on june 9th a year to the day where tyler ryan and jj valo were found on chad dabo's property
chad had a hearing where he was to be in front of the judge and actually plead guilty or not
guilty he had eight charges against him now he did plead not guilty but today i thought we would do
something a little bit different something that i haven't done in a little while and we're going to
focus actually on chad dabell and his responses to the judge i found a few interesting little
tidbits that i think you would be interested in now before we get started it's notable that we saw
k woodcock in court kobe ryan we also saw natalie palowski who is ian palowski's ex-wife also behind
chad sat three of his children garth emma and seth so the judge reads out the charges to chad
and the potential penalties of the eight counts which included conspiracy to commit first-degree
murder and first-degree murder in the death of tyler ryan j.j valo and tammy dabell there was
also grand theft of deception for the death of tyler and jj and also insurance fraud of the life
insurance policies for tammy debell and in court chad responds to the understanding of each charge
to the judge and as i mentioned there are little nuances in the way he responds to each charge it's
small but there are differences so let's take a look now first he's going to respond to the charge
regarding to tiley ryan and he seems distracted at first with john pryor you
know flipping through pages that kind of thing but as soon as the judge mentions tyler ryan's name
you'll see him focus right in on the judge the indictment that was filed on may 25th
in count one charges mr daybel the offenses of conspiracy to commit first degree murder
and grand theft by deception both felony counts under idaho code 18 1701 18 4003 a 18 1824031
1824034a 1820 407 1b3 the count in count one names tiley ryan as the victim on the murder charge
and that count carries a penalty on the murder charge of it is punishable by death
or imprisonment for life and it provides that if the death penalty is not pursued by the state then
the court shall impose a life sentence with a minimum period of incarceration of 10 years
at the moment the judge mentions grand theft you can see chad's kind of squint his eyes the grand
theft portion of that charge has a penalty of up to 14 years of prison and a fine of up to
five thousand dollars and possible restitution now he seems also to swallow pretty hard in this
next clip and some nose twitching and that kind of thing but what caught my eye is at the point where
he says he understands the charges and it's very very subtle and i have said this before about chad
that i wonder if it's duper's delight or duping delight
there's something there so we'll take a look and i'll have another point to show you later
on in this video and it also relates to tyler that's a summary of those charges
and you've waived the reading of the charges so let me ask you on that count one mr davao
do you understand the charge and those possible penalties yes i do your honor okay
the next count in the indictment is count two that is a count of first degree murder
under idaho code 18 800 thousand 18 eighteen four thousand two eighteen four thousand three
subsection a and eighteen four thousand four and that count names tiley ryan as the victim
the possible penalty or punishment for that count is by death or imprisonment for life and if the
death penalty is not pursued then the court shall impose a life sentence with a minimum period of
incarceration of 10 years do you understand that charge and the possible penalties yes your honor
next is the charges related to jj and if you look closely chad is actually a little bit different in
the way he responds to this as opposed to when he was uh responding to tiley he's a
little distracted still again but he does look down a couple times you'll see him
and after that he says he understands the charges which you'll see in a minute
but his mouth is a little different this time count three of the indictment charges conspiracy
to commit first degree murder and grand theft by deception those are felonies under the same
code sites that were previously listed under count one that count names joshua jackson valo
also known as jj valo as the named victim in that count and the penalty for those charges
on the conspiracy to commit first-degree murder is punishable by death or imprisonment for life
and if the death penalty is not pursued then the court shall impose a life sentence with a
minimum period of incarceration of 10 years on the charge of grand theft by deception that would have
a penalty of up to 14 years in prison and a fine of up to five thousand dollars do you understand
the charge in count three and those possible penalties mister day bell yes your honor very well
count four of the indictment charges you with first degree murder
a felony under this statute previously cited in the other counts also that count names j.j valo
as the victim and again is punishable by death or imprisonment for life if the death penalty is
not pursued then the court shall impose a life sentence with a minimum period of incarceration
of up to 10 years do you understand count four and the possible penalties mr daybell yes your honor
i don't see the dupers like i did see with tyler and it seems almost like he
possibly feels different when it comes to jj and tyler just based on the differences here this is
just an observation in my opinion now there's also a hard swallow as well like we saw when the judge
was talking about tiley and reading those charges next up is tammy dabell now at the beginning of
the charges when the judge was reading you'll see chad lift up his chin and take a deep breath
there's also yet another hard swallow and then chad does something with his mouth now it comes
across as though something is bothering him he actually does it twice and you'll see him
say you know yes your honor that kind of thing and then he moves his mouth like that take a
look he actually does it twice all right the next count listed in the indictment is count
five conspiracy to commit first degree murder that count names tamara tammy dabell
as the named victim it's charged again under idaho code 18 4001 18 4003 subsection a and 18
1701 and that count is also punishable by death or imprisonment for life and if the death penalty is
not pursued then the court shall impose a life sentence with a minimum period of incarceration
of 10 years do you understand the charge and count five in the possible penalties yes your honor
count six of the indictment is a charge of first degree murder that names camera tammy
dabel is the victim it's charged under idaho code 18 4001 18204 and 18 4003 subsection a
that count also is punishable by death or imprisonment for life provided that
if the death penalty is not pursued then the court shall impose a life sentence with a minimum period
of incarceration of 10 years do you understand count six and those possible penalties mr davao
yes your honor and here is where it gets quite interesting in my opinion the next set of
charges that the judge reads out is regarding the insurance fraud of tammy's life insurance policy
now after the judge reads them out loud chad says yes i do your honor yes your honor and watch while
he nods his head in agreement right after that he'll say yes and then another thing i noticed
