>> So as soon as they did
all that damage to my car,
I took my son
to my friend's house.
So the officer,
when he first got the there,
he only spoke with her.
And then they called me
and told me.
>> Judge Judy: I know that.
The only person that they talked
to was her.
Then later,
they came and spoke to you.
>> Yeah.
So maybe he assumed that...
>> Judge Judy: Shh. I don't
what he assumed.
That's what he wrote.
>> Oh, okay.
>> Judge Judy: So at no time
did you,
you, tell the police
that it was Ms. Brown
that damaged your car.
>> Yes. I did.
>> Judge Judy: I want you
to show me that
in the police report.
You have it.
because the only way
that she was identified
was the police
brought back photos to her...
>> Yeah.
>> Judge Judy:
...and showed you a photo ID.
Is that correct?
>> Yes.
>> I'm not saying
they didn't do it.
I'm going to figure
out the story.
Show me in the police report
where it says you said
that these two people
damaged your car.
>> It's not in
the police report.
>> Judge Judy: It's not in Judye
report is clear.
It said, "She identified
the person from a photo array."
>> She told the officer
who it was.
And he said,
"If I bring back a lineup,
can you pick her out?"
And she said yes because we only
met them at a camping trip once.
>> Judge Judy: I'm asking you...
>> I wasn't at the camping trip.
>> You came and picked her up.
>> Judge Judy: ...where in
here... Listen to me.
>> You never met my mom.
>> Judge Judy:
I'm asking you where you...
Because it looks to me
as if you left the house.
>> You weren't there
when I picked her up.
>> As soon as it happened,
I took my son away.
I did.
>> Judge Judy:
As soon as the assault was over,
or as soon as
the vandalizing was over?
>> Announcer: As soon
as the vandalism was done.
>> Judge Judy: Was over.
Okay.
But you didn't take your son
after the assault was over?
>> I never touched her daughter,
and me
and my son went back to sleep.
So...
>> Judge Judy:
I don't believe you.
I don't believe you at all.
>> I think that's a lie.
>> Judge Judy: I don't believe
you at all.
And I absolutely believe
that you vandalized their car,
absolutely, positively.
>> I never touched her daughter.
>> Judge Judy: Then you keep
very, very poor company
because if somebody came to
a house
looking for a fight,
and came in and said to me
with my baby son there,
"Some people came to fight me,"
which is what you want me
to believe...
And she ran outside.
And you leave your baby in
the house
and go outside and put
your braces on and go outside.
And there are guys
in the house,
her boyfriend, your boyfriend.
There were are a whole bunch
of people there.
So you don't have
to get involved,
but you're getting in
between a fight.
And it would be very easy
for Ms. Brown to say
that she punched her, very easy.
Did you ever make
an accusation...
What's your last name?
>> Gulley.
>> Judge Judy: Ms. Gulley
assaulted you?
>> They both did.
>> The police report...
>> Judge Judy: Just a second.
You made an accusation
that they both did?
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy:
Were you ever arrested?
>> No.
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
Fine.
>> She told the police
only Maliah hit her.
>> Judge Judy: Well, there's no
question
that you were assaulted.
I think you were having a fight
with your boyfriend.
And I think that
they got in your face.
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy: That's what
I think happened.
And you got hurt.
>> Your Honor, only
I got in her...
>> Judge Judy: Hey.
And most people who are normal
people want the person
who hurt them to be punished,
not the wrong person,
the right person.
So she could just as easily
have sued you.
She didn't.
She said that she was arguing,
but she said
she sucker-punched her.
>> Your Honor, that's not true.
>> I wasn't near her.
>> She jumped in it.
Gulley jumped in it.
>> You weren't there.
I was nowhere near her daughter.
>> Judge Judy:
And you weren't there.
There's no question that between
the two of you, she was injured.
Neither one of you were injured.
>> Yeah.
We got into a physical fight.
>> Judge Judy:
Neither one of you were injured.
>> Maliah jumped in
and was calling me...
>> I never hit your daughter.
So stop lying.
>> Your Honor, I didn't jump in
because Jasmine is handicapped.
So me...
>> You know I wasn't near you.
You know I never hit you.
>> Byrd: Miss, miss.
>> Even my...
>> Judge Judy: Just a second.
I'm done.
>> Okay.
>> Judge Judy: I'm done.
I absolutely believe
that your car was vandalized.
And I absolutely believe
that they vandalized your car.
And based upon the damage
to the car, it's at least $5,000
worth of damage to your car.
I absolutely believe
you were assaulted.
I absolutely believe that she
was partially responsible
for the assault,
and you were injured
and the medical reports suggests
that you had a swollen eye and
a broken cartilage in your nose,
for which I'm awarding you
$5,000,
which means that neither
one of you get anything.
Goodbye.