- So I'm seeing, oh no.
Pickles.
- Hey, everyone, I'm Sepi and today,
we're gonna see who's got the best Shake Shack Order.
- Shake Shack is a proper dinner to me.
It's not a drunk food.
It's not after a night out
the way that other burger places are
like this is a legit meal.
It's an event.
- We always get it on a takeout.
It's our go-to order.
Love burgers, love meat.
Love you, Shake Shack.
- I love burgers but I love burgers made my way
so I like that there's some customization in Shake Shack.
- So you're gonna go to Shake Shack, shake it up,
mix it up, all of that 'cause it's amazing.
- My Shake Shack order is a ShackMeister
'cause I love the sauce but with a double patty.
I gotta have my lettuce, onions, pickles,
ketchup in the burger
and I have ketchup on the side for my cheesy fries
and I love their caramel milkshake.
If you like plain, you're not gonna like it
but if you like a good burger
then you're gonna love my order.
- Big in caps.
Thick.
Huge.
Damn.
- I'm seeing raw onions in this bad boy.
I'm seeing raw onions and you know, I'm just.
- Love the onions.
Add a bit of crunch and texture.
We love to see that.
- We've got the world's biggest onion
and the world's smallest milkshake.
- They've gone for a double patty which is heavy.
It's stodgy.
You've made a bit of a rookie era there.
You need just one because there's no balance there.
It's otherwise, it's gonna be just too much meat.
- I mean, it's a great burger.
This person, they know what they're doing.
They definitely know what they're doing.
- This needs to be simplified in my head
like it needs to be trimmed back.
It's just a burger.
Don't overdo it.
Don't have too many toppings.
- I personally find like raw onions and pickles
to be very overwhelming flavors.
- I've been told this person
likes to dip the burger in the ketchup
which I'm like, smart.
- This person knows what they're doing with burger orders.
They know ketchup on the burger equals soggy
so I like that they use it as a dip
and as an American, I love dips
even though ketchup is not really a dip,
it's more of a sauce but that's fine.
- I have to say the ketchup technique,
one extra point in my brain 'cause that's good.
- Great way of doing it.
- That's a bit of a game changer for me.
The ketchup with the cheesiness and the fries, fire.
- The cheese and the ketchup is like a match made in heaven.
Last but not least, the shake.
- Caramel.
I don't taste caramel anywhere in this.
- It's nice.
Not as good as my shake I have to admit.
- It doesn't work.
It's too sweet.
Out of 10, I would give this a 7.5.
- I would give this order a seven.
- I give this order a seven out of 10.
- So my order is the Chicken Shack Burger.
So you're gonna have the sliced cheese in there,
the cherry peppers and the sliced onion
'cause I just love that kind of extra oomph
to the burger that it adds and obviously the cheesy fries.
If you're getting plain fries, don't talk to me.
I've got the extra herb mayo on the side
'cause it's just super potent and garlicky which I love
and then obviously
you've gotta get the cookies and cream shake
because that is what it's all about.
No other shake will beat that, never.
- This is the chicken burger.
Oh wow.
I've never had the chicken burger from there.
I do love a chicken burger though.
- Oh, don't tell me this is a Oreo milkshake.
Same old ****, different day.
- This person is obviously after my own heart
because I love a dip.
- So I see we've got some beautiful fried chicken, cheese
and my cherry peppers.
Good job.
- Extra mayo with chicken burger always goes down well
because they never give you enough mayo, you know?
They're stingy with the mayo.
They're like where you need to be.
That's what you need, not.
Oh, she thick.
Ah.
- The flavors are spot on.
It's a little bit dry if I'm honest with you.
- I don't know why
but for some reason, this amount of flavors
feels like it would work with a beef burger
but this just doesn't feel
like it's working with the chicken burger.
- I knew that because their beef patty meat is quite good,
I knew their chicken meat would be good
so I'm not disappointed with their chicken meat.
I'm actually rather pleased.
- Let's see if including this dip with the fries
can save this person's order.
- So it's like a garlicky mayo or garlicky herby thing.
- You know what, I learned something here today
with the garlic aioli, with the chicken.
Maybe sometimes you don't just stick to the norm
and be a sheep and follow everyone else and get beef.
Maybe sometimes you get chicken.
- To me, this order's not it.
