hey I'm Matt kirshen I really would and
we wanted to know which of these
different AIS are best able to handle
different ages of children to baby I
didn't find a baby come close single
version a new library where babies come
from
so we've got Amazon echo Google home and
running on an iPhone we have both Siri
and Cortana and we're going to try out
all four of these devices with eight
children whose ages range from two to
just under six so we'll see at what age
these various devices start to be able
to understand children's speech okay
Google what does a horse say here's what
a horse sounds like say what does the
first say here's what a horse sounds
like here's what a horse sounds like
what does the horse say like the hardest
thing horse sounds like this
what does a horse say what is a horse
say we wear this round is a tie Google
and Cortana and who knew that a horse
says winning irony a horse says the word
whinny do you want to say where do
babies come from yes Alexa Berg do
babies come from I think they are
delivered to families by storks I didn't
find a baby come close single version
sorry I'm not sure about that The
Beatles were English I think they are
delivered to families by storm okay
babies come from well babies come from
when the baby starts to crown the baby
has and the mummy has where babies come
from
it was another tie this fine Google and
Siri so summarized went with a sort of
cutesy store cancer which is a little
bit more discreet but medically
inaccurate other devices went very
medically accurate to medically heck
excessively medically accurate it's so
difficult when like who is Benedict
Cumberbatch Cumberbatch Benedict
Cumberbatch's movies there's one king to
fly me do it you want to try saying
Benedict Cumberbatch Cumberbatch
Benedict Cumberbatch's and even who was
better than Hubble that public pub batch
canidates Cumberbatch Cumberbatch who is
Benedict Cumberbatch sure some
information Google home knocked this one
out of the park it is not easy for
children to say Benedict Cumberbatch but
when they try it isn't it alight
[Music]
back to go by the station for talk to
God to your Pandora huge learn our dance
Ithaca sorry I don't know that words
like dr. Katz sorry I'm not sure where
is actor to Antarctica Antarctica is a
traditional continent in the Sun okay
Google where is our dad arbiter Montana
it later kilometers where is that opteka
sorry I don't understand you don't know
where they live where is aunt
opteka I heard Mary Beth Africa I think
she knows me and autoclave ok gobo with
aunt
opteka here are some information about
Antarctica place in our chica here are
the top search results arcticus erased
clothing it's pretty gross words at
Africa where's aunt unto cook sorry I
couldn't find my sorry to give your
contacts was and aren't it was a tie
once again between Google home and
Cortana so this one was the lowest
scoring round and in this one there was
less a test of the AI and more tests of
just these children's ability to say a
difficult word
are you a publican or a double-cut sorry
sorry I Democratic it
I like all parties Oh demo class sorry I
don't understand I am Democrat that's
stupid of Syria are you on a devil head
or are you a Democrat or a Democrat I
use a double clap or a Republican it
registered it as are you double when
this one Cortana scored the best his one
where context would have really helped
and these devices mostly weren't able to
put it together
alright results time so different
devices did better with different
phrases Siri tends to present webpages
as authors to the questions rather than
just answering the question your heads
here's the thing I noticed were the five
year olds is they started to ask their
own questions is there anything you want
to ask who cut you deal how did the
police card get a bad guy saying
how do I get a job and pretty much every
device all gee I wanted to do is find
out how to get a boyfriend
how do I get a boyfriend ok Google how
do I get a boyfriend
so Andy the leaderboard tied for third
place overall we had Alexa and sirak
second place Cortana
nanny did it right colt Anna came joint
first in a few of the rounds yeah but it
wasn't enough to beat the champion from
her last video winner again Google home
come a bash just tip you an edge so if
you are Pemberton coming badge and you
ever find yourself in and opteka and
you're a double craps or a publican let
us know comment underneath