November 1965 saw one of the most widespread power outages in North American history. On
the freezing cold evening of the 9th, the grid was operating at maximum capacity as people
tried to stay warm when a misconfigured relay tripped a breaker on a key transmission line.
The loss of that single line cascaded into a loss of service for over 30 million people in
the northeast US plus parts of Ontario in Canada. Restoring electricity to that many
people is no simple task. In this case, the startup began with a little 12 megawatt gas
generator in Southampton, New York. That’s about the capacity of four wind turbines,
but it was enough to get power plants in Long Island back online which were able to power up
all of New York City, eventually returning service to all those 30 million people.
The grid is a little bit of a house of cards. It’s not necessarily flimsy, but if the whole
thing gets knocked down, you have to rebuild it one card at a time and from the ground
up. Restoring power after a major blackout is one of the most high stakes operations you
can imagine. The consequences of messing it up are enormous, but there’s no way to practice a
real-life scenario. It seems as simple as flipping a switch, but restoring power is more complicated
than you might think. And I built a model power grid here in the studio to show you how
this works. This is my last video in a deep dive series on widespread outages to the power grid,
so go back and check out those other videos if you want to learn more. I’m Grady and this
is Practical Engineering. In today’s episode we’re talking about black starts of the grid.
This video is sponsored by HelloFresh. More on them later.
An ideal grid keeps running indefinitely. Maybe it sustains localized damage from lightning strikes,
vehicle accidents, hurricanes, floods, and wayward squirrels, but the protective devices trigger
circuit breakers to isolate those faults and keep them from disrupting the rest of the system. But,
we know that no grid is perfect, and occasionally the damage lines up just right or the protective
devices behave in unexpected ways that cascade into a widespread outage. I sometimes use the word
blackout kind of freely to refer to any amount of electrical service disruption, but it’s really
meant to describe an event like this: a widespread outage across most or all of an interconnected
area. Lots of engineering, dedicated service from linesworkers, plenty of lessons learned from past
mishaps, and a little bit of good fortune have all meant that we don’t see too many true blackouts
these days, but they still happen, and they’re still a grid operator’s worst nightmare. We
explored the extreme consequences that come from a large-scale blackout in a previous video. With
those consequences in mind, the task of bringing a power grid back online from nothing (called a
black start) is frightfully consequential with significant repercussions if things go wrong.
The main reason why black starts are so complicated is that it takes power
to make power. Most large-scale generating plants - from coal-powered, to gas-powered,
to nuclear - need a fair amount of electricity just to operate. That sounds counterintuitive,
and of course configurations and equipment vary from plant to plant,
but power generating stations are enormous industrial facilities. They have blowers
and scrubbers, precipitators and reactors, compressors, computers, lights, coffee makers,
control panels and pumps (so many pumps): lubrication pumps, fuel pumps, feedwater pumps,
cooling water pumps, and much much more. Most of this equipment is both necessary for the
plant to run and requires electricity. Even the generators themselves need electricity to operate.
I don’t own a grid scale, three-phase generator (yet), but I do have an alternator for a pickup
truck, and they are remarkably similar devices. You probably already know that
moving a conductor through a magnetic field generates a current. This physical phenomenon,
called induction, is the basis for almost all electricity generation on
the grid. Some source of motion we call the prime mover, often a steam-powered turbine,
spins a shaft called a rotor inside a set of coils. But you won’t see a magnet on the rotor
of a grid-scale generator, just like (if you look closely inside the case) you won’t see a
magnet inside my alternator. You just see another winding of copper wire. Turns out
that this physical phenomenon works both ways. If you put a current through a coil of wire,
you get a magnetic field. If that coil is on a rotor, you can spin it like so.
This is my model power plant. I got this idea from a video by Bellingham Technical College,
but their model was a little more sophisticated than mine. Let me give you a tour. On the right
we have the prime mover. Don’t worry about the fact that it’s an electric motor. My model power
plant consumes more energy than it creates, but I didn’t want to build a mini steam turbine just for
this demonstration. The thing that’s important is that the prime mover drives a 3-phase generator,
in my case through this belt. And the generator you already saw is a car alternator that I
“modified” to create an Alternating Current instead of a Direct Current like what’s used
in a vehicle. The alternator is connected to some resistors that simulate loads on the grid.
And I have an oscilloscope hooked up to one of the phases so we can see the AC waveform. Yeah,
all this is so we can just see that sine wave on the oscilloscope. It could have been a couple
of tiny 3-phase motors; It could even have just been a signal generator. But, you guys love these
models so I thought you deserved something slightly grander in scale. There’s a few
other things here too, including a second model power plant, but we’ll get to those in a minute.
