Planes, trains and automobiles, well if we leave out the automobiles, we’ve seen a
few variations on the theme of how trains have been powered from steam, to diesel and
now electric but there was a time when several experimental trains used engines from planes
as there main propulsion, so this is a look at the very rare and futuristic aerotrains
and why to excuse the pun, they didn’t take off.
This video is sponsored by Magellan TV, Magellan is a new documentary streaming service run
by filmmakers that have a passion for their work. They believe that science defines the
cutting edge of society and their mission is to tell great stories that define the human
struggle to discover more. Magellan now has over 3000 documentaries available
with more being added each week with a wide selection of those in 4k for no extra cost
and you can also stream directly to your smartphone or tablet where ever you are.
There is a great 25-minute documentary called Trains, rockets and pains which is part of
the “Disasters in space” series which looks at the behind the scenes stories of
NASA catastrophes and near misses many of which are unknown to the public or me and
proved to be rather eye-opening and well worth watching.
You can watch this and many more by getting your 1 month free trial using the link for
this special offer right at the top of the description below and I’m sure you’ll
find MagellanTV as worthwhile as I have. Now look at these two trains, on the left
is the original Japanese Shinkansen 0 Series aka the Bullet train which entered service
in 1964 with a top speed of 130 mph or 210km/h. So you ask what is the one on the right.
Well, that was the German Schienenzeppelin or rail Zeppelin and that was debuted in 1930
with a top speed of 143mph or 230km/h, 34 years before the Shinkansen.
But of course there is also something majorly different between them besides 34 year age
gap. If we pull the picture out you see that not only is the Schienenzeppelin just a single
rail car but its also powered by a propeller and aero engine on the back of the railcar.
Now this wasn’t the first attempt to power a train with a propeller, in 1917 the Soviet
engineer Valerian Abakovsky created the Aerowagon, an experimental high speed rail car powered
by an aero engine and propeller. This could travel at upto 87 mph or 140km/h and was designed
to carry soviet officials. However, in 1921 things didn’t go too well
for it. After a successful test run from Moscow to Tula with several foreign delegates onboard,
the Aerowagon was on the return journey back to Moscow when it derailed at high speed killing
7 of the 22 people onboard including its creator Abakovsky, putting a rather abrupt stop to
the project which was cancelled shortly afterwards. The idea was then taken up eight years later
in 1930 by the German aero engineer Franz Kruckenberg when he created the Schienenzeppelin
for the German Imperial Railway Company - Deutsche Reichsbahn.
Kruckenberg was inspired by the aerodynamics from the then-current zeppelin airships and
the Schienenzeppelin was constructed with a lightweight aluminium aircraft-style body
to reduce its weight to just 20 tons. At just over 25 meters long the railcar ran on two
axles and the power came from two conjoined BMW 4 six-cylinder aircraft engines driving
a 4 bladed propeller, though later this would be changed for a single 600hp 46 litre BMW
6 V-12 aero engine driving a 2 bladed prop which was tilted down by 7 degrees to provide
some downforce. In the interior there was room for 40 passengers
on board which was done in rather minimalist Bauhaus style.
On June 21st 1931 on the Berlin-Hamburg line, the Schienenzeppelin set a new world speed
record for the fastest railcar at 143 mph or 240 km/h which stood for 23 years until
it was broken again in 1954 and it still holds the speed record for the fastest petrol-powered
rail vehicle. Now as a concept, it looks good on paper but
it doesn’t take long to see the major flaws. The most obvious is the large open propeller
spinning at high speed that would be only a couple of meters away from people on a train
platform as it pulled in to and out of a station. The noise and thrust it generated would also
kick anything that was not fixed down, dust, rubbish, signs and track ballast.
Going backwards was dangerous because of the open prop and couldn’t easily tow carriages
again because of the prop. It also had trouble going up steep inclines as the airflow separated
when full power was applied and just to add the cherry on top the cake, the standard railway
lines themselves were just not upto the demands of sustained high-speed travel.
