What is it? You buy yourself a robot girlfriend? I don't need
a robot girlfriend cause 20 years from now I guarantee you I will be Carly's second husband
Carly Shay and Freddie Benson have quite an interesting relationship
when the series begins Freddie has an incredibly one-sided attraction to Carly but Carly makes it
abundantly clear that she'd rather they just stay friends I thought we talked about this we can be
buds but you got to get over this crush thing I am over it seriously I'm in love with you you just
want to be friends and I'm totally cool living with that constant pain that is until Freddie
starts showing affection for other girls it's then that we see just how possessive Carly can
be when it comes to Freddie and his feelings for her despite the obvious tension between the two
Carly and Freddie only dated in one episode but now that we have the iCarly revival series there's
definitely potential for more than just friendship the only remaining questions are when will it
happen how will it happen and can they have a stable relationship can friendship cloud the
feelings of Carly and Freddie well let's take a look back and Jaynalysize Creddie's compatibility
there's not enough people with originality so here i am to save the day Jayniac
I have as much of a right to Freddie as you. You do not Freddie loves me
always remember it's not your fault this has been coming a long time
and just because Sam and I are splitting up it doesn't mean I love you any less
now Carly has never been a character that shies away from expressing herself in her core group of
friends she acts as the glue that holds everyone together what keeps Carly so level-headed among
her chaotic peers is her empathy no matter how horrible a situation might be Carly tries to give
everyone the benefit of a doubt which is exactly why most of our relationships don't go very well
are you calling me shallow no I'm calling you consistent think back on all the guys you've dated
over the years gorgeous dum-dums himbos pretty in the face empty in la cabeza pretty much all
of Carly's romantic interests were based solely on physical appearance if he's cute she wants him but
none of them last very long some get dumped for not being as cool as she thought and others just
flat out disappear and then there's Freddie easily the most consistent guy in Carly's life his first
appearance firmly establishes that he has a crush on her and that she doesn't reciprocate but why
why doesn't Carly like Freddie she clearly had no problem taking advantage of his crush on her and
she also had no problem joining Sam in humiliating him on iCarly.com so is it possible that rather
than Carly just not finding Freddie attractive she honestly and truthfully just sees him as a friend
and nothing more well this would make sense until you realize that anytime Freddie starts dating a
new girl Carly behaves a bit differently around him the biggest exception to this being when
Freddie dates Sam so obviously Carly does feel something for Freddie she just doesn't completely
embrace those feelings that is until I saved your life where Freddie pushes Carly out of the way of
a taco truck leaving Carly unscathed and Freddie completely injured it's not long after this that
Carly and Freddie officially start dating but it doesn't go very far Sam tells Freddie that
Carly's only interested in him because he saved her life and instead of taking advantage of Carly
Freddie breaks it off telling her that if she still likes him after the whole hero thing wears
off he'd be psyched about it something worth noting is in the extended cut of the episode
yes that totally exists this happens you look so cute in your cast yeah well I was thinking
maybe you two already have plans yep we do it's interesting because she's never
been this way with any other guy fast forward to the series finale and we get this exchange
I'm leaving in a few minutes you don't have to take all your tech stuff home tonight
I figure the sooner I get all this equipment out of here the sooner I can take it down
and then the show ends until 2021's revival where Creddie is teased quite a bit
most notably in the episode I got your back where after accidentally booking a honeymoon suite
Carly describes Freddie as her platonic best friend with whom she has a complicated romantic
history which points to the biggest problem so far the two have never openly discussed their feelings
left over from the previous series I don't think Carly ever truly accepted her feelings for Freddie
she kind of just went to Italy and forgot about the whole thing all that really needs to happen
is well one of them needs to speak up and initiate that conversation after that I
think Carly's only real struggle might be her jealousy sure Carly seems to be close friends
with Freddie's ex-wife Gwen but we don't know anything about his other ex-wife maybe instead
of pretending to be enemies like she did with Gwen Carly genuinely dislikes Freddie's other ex-wife
if you want to add some drama we could even have his other ex-wife resurface while Carly and
