Peter Weber's time as The Bachelor kicked off with an unexpected twist.
While fans were aware that former Bachelorette Hannah Brown, who dated Peter on her season,
was set to return at some point, viewers had no idea how intense the situation would become
when she showed up on the season premiere.
The star of the show was shocked when Hannah stepped out of the final limo and told him
that she had "mixed emotions" when she found out he would be the Bachelor.
She then returned the pilot wings Peter had given her on her season of The Bachelorette,
and wished him well.
But Hannah popped up again later, to the shock of both contestants and viewers.
Making an appearance during the second group date, Hannah decided to retell the infamous
windmill story involving her fantasy suite with Peter, and proudly admitted, yet again,
that they slept together four times that night.
A bit later, a confused Hannah began reflecting on her past choices and seemed to regret that
she hadn't ended up with Peter.
She privately told him,
"My heart was very confused...I don't know what the f--- I was doing.
I don't know...I question what I should have done.
You know, I question a lot."
Peter was willing to listen, but told her he didn't want to be someone's "third option."
Hannah chose both Tyler and Jed over Peter, ultimately getting engaged to Jed.
However, Hannah quickly broke things off with Jed when she realized that he'd had a girlfriend
back home when he came on The Bachelorette.
Peter also revealed that he was hurt when Hannah asked Tyler for a date after splitting
from Jed, and wondered if it had occurred to her to reconnect with him instead.
Hannah responded,
"[Tyler] was reaching out, you didn't say anything...I didn't know if you just wanted
to get past it.
I mean, I thought you wanted to be the Bachelor."
Things aren't necessarily over between Peter and Hannah, and it turns out that he's willing
to give her another chance.
He went on to say,
"This is so insane.
What would you say if I asked you to, like, come and be part of the house?"
And Hannah responded,
"I mean, maybe."
Peter, always one to be open about his feelings, confessed he wanted Hannah to enter the Bachelor
mansion as soon as she stepped out of the limo on the first night.
However, he added,
"I'm so confused...I look at her and I just don't want to stop looking at her, and I want
to just kiss her...And I feel like such a jerk because I have such an awesome group
of girls here expecting to meet someone that was truly ready to have this work for them
as well and I don't know."
The unprecedented situation left many viewers just as shocked as the contestants, and reactions
among fans were mixed, to say the least.
Plenty of people support Hannah, with one viewer tweeting,
"I'll forever be team [Hannah B].
I appreciate her authenticity and vulnerability.
Way to stay true even through the difficult times."
Some fans are ready for the pair to give love another chance, with one tweeting,
"Hannah Brown I sure hope u end up with Peter Weber in the end u can both see the love in
your eyes he still has feelings for u [and] that's amazing true love."
Others aren't so keen on the whole reunion idea.
One person bluntly tweeted,
"Go home Hannah B."
As for Hannah, she didn't give away any spoilers, but she did take to Twitter after the emotional
episode, saying,
"So that was not a blast at all.
It was truly the hardest day, a day I was not looking forward to reliving."
That doesn't seem to hint at a happily-ever-after, but maybe she's just trying to throw viewers
off the trail.
Even though there have already been plenty of spoilers and leaks, Peter has said that
there's still no way anyone will figure out what happens in the end.
"You got a girlfriend?"
"You gotta tune in and find out."
Check out one of our newest videos right here!
Plus, even more List videos about your favorite stuff are coming soon.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel and hit the bell so you don't miss a single one.