is as the judge was reading out this charge he shifts his eyes back and forth really quickly
you'll see it and he'll do it really quickly and then says yes and then head bobs
and then at the end of this he bites his upper lip all right count seven of the
indictment is not a charge against you it's a charge against a co-conspirator
count eight of the indictment charges you mr day bell with the crime of insurance fraud which is a
felony under idaho code section 41 293 that is a felony that carries up to 15 years in prison
and a fine of up to 15 thousand dollars plus restitution do you understand that charge
in those possible penalties yes your honor all right count nine is also a charge of insurance
fraud under that same statute it carries the same penalty i just mentioned in count
eight which again is 15 years of prison and a fifteen thousand dollar fine plus restitution
do you understand that charge in those possible penalties yes your honor all right that is a
summary then of the charges that have been filed against you in the penalties i would also note
those penalties now also when the judge talks about these penalties being run consecutively
or concurrently chad also does the head bob in agreement it's interesting summary then of
the charges that have been filed against you in the penalties i would also note those penalties
in each of the counts could be ordered to be served either concurrently meaning running
together or consecutively and so do you understand those charges could also run consecutively in
those different counts mr davao yes i do and i'll get to the part where he pleads not guilty
but i do want to point out that he's in agreement with these head nods in the understanding of the
charges and the penalties regarding the insurance policy but yeah we don't see
any of that when it comes to tiley jj or tammy's charges now let's talk about his plea
remember how i talked about duper's delight with tylie we're gonna see it again when he actually
pleads not guilty to tiley's charge but we won't see that in the others this is what really made me
take notice now we've seen chad do this before i've mentioned this before in the preliminary
hearing where the exhibits were being shown to the defense and as that was shown you could see chad
leer and look at what's on there and you could see a little bit of a smirk or that dupers or duping
delight in my opinion there's some amusement of some sort now also something very important
when chad says he's not guilty of each charge he does it with an upward inflection in his voice
it's also called uptalk i find it very interesting so instead of saying not guilty he says not guilty
like a question if i'm sitting there and i'm you know being charged for murder i'm sure is heck
gonna make a statement that's pretty prominent saying not guilty so here instead of him being
sure of himself he sounds like he's making it a question mark making it unsure or sounding unsure
now could be something he normally does and he talks like that or has a habit of doing we've
seen that with kiera collins in the justin evans case in one of her recent interviews she does
a lot of the upticks and answers like a question i think that might be more of a pattern with her
whereas here i'm not sure but we kind of know a little bit more in the details when it comes to
this so i think we all know what we're thinking but this is an observation i'd be more hell no
i'm not guilty just plain not guilty not not guilty right guys you want to believe me right
anybody and anybody lucille at this point i would ask your client how he intends to plea before i do
that mr pryor do you have any questions for the court or anything you need to discuss with your
client before i ask for the plea no judge and i anticipate that my client will be entering a
plea of not guilty to all of the charges all right thank you mr pryor i will go through
them then individually again on count one of the indictment mr dabell how do you plead not guilty
we'll enter the not guilty plea on count one on count two how do you plead
not guilty on count three how do you plead not guilty on count four how do you plead
not guilty on count five how do you plea not guilty on count six how do you plea
not guilty on count eight how do you plea not guilty and on count nine how do you plead
not guilty now one more thing that's interesting in count six was pertaining to tammy dabell and
the first degree murder charge and there's ever so slightly a little eyebrow raise when he says
not guilty just another observation on count six how do you plea not guilty now speaking of please
k woodcock and colby ryan were outside being interviewed by nate eaton from east idaho news and
when it came to the plea kay woodcock said i think he should just give it up how do you have two kids
in your backyard and you don't know anything about it he's a liar he's a liar and colby says seeing
him knowing he did it and knowing everything about the truth this whole process is really
hard we've all had to go through it but he's going to say what he's going to say he's going to lie
about it from the beginning they have lied there's nothing you can do about it now quickly i'm going
to combine the answer that chad gives on each count and just make it a really short clip so you
can see the differences up close in his response and i'll also compare the two of tyler where the
charge is being read with that duping delight and also with the not guilty charge count one
mr dabal do you understand the charge and those possible penalties yes i do your honor okay
how do you plead not guilty we'll enter that do you understand that charge and
the possible penalties yes your honor count two how do you plead not guilty do you understand
the charge in count three and those possible penalties mr daybell yes your honor very well
on count three how do you plead not guilty do you understand count four and the possible penalties
mr daybell yes your honor all right on count four how do you plead not guilty
do you understand the charge and count five in the possible penalties yes your honor
on count five how do you plea not guilty count six and those possible penalties mr davao
yes your honor on count six how do you plea not guilty
do you understand that charge in those possible penalties yes your honor all right on count eight
how do you plea not guilty do you understand that charge in those possible penalties yes your honor
all right that is a and on count nine how do you plead not guilty very well not guilty please are
entered as to all the counts in the indictment let me know your thoughts in the comments below people
have patterns and the truth is in the details now chad will be back in court on june 23rd and
then the trial dates will be set the change of venue though is still an issue if you remember
john pryor was pushing to get that so stay tuned for that now lori is now going to be going
and getting her restorative treatment so her hearings are on hold until she is competent
everything's on hold then she'll come back if the judge comes back and says okay
now she's competent then everything will resume so let's have a chit chat below let me know what your
thoughts are and please subscribe if you haven't done so already i'm always having new videos and
don't forget to share and don't forget to like thank you so much for watching see you soon