - England's West Country.
Thus, he went ahead and used that dialect for the character.
Noteworthy here is that fishing and shipyards were a part of everyday life in the West Country,
and thus maritime slang was often used as well, much of which was adopted by Newton
for the character in the film.
Perhaps the most popular "pirate speak" expression that comes from this is "arrrr", despite that
there is no documented evidence that this was a thing pirates said historically.
However, where this was spoken in regular conversation was in the West Country when
Newton was growing up in the early 20th century.
Here, "arrr" more or less functioned as an expression that acted as a confirmation, like
"okay".
However, while it is always possible that this expression was around in the West Country
during the so-called "Golden Age of Piracy" from about the mid-17th to mid-18th centuries,
it is unlikely it would have been remotely the norm among the general pirate populace.
As noted by historian Colin Woodard, “[Pirate ships] included large numbers of Scots, Irish,
Africans, and French, as well as a smattering of Dutchmen, Swedes, and Danes.
Of those of English origin, the largest number were probably from London, then by far the
empire's largest port and city.”
Whatever the case, after Robert Newton’s popular portrayal of the character of Long
John Silver in the film and TV sequels, his accent and various things he said became more
or less the gold standard of how a pirate should look and talk.