hi welcome!
today I wanted to share with you guys another hypothetical, so the
last time I did this was with somi and why she should have debuted with Itzy
and you can check that out in the card above if I remembered, but instead today
we're gonna talk about why Miyeon from G Idle should have debuted with blackpink
but also why she's better off with G Idle, but that proved to be a very long
and complicated title, so for those who don't know Miyeon from g idle was a
trainee at YG entertainment and she was part of the original line of blackpink
so yes blackpink was supposed to be 5 members however she left for
unknown reasons though legend has it that you can still see her within their
choreography, I will mention that we have not ruled out the possibility of
infinite blackpink members so I definitely think there would have been
some advantages had she stayed in blackpink but of course I definitely also
agree that she is better off with G Idle so we will be discussing both
facets of this argument, of this- it's not an argument, of this hypothetical problem
it's not a problem- of this hypothetical question so let's do that actually I'm
gonna stop you right there to remind you to subscribe to this channel, click the
bell to be notified and you can also do little things here and there to help
sustain this channel like asking me why I pronounce the Rosé they like that or
sharing my videos with people that you can hate them with, so the first
advantage we would see is that their choreographies would be so much better
because blackpink is a 3rd gen girl group and refused to have one member cut
off from the choreography to have their part shine like 2NE1 would have, I know I'm
sorry it's really hard to not bring up our lord and saviors in every video
back to topic and so we often see that these groups who have even number of
members tend to cover one member to center another one
the choreography was just a lot different back then so it didn't really
happen as much as it does now, now for groups like G Idle, who are an even
number of members you see one member covered constantly, gfriend you see one
member covered and blackpink is no exception with them being four members
so had she stayed in the group this would have eradicated that problem, and
they would have been more balanced choreography wise
and we wouldn't have so many videos of delusional fans hypothesizing what
blackpink would be like if three members, so another advantage that we
would see how she debuted with blackpink would be that we would have a more
distinguished group from 2NE1, I mean obviously at the end of the day yg
himself has admitted that he made no effort to distinguish blackpink from 2NE1
and that he wanted a pretty version of 2NE1
okay cool bro we all get it, but at least if blackpink were a five-member girl
group, it would have changed their dynamics ever so slightly and I think it
would have lessened a little bit of the comparisons, I mean I sure as hell still
would have compared them but it might have helped their case with blind 2nd
gen stans, I said what I said and I said it with my whole chest, so now we're gonna
move on to the disadvantages had she stayed in the group and the first one
would be that her position would be redundant
I find that each member as of now brings something pretty unique to the table
I find that her personality and just her position in the group it would be way
too similar to Jisoo and my opinion their energies onstage are quite similar
and then I find them to have a same type of voice so obviously they don't sound the
same but they have a similar type of stability within their voices rather
than a more emotional type of voice like Rosé and in my opinion they're also
both kind of considered visuals of the group which i think is a trend in kpop
that should die, but I digress I just feel that her position would be a little
bit unnecessary and of course this is based a lot off of the fact that I know
what blackpink are like right now and I understand their dynamic now but
obviously there's a huge possibility that she would have blended super well into
the group and I wouldn't have felt this way, so the next thing we're gonna talk
about I don't know if it's an advantage or a disadvantage so definitely let me
know in the comments down below what you think, so in some ways I feel like she
would have been out shined by other members but in other ways I feel like
she would have added some balance to the group if that makes sense I find that Jisoo
is often put in the back of the choreography, she is the member that is
hidden the most times in the choreography so I don't know how that
would have worked out obviously no one would really be hidden but I wonder how
they would have competed for the spotlight if that makes sense it could
go either way either would have balance out the group or maybe those who would
have proverbially be put in a corner, but I definitely
would love to know your thoughts in the comments down below so the comment
shout-out goes to this lovely individual yes Kevin without fail is always at the
end of my videos saluting you aggressively, my mom loves it when you
guys mentioned Kevin so keep it up and I love when you guys mention parrots or make
memes about me so keep that up as well that's basically all I had to say for
this video don't forget to subscribe to this channel and click that bell to be
notified and you can also follow me on a swag hump so yeah I will see you guys
next time bye