- So 'cause this one had a bit more complex flavors,
I would say I'm gonna give this a seven out of 10.
- I feel bad
but I think this order is getting a four out of 10.
- I give this order an eight.
- So my order is a Single Burger, no pickles.
Add the Shake Shack Sauce.
On the side, cheese fries with extra sauce as well.
That is a must.
I also get six piece chicken nuggets on the side.
I love chicken nuggets so if there's nuggets on the menu,
I'm getting them and for a shake,
it's the half vanilla, half chocolate half and half shake.
- That's a lot.
- What is this?
- I'm seeing good things here.
- Oh, like nuggets.
A chicken nugget.
- This is making me a happy man.
I'm seeing a bit of cheese.
The Shake Shack Sauce.
Look, if I shake it, I'm shaking the Shack Sauce.
- The initial bite is good
because you get the nice beef patty with the sauce
but then the bacon comes and goes bang,
here's all the salt that you need, your daily allowance.
- Some of their like Shake Shack Sauce in there
which is good.
I think it needs a bit more.
One thing that's great about it
is that it's the perfect size like it's sizeable
I can buy into it easily which is great.
- Only thing missing is a bit of acidity.
Get some pickles in there.
I need that acidity to cut through that bit of that fat.
- Pickle.
- I didn't know Shake Shack did like little chicken bits.
- I don't know, they're not uniform.
Someone just went in the kitchen
and just chopped up the chicken bits
and just chucked them in there.
- I think I'm falling in love
like this is love at first bite truly.
- You know what?
Hold on, I may have something here.
The nugget in the Shake Shack Sauce.
Now, now we're talking.
I'm a genius.
- And let's just have a little cheeky sip of the milkshake.
Obviously, you've gotta try this.
Why does this have like a super
like childhood nostalgic kinda taste to it?
- Flavors wise, it's not, it's quite plain
but I think if you like chocolate milkshake
but you don't want it too chocolatey then this is a safe bet
but not for me.
- Well, cheesy fries, yeah, heck yeah.
Beautiful.
- I'm gonna give this order a 6.5.
- I'm gonna give this order an 8.5.
- I give this order a 7.5.
- So my order is the Shack Burger
with the added pickles for that bit of acidity
just to cut through that fatty beef.
I also get the fries.
With my fries, you know I can't have 'em plain.
I have to have that beautiful melted cheese drizzled on top.
My mouth is actually watering
just talking about my own order.
Finally, you know I have to finish it off
with a bit of that sweetness.
I get a vanilla cookies and cream shake.
As a chef, I know that my order's gonna win.
Simple.
- Oh, this looks so good.
- This burger's thick.
It is so thick.
- We got some bacon in the burger.
Is that peppers, chilies?
- So I'm seeing, oh no.
Pickles.
- I think some onion's missing from this
and a bit of ketchup on the side or even in the burger.
- I'm hoping that the million other toppings on this
hide the pickle flavor but sorry, pickles are not my jam.
- Ah, will this fit in my mouth?
Ooh, we'll see.
- It was a juicy bite like I bit and it was just like.
- Ooh.
Oh, it's quite salty.
- The pickle is very strong
and then you got the peppers as well
and then no sauce to kinda like mix up the flavors.
- The bacon is quite salty and I don't think you need that
with especially the acidity of the pickles.
It's like two super strong flavors kinda clashing.
- I think there's genuinely enough other flavors in here
that the pickles haven't overwhelmed my taste buds too much.
Normally, I can taste a pickle through anything
but I haven't so far which is great.
- Like listen, cheesy fries.
I know I'm gonna like this.
- Mm.
Oh wow.
- Perfection.
Has the shake and the shack and that's what we want.
- It looks great like it looks like it's gonna be exciting
but is it?
- To me, it's missing dips and it has pickles
so I'm gonna give it an eight
but that is a really strong, this is a strong order.
- I would give this order a six out of 10.
- I would rate this order an eight out of 10.
- Oh.
I am 0% surprised that my order won.
It has the best of everything.
It has a bit of the whole menu wrapped in
and I'm glad that I was able to open everyone's minds
into what the best possible order could be.
- No, that's not right.
I mean, I'm a bit shocked.
- Always trust the American when it comes to burgers.
What can I say?
(calm music)