The alternator I used in my model has two brushes of graphite that ride along the rotor so that we
can supply current to the coil inside to create an electromagnet. This is called excitation, and it
has a major benefit over using permanent magnets in a generator: it’s adjustable. Let’s power up
the prime mover to see how it works. If there’s no excitation current, there’s no magnetic field,
which means there’s no power. We’re just spinning two inert coils of wire right next to each other.
But watch what happens when I apply some current to the brushes. Now the rotor is excited, and I
have to say, I’m pretty excited too, because I can see that we’re generating power. As I increase the
excitation current, we can see that the voltage across the resistor is higher, so we’re generating
more power. Of course, this additional power doesn’t come for free. It also puts more and
more mechanical load on the prime mover. You can see when I spin the alternator with no excitation
current, it turns freely. But when I increase the current, it becomes more difficult to spin.
Modern power plants adjust the excitation current in a generator to regulate the
voltage of electricity leaving the facility, something that would be much harder to do in a
device that used permanent magnets that don’t need electricity to create a magnetic field.
The power for the excitation system can come from the generator, but,
like the other equipment I mentioned, it can’t start working until the plant is running. In fact,
power plants often use around 5 to 10 percent of all the electricity they generate. That’s why a
black start of a large power plant is often called bootstrapping, because the facility
has to pick itself up by the bootstraps. It needs a significant amount of power both to
start and maintain its own creation of power, and that poses an obvious challenge. You might
be familiar with the standby generators used at hospitals, cell phone towers, city water pumps,
and many other critical facilities where a power outage could have severe consequences.
Lots of people even have small ones for their homes. These generators use diesel or natural
gas for fuel and large banks of batteries to get started. Imagine the standby generator capacity
that would be needed at a major power plant. Five percent of the nearest plant to my house,
even at a quarter of its nameplate capacity, is 18 megawatts. That’s more than 100 of these.
It’s just not feasible to maintain that amount of standby generation capacity at every power
plant. Instead, we designate black start sources that can either spin up without support using
batteries and standby devices or that can remain energized without a connection to the rest of the
grid. Obviously, these blackstart power plants are more expensive to build and maintain, so we only
have so many of them spread across each grid. Their combined capacity can only supply a small
fraction of electricity demands, but we don’t need them for that during a blackout. We just need them
to create enough power so that larger base load plants can spin up. Hydropower plants are often
used as blackstart sources because they only need a little bit of electricity to open the gates and
excite the generators to produce electricity. Some wind turbines and solar plants could be
used as blackstart sources, but most aren’t set up for it because they don’t produce power 24-7.
But, producing enough power to get the bigger plants started is only the first of many hurdles
to restoring service during a blackout. The next step is to get the power to the plants. Luckily,
we have some major extension cords stretched across the landscape. We normally call them
transmission lines, but during a blackout, they are cranking paths. That’s because you can’t
just energize transmission lines with blackstart sources. First those lines have to be isolated
so that you don’t inadvertently try to power up cities along the way. All the substations along
a predetermined cranking path disconnect their transformers to isolate the transmission lines
and create a direct route. Once the blackstart source starts up and energizes the cranking path,
a baseload power plant can draw electricity directly from the line, allowing it to spin up.
One trick to speed up recovery is to blackstart individual islands within the larger grid. That
provides more flexibility and robustness in the process. But it creates a new challenge:
synchronization. Let’s go back to the model to see how this works. I have both generating stations
running now, each powering their own separate grid. This switch will connect the two together.
But you can’t just flip it willy nilly. Take a look at my oscilloscope and it’s easy to see
that these two grids aren’t synchronized. They’re running at slightly different
frequencies. If I just flip the switch when the voltage isn’t equal between the two grids,
there’s a surge in current as the two generators mechanically synchronize. We’re only playing with
a few volts here, so it’s a little hard to see on camera. If I flip the switch when the
two generators are out of sync, they jerk as the magnetic fields equalize their current.
If the difference is big enough, the two generators actually fight against each other,
essentially trying to drive each other like motors. It’s kind of fun with this little model,
but something like this in a real power plant would cause tremendous damage to equipment. So
during a black start, each island, and in fact each individual power plant that comes online,
has to be perfectly synchronized (and this is true outside of black start conditions as well).
