I'm hoping for a bunch of trinkets galore.
All right.
[bell dings]
[grunts]
Perfect.
I can sell all this glassware stuff on my website.
So I'm going to say this box is worth 75 bucks.
Score.
[grunts]
Oh, peanut butter maker.
So vintage.
Perfect for my website.
20 bucks.
And the rest of this stuff--
yuk, pots and pans--
disgusting.
Man, these boxes are beat up.
Ah, some pine cones, a little Christmas decoration.
Looks like lots of glass pieces.
What do we got?
A little bell.
[bell dings]
Every time a bell rings, an angel gets its wings.
I'm going to say this box--
40 bucks.
Grody.
Ugh!
Forget crusty plush.
This is dusty-- oh--
plethora o' sickness.
Oh, please, bins, save me from my crusty plush.
[gasps]
This thing looks freaking cool.
Organic peanut butter.
So neat.
So I've got to get this thing checked out.
Maybe I just found myself a side business.
Good thing I don't have a peanut allergy.
Come on, be something good.
Stenograph.
[gasps] Now we're freaking talking.
It has a warranty with it.
I can sell this for probably, what--
40 bucks.
OK, things are looking up.
Thank god.
Boring purple wine glass.
Dish.
So this box-- not bad.
40 bucks.
Oh, they're Longchamp in the original box--
15 bucks.
I mean, where's all the doodads and the tchotchkes?
Thought this was going to be it.
An old hard drive, romance novels.
This is cool.
Never mind.
Damn.
Oh, there's some jewel earrings--
$24.99.
Sell them for 10 bucks.
Oh, a tooth!
Look at that thing.
Sick.
Oh!
This stuff might be old.
Ooh, is that a Rolex?
I hope.
50 bucks.
Let's see what else is in here.
This is cool.
25 bucks.
My pocketbook.
China and glass.
Ooh, cute little teacup.
Oh, girlfriend.
I've never seen a teacup that says "girlfriend."
Come on over with some crumpets and some biscuits.
So this whole box--
50 bucks.
Ugh!
The crustiest of colors and in the dustiest of lockers.
Get out of here, crusty, dusty.
But I'm hoping that this peanut butter
machine is where the money is.
Huh.
Hey!
Hello!
You're welcome.
I'm taking my Nutter Butter machine to Zach
and Valerie Fishbain's house.
They have a business called Spread the Love.
VAL FISHBAIN: Come on in!
ZACH FISHBAIN: Why don't we get it out of the box?
MARY PADIAN: So what, it grounds up the peanuts?
VAL FISHBAIN: Any kinds of nuts, actually.
Who would normally buy this?
Grocery stores will have it.
A lot of places, you can buy your peanuts in bulk.
So y'all's looks a lot older than mine.
It does.
Definitely got a little more wear and tear.
How did you guys get started?
Well, we started back in 2013.
We made 150 jars of peanut butter for our wedding.
As wedding favors.
Oh, my gosh.
As favors.
And little did we know at the time,
people would keep asking for it.
And people were putting in purchase orders
for their families, friends.
That's great-- doing what you love and spreading the love.
VAL FISHBAIN: Yeah. ZACH FISHBAIN: You know.
VAL FISHBAIN: Exactly. ZACH FISHBAIN: Exactly.
Do you mind if I--
MARY PADIAN: Yeah.
--take it apart for a second?
MARY PADIAN: Totally.
It looks like it's been very well
maintained, which is very good from a value
and a utility perspective.
That's good.
[machine turns on]
Oh, cool.
These grooves push the peanuts forward.
And when this is attached, this is actually what's grinding it.
So all of the force is taking this and turning it
into peanut butter.
You ready to try this thing out?
Yeah, I'm ready.
Yeah?
All right.
See how that works?
Mary, go ahead.
Start her up.
[fanfare music]
Looking good, guys.
VAL FISHBAIN: Wow.
That looks amazing.
Look at my peanut butter.
[laughs] Yes!
ZACH FISHBAIN: All right.
It's warm.
Mm, it's good.
Now we got some competition here.
MARY PADIAN: Not as good as you guys.
That's some fresh peanut butter right there.
Well, that's good peanut butter.
But I really need to know how much this thing is worth.
Brand new, it would be about $2,500.
Oh, wow.
ZACH FISHBAIN: This is 14 years old,
but it's in very good condition.
You've got some nice stainless steel.
VAL FISHBAIN: It's well maintained.
Hm.
Let's think about this.
ZACH FISHBAIN: I think $1,000.
Nice.
Yeah. $1,000.
That's not peanuts.