NARRATOR: Cayuga, Indiana, February 16, 2019.
Paranormal investigator Dave Spinks and his associate Haley
Sharp have traveled here to this small town
to investigate a house that many consider to be the most
evil place in North America.
Referred to as Willows Weep, it has been the site
of a series of gruesome deaths since it
was built in the 19th century.
[eery music playing]
Brenda Johnson owns Willows Weep.
Hi, Brenda.
Dave.
NARRATOR: She dismissed the rumors
about it being an evil place and purchased it only a few years
ago with plans to renovate it.
This is my sister Haley.
BRENDA JOHNSON: Hey.
It's nice to meet you.
NARRATOR: But recent events have convinced her that she may
have made a terrible mistake.
To this end, she's invited Dave and Haley
to come in and investigate the house
and see if her strange experiences can be verified.
So, how are you doing?
Not good standing here.
All night last night I was sick thinking about coming
over here around this house.
So tell us a little bit about the house and some
of your experiences here.
Well, when I bought the house, we started working on it.
And then my son was working on the ceiling.
The boards come flying off at him and hurt him.
And I've been scratched in there, six claw marks
down my back, doors slamming on you,
banging underneath the floors.
I understand there's been deaths in this house.
Can you kind of go through those a little bit?
Yeah.
The man that built the house, he died in the bathtub.
There was two suicides and then another hanging.
And I heard that three men had been poisoned.
About six months prior before I bought it,
there was a man that he committed suicide in there.
He fell into the chair.
DAVE SPINKS: And that's where they found him,
or they found him a couple days later, right?
BRENDA JOHNSON: A week. DAVE SPINKS: A week.
Week later, OK.
Do you think what's in that house is evil?
Yes, I do.
Without a doubt?
Yes, I do, without a doubt.
If it wasn't evil, it wouldn't be hurting people.
I don't think there's nothing good in there.
The house was built in late 1800s, correct?
1890, yes.
So regarding the shape of the house,
it's in the shape of a cross.
Upside-down cross.
DAVE SPINKS: Strange.
BRENDA JOHNSON: Yes, very strange.
Was Willows Weep really built to attract evil spirits?
For Brenda Johnson, Dave Spinks, and Haley Sharp,
the answer is a very disturbing yes.
But why would someone deliberately want
to construct an evil place unless, perhaps, it wasn't
meant to attract demonic spirits but to entrap
them in an effort to create a deadly warning
that demons are real.