I can adjust the speed of my motors to get them spinning at nearly the exact same speed,
then flip the switch when the waveforms match up just right. That prevents the surges of power
between the two systems at the moment they’re connected. You can see that the traces on the
oscilloscope are identical now, showing that our two island grids are interconnected. One
way to check this is to simply connect a light between the same phase on the two
grids. If the light comes on, you know there’s a difference in voltage between them and they
aren’t synchronized. If the light goes off and stays off, there’s no voltage difference,
meaning you’re good to throw the breaker. Older plants were equipped with a synchroscope that
would show both whether the plant was spinning at the same speed as the grid (or faster or
slower) and whether the phase angle was a match. I bought an old one for this video,
but it needs much higher voltages than I’m willing to play with in the studio, so let’s just animate
over the top of it. Operators would manually bring their generators up to speed, making slight
adjustments to match the frequency of the rest of the grid. But matching the speed isn’t enough,
you also have to match the phase, so this was a careful dance. As soon as the synchroscope needle
both stopped moving and was pointing directly up, the operator could close the breaker.
During a black start, utilities can start restoring power to their customers,
slowly matching generation capacity with demand as more and more power
plants come online. Generally, the most critical loads will be
prioritized during the recovery like natural gas infrastructure, communications, hospitals,
and military installations. But even connecting customers adds complexity to restoration.
Some of our most power-hungry appliances only get more hungry the longer they’ve been offline. For
example an outage during the summer means all the buildings are heating up with no access to
air conditioning. When the power does come back on, it’s not just a few air conditioners ready
to run. It’s all of them at once. Add that to refrigerators, furnaces, freezers, and hot water
heaters, and you can imagine the enormous initial demand on the grid after an extended outage. And
don’t forget that many of these appliances use inductive motors that have huge inrush currents.
For example, here’s an ammeter on the motor of my table saw while I start it up. It draws a whopping
28 amps as it gets up to speed before settling down to 4 amps at no load. Imagine the demand from
thousands of motors like this starting all at the exact same instant. The technical term for this is
cold load pickup, and it can be as high as eight to ten times normal electrical demands before
the diversity of loads starts to average out again, usually after about 30 minutes. So, grid
operators have to be very deliberate about how many customers they restore service to at a time.
If you ever see your neighbor a few blocks away getting power before you,
keep in mind this delicate balancing act that operators have to perform in order to
get the grid through the cold load pickup for each new group of customers that go online.
The ability to black start a power grid quickly after a total collapse is so important because
electricity is vital to our health and safety. After the 2003 blackout in the US,
new reliability standards were issued, including one that requires grid operators
to have detailed system restoration plans. That includes maintaining blackstart sources,
even though it’s often incredibly expensive. Some standby equipment mostly just does just that:
stands by. But it still has to be carefully maintained and regularly tested in the rare
case that it gets called into service. Also, the grid is incredibly vulnerable during a blackstart,
and if something goes wrong, breakers can trip and you might have to start all over
again. Utilities have strict security measures to try and ensure that no one could intentionally
disable or frustrate the black start process. Finally, they do detailed analysis to make sure
they can bring their grid up from scratch, including testing and even running drills
to practice the procedures; All this cost and effort and careful engineering just to ensure
that we can get the grid back up and running to power homes and businesses after a major blackout.
Cost and effort are good things to spend on electrical infrastructure,
but I prefer our family dinners to be inexpensive and easy. Between juggling naps, chores,
and activities, it gets hard to fit cooking dinner into the schedule. HelloFresh saves us
time on the crazy weeknights by making cooking simple and quick. Plus it’s just a lot of fun.
“A tomato…”
HelloFresh has a lot of recipes that you can choose from each week, and different plans to help
you meet your goals, try something new, or just keep everyone happy, including family friendly,
fit and wholesome, vegetarian, and a bunch of options for side dishes and upgrades.
“Yeah, really get your thumb in there…”
We’ve been using HelloFresh for more than 3 years, and really, it’s not because of how convenient,
delicious, and healthy the meals are. It’s really just because we enjoy it. HelloFresh
is basically a shortcut to a memorable night in, and the meal at the end is an added bonus.
“Isn’t zesting something just peeling it and not throwing away the peel?”
They have a new offer if you’ve been on the fence about giving it a try. If you
go to HelloFresh dot com and use code PRACTICAL18, you’ll get 18 free meals
plus free shipping. I really think you’ll enjoy it. That’s HelloFresh dot com and
use code PRACTICAL18. Thank you for watching and let me know what you think.