Freddie are dating I'm kind of worried it's not like getting to skip two classes in a row I know
is it too late for you to love me what nothing
did you just say no
and on the flip side we have Freddie, Freddie, Freddie, Freddie ever since the sixth grade
he's wanted Carly to be his girlfriend why he wants her to date him is never made clear though
he just does Freddie do you believe in love at first sight yes I do I always did I mean
that Sam likes your friend Jonah oh maybe it's because of the kindness she shows him
that he probably doesn't really get from anyone else since Carly always rejects him peacefully
perhaps Freddie doesn't see it as rejection at all just a waiting period it also doesn't
help that his mother definitely knows about his crush on Carly yeah Freddie and I are just buds
i totally understand thank you why won't you love my son I'm sorry this leads me to believe
that any feelings Freddie has for Carly are also being reinforced by his mother since Freddie's
so obedient he always sees Carly as a potential love interest the only time this may not be true
is when he's dating Sam but it's interesting that after breaking up with Sam in I love you
Freddie randomly asks Carly if it's too late for her to love him in the episode iOpen a
restaurant this is just 8 episodes later 9 if you count the blooper episode so was Freddie secretly
holding on to his feelings for Carly even while he was dating Sam I mean when you think about it
Carly played a big role in keeping Sam and Freddie together suppose for a second that Freddie's
willingness to tolerate Sam had something to do with his love for Carly because Carly tells him
she thinks he and Sam should date Freddie goes along with it that would definitely put a spin
on the two's relationship huh anyway freddy is always self-sacrificing whenever it comes to Carly
which is why he always gets jealous over the guys she dates but in the revival series Freddie's been
through a lot a failed startup two divorces losing his life savings to a multi-level marketing scheme
Freddie's seen better days he's lost a lot of his confidence and revived a few of his insecurities
does this sound like a guy who's ready to start dating the love of his life
yeah no but for the sake of drama you could take this relationship in a unique direction suppose
Carly and Freddie do start dating they reflect on their childhood and they finally talk about that
last kiss instead of ignoring it things are fine and dandy until Freddie realizes that even though
he's finally dating Carly he's still not happy his new relationship doesn't suddenly solve the pain
he previously experienced Carly can try to get him back on his feet but Freddie learns that he needs
to face his demons himself ultimately resulting in better characterization for Freddie instead of
just being everyone's punching bag please do you really think I'd stage a fake wedding ask Freddie
to be my best man to make sure you'd be here even though I can't stand him and never could hey
though i think Freddie could do better than Carly but it seems to be the direction we're heading in
so if Creddie does happen I just hope they don't wait until the last minute to make it official
develop them properly and don't just make their relationship boring give them drama give them
hardships give them the things required to make not just dialogue but characters
making this video I really didn't think much of Carly and Freddie in a relationship I kind of
just thought they'd be well boring but yet again after making the video I strongly believe that
Creddie was not only going to happen but has potential to be something special and let's
face it this is one of the most interesting things that could happen in the new show
I just hope they handle it well season 1 of the new iCarly series ended with a cliffhanger where
Carly has to decide between her new boyfriend Wes and her new ex-boyfriend Beau but come on you just
want to see Freddie and Carly get together right get these jokers out of the way man
speaking of jokers be sure to follow me on my social medias but especially twitch if you want
to see me live stream while you're at it be sure to follow the Jr. & Marcus Talk Podcast where we
talk about movies TV shows and whatever you want us to talk about if you're already subscribed to
this channel please subscribe to my backup channel Jayniac Jr. in case anything bad happens to this
one and finally please check out the merchandise every single purchase supports this channel a
tremendous thank you to everyone who's been following me this long on like everything i really
do appreciate your support I know this is the part where most people stop watching but i still
wanted to say something for those of you that do so I'm letting you know right now that next week's
episode is going to have a special gift at the end stay tuned until then I'll leave you with this
Are you ready Kevin? What are you guys thinking for dinner
tonight? How about my world famous chili con carne