Ms. Williams is your sister?
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy: Older sister
or younger sister?
>> Older.
>> Judge Judy: How old are you?
>> Twenty-one.
>> Judge Judy: And you?
>> Twenty-three.
>> Judge Judy: You claim a loan
to your sister.
>> Yes.
>> Jude Judy: A loan that
you gave her $400
in March of this year.
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy: Needed something
for rent
or her bills or whatever.
It's really not urgently
important because
Ms. Williams acknowledges
that you made a loan to her
in the amount of $400
in March, correct?
>> Right.
>> Judge Judy: So you needed
money.
You asked your sister.
She helped you.
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy: You didn't pay
her back in March.
Didn't pay her back in April.
>> No.
>> Judge Judy: Right?
And didn't pay her back in May.
Your defense to this is that
your sister vandalized your car.
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy: She vandalized
your car with a rock.
She got angry with you.
You'll tell me about it.
And you have a counterclaim.
Your counterclaim is for
the damage to your car.
I'm sure you have pictures
and an estimate
and that the damage far
exceeds the amount of the loan.
>> Right.
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
that you are owed $400.
Do you remember this incident
that your sister
is talking about in May?
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy: And that was
towards the end of May...
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy: ...of this year?
>> Mm-hmm.
>> Judge Judy: You remember
what date it took place?
>> The 27th.
>> Judge Judy: Why don't you
tell me what happened.
>> Well, she came up to my
boyfriend's house,
and, like, she was honking.
And then I went outside.
And then she came at me
because me and her boyfriend
kissed at a party.
And she pushed me.
Like, I got out of the way.
And then, she picked up a rock
and tried to throw it at me.
And then, I moved,
and she hit her own car.
>> Judge Judy: So she picked up
a rock and threw it at you.
And you say she caused
the damage...
>> Yeah.
>> Judge Judy:
...to her own car?
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy: I'm listening.
>> That doesn't make any sense.
I was standing by my car.
So, how would I have thrown
the rock at my own car?
>> Judge Judy: So tell me
what happened.
>> When I got out,
she came over there.
We're arguing back and forth.
>> Judge Judy: She came
over to...
>> She walked right
toward the car.
She was standing, like,
by the driveway.
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
You went to her house?
>> Her boyfriend's house.
>> Judge Judy: Where she
was staying.
>> Right.
>> Judge Judy: And you knew
that she was there.
What did you go there for?
>> To confront her
for what she did.
>> Judge Judy: You didn't see
what she did, but
I assume you heard what she did.
>> My boyfriend admitted to it.
So that's how I went over there
to confront her.
>> Judge Judy: So you went over
to your kid sister's house
because you thought she was
fooling around
with your boyfriend,
who confessed to you that he was
fooling around with your sister?
>> Right.
>> Judge Judy: By the way,
what did you say or do
to your boyfriend?
>> Well,
that's a different story.
We got into it
before I went over there.
>> Judge Judy: What is...
>> But at the end of the day,
that's my sister.
So I would expect more from her.
So that's why I went
to go confront her.
>> Judge Judy: Well,
that's true.
So you expect
nothing from your boyfriend...
>> Well, I expected --
>> Judge Judy: ...so that
you're not disappointed?
>> I was more than disappointed
with him.
But I was more disappointed with
her because that's my sister.
>> Judge Judy: I don't disagree
with you.
I think that that's probably
logical that you would
expect more from your sister
than you would do from a boy.
Because how old are you?
>> Twenty-four.
>> Judge Judy: No morals.
They think with a different
organ than most people.
But I can understand it.
So you went over there to your
sister's
house where she was staying,
and you drove there.
What did you do?
I started honking the horn.
And then she came out.
And --
>> Judge Judy: So she came out
of the house, and you are where?
>> By my car.
I walked around it.
So I'm by the back door.
>> Judge Judy: And then
what happened?
>> We're going back and forth
yelling,
calling each other names.
She got mad because I told her
that
I would sleep with her boyfriend
because of what she did.
So that's when she threw
the rock.
And I ducked, so I -- well not,
ducked, but went out the way,
and then it hit the car.
>> Judge Judy: Well, you really
didn't mean
that when you said that to her.
>> No, I wouldn't.
>> Judge Judy: Because
that would be really stupid.
>> Yeah.
>> Judge Judy: Then you would
be the fool, right?
>> Right.
>> Judge Judy: Have you spoken
to each other since?
>> No.
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
Can I see photographs of the
car, please?
What kind of rock
caused this damage?
>> Like, a little boulder.
It was, like, a large rock.
Like, theres, like,
a little garden,
and there's rocks around it.
And that's the one she grabbed.
>> Judge Judy: Do you have
an estimate for fixing it?
>> Yeah.
>> Judge Judy: $816,
minus $400.
That's $416.
So you lost the loan.
And she's getting her car fixed.
Judgment on the counterclaim
in the amount of $416.
We're finished.
Thank you.