"Fasting to Treat Depression"
For over a century, fasting has been espoused as a treatment
of supposed “great utility in the preservation of health,”
especially rejuvenating the body, but above all the mind.
But fast people even just 18 hours, and they get all hungry and irritable.
After one or two days positive mood goes down, negative mood goes up,
and by 72 hours people can feel sad, self-blaming,
and suffer a loss in libido.
But then something strange starts to happen.
After a few days, people experience a “fasting-induced mood enhancement…
decreased anxiety, depression, fatigue, and improved vigor.”
And that’s what studies tend to show across the board.
Once you get over the hump, fasters frequently experience
“an increased level of vigilance and… mood improvement,
a subjective feeling of well-being, and sometimes [even] euphoria.”
And no wonder, as by then your endorphin levels
may shoot up nearly 50 percent.
This enhancement of mood, alertness, and calm
makes a certain amount of evolutionary sense.
Yeah, your body wants you to feel crappy initially
so you continue eating day to day when food is available,
but if you go a couple days without food your body realizes
it can’t have you moping back in the cave—you’ve got to
get motivated to get out there and find some calories.
So, can fasting be used for mood disorders like depression?
Yeah, it’s great that you can get people to feel better
after a few days of fasting, but the critical question
revolves around “the persistence of mood improvement over time”
once you start eating again.
You don’t know until... you put it to the test.
Interestingly, the little published evidence we have comes out of
Japan and the former Soviet Union, and some of it is just ridiculous.
Like this study, which included women with a variety of symptoms,
which the researchers blame mostly on marital conflict.
Oh, husband not treating you right?
How about a little electroshock therapy?
That didn’t seem to help much, though, so what about hunger therapy?
Of course, starving those women made them hungry,
but that’s what Thorazine is for.
If you keep injecting them with an antipsychotic to calm them down,
they can sail right through.
So, what happened? Who cares what happened?
What would we even do with those results?
But this other study skipped the Thorazine.
Ten days of fasting, but they also kept them in bed all day
completely isolated, with no contact with the outside world.
So, if people got better or worse it would be impossible
to tease out the effects of just the fasting component.
But they did apparently get better with efficacy supposedly
demonstrated in 31 out of 36 patients suffering from depression.
They conclude that fasting therapy may provide an alternative
to the use of antidepressant drugs,
considering it “a kind of shock therapy.”
People are so relieved to just be eating again,
to get out of solitary confinement,
to even just get out of bed they report feeling better.
Yeah, but that was at the time of discharge.
How did they feel the next day, the next week, the next month?
Fasting is by definition unsustainable, so ideally what we want to see
are some kind of longer-lasting effects.
So, what the researchers did was follow-up with a few hundred patients,
not just a few months later but a few years later.
Of the 69 who were evidently suffering from depression,
90 percent reported feeling good or excellent results
at the end of the 10-day fast and remarkably, years later
87 percent of the 62 that replied claimed that they were still doing good.
Now there was no control group, so we don’t know
if they would have done just as well or better without the fast,
and it was just self-reports, so maybe there was response bias
where you try to please the researchers, or maybe they were afraid
otherwise they’d get sent back to the hole.
We have no idea, but we do have good evidence
for the short-term mood benefits. The question is why.
In addition to the endorphins when you fast and the surge in serotonin,
the so-called happiness hormone, there is a bump in BDNF,
brain-derived neurotrophic factor,
considered to play a crucial role in mood disorders.
And it’s not just because you perk up rodents with it.
Humans with major depression have lower levels
circulating in their blood stream.
Autopsy studies of suicide victims show only about half the BDNF
in certain key brain regions compared to controls,
suggesting it may play an important role in suicidal behavior.
You can boost BDNF with antidepressant drugs
and electroshock,or with calorie restriction—a 70 percent boost
in levels after three months cutting 25 percent of calories out of their daily diet.
But is there anything we can add to our diets to boost BDNF levels
so we can get the benefits without the hunger? We’ll find out next.