So after the record-breaking run it was modified and the propeller was removed and a hydraulic
drive was fitted to a new powered front bogie but this lowered the top speed to 110mph or
180km/h. However, by 1932 the Deutsche Reichsbahn had
gone off without Kruckenberg and developed a new streamlined two-car trainset which became
known as the Hamburg flyer or the flying Hamburger which became the first fast diesel-electric
powered train in Germany. The Schienenzeppelin fared less well and with
the competition from the Deutsche‘s other high speed efforts it was eventually scrapped
in 1939 to supply metal for the war effort. But it wasn’t forgotten, the lightweight
streamlined design was years ahead of anything else and would influence high-speed train
design decades after the Schienenzeppelin had been scrapped.
Now you may have thought the after the Schienenzeppelin, trains powered by aircraft engines wouldn’t
have made past the design brief let alone into construction but that didn’t stop the
Americans from having go but this time with a jet-powered railcar.
The idea came from the Tech centre of the New York Central railroad to see if they could
develop a high-speed train for city to city use. Using jet engines was the cheapest and
easiest way to gain the 10,000 hp required. The idea was presented to Alfred Perlman,
the president of the New York Central in 1965 and discussed but then shelved.
Then about a year later the director of the tech centre, Jim Wright got a phone call from
Perlman saying the project had been given the go-ahead but it had to be done in 30 days…
and to make it happen he was effectively given a blank cheque to use what ever resources
with in the company to get it done. They started with a 13-year-old Budd RDC-3
self-propelled railcar, number M-497. The engines were disconnected from the wheels,
several rows of seats were removed for the jet mounting structure, new jet fuel tanks
were fabricated and fitted and over 50 different instruments installed to measure stress, temperatures,
vibrations etc make it a rolling laboratory. The engines were a pair of surplus GE J47-19’s
plus their mounting pod which had originally been used as boosters for the B-36 Peacemaker
nuclear bomber. The engines and pod was mounted upside down
on the front of the railcar and inclined 5 degrees downwards to give greater downforce.
Then finally a fairing which had been wind tunnel tested was added to the front and the
dark paint job gained it the name of the “Black Beetle” by the press.
Don Wetzel, Jim Wrights assistant and the project manager was chosen to pilot the train
because he was not only a qualified locomotive engineer but also had been a pilot in the
Marine Corp and was familiar with jet engines. The test run was to be done over a weekend
on the 23-24th July 1966 on a section of track between Butler, Indiana, and Air Line Junction,
Ohio where the track was straight and there was a four-mile section of continuously welded
rail. Over the two days, various runs were done
culminating in a top speed of 183.85 mph or 295.85km/h, though Don said that on that run,
it had gotten away from him and hit over 190 mph and he was decelerating through the timing
gate. Although this was just a concept it was seriously
looked at to power future trains but modifying all the automatic signals to work at over
double the 90mph limit they used at the time, together with the problem of low bridges,
noise, debris and ballast blown up by the jets meant much more money would be required
to ready the track and station infrastucure than just creating the jet railcars themselves.
There was also the issue that at under 300mph or 480km/h the jet engines were very inefficient
and used far more fuel than a standard railcar. After the tests, it was converted back to
a normal railcar and went back to working the commuter lines until 1977 when it was
retired and sat in sidings until it was finally scrapped in 1984.
Meanwhile, in 1970 in the Soviet Union an experiment studying wheel pairs and bogies
at speeds above 160km/h required the building of a laboratory railcar. To remove the influence
of the wheels being driven, the power would come from a pair of jet engines mounted to
the roof similar to that of the US Black Beetle. A traction car from an ER22 electric train
was converted with a pair of AI-25 jet engines from YAK-40 passenger plane. Originally it
was due to use the RD-45 engines from a MiG-15 fighter but at 900kg each they were too heavy
so they switched to the lighter 400kg AI-25’s Farings were added to the front and rear and
the wheels were covered. During wind tunnel testing 15 variations were tried with the
best one achieving a drag factor of 0.252, as good as many high-speed sports cars. Tests
started in 1971 and in 1972 it reached a top speed of 249km/h or 154mph.
The program ran until 1975 with the results used to build the experimental RT200 high-speed
passenger cars and the ER200 high-speed electric train.
Again like in the US, the possibility of using jet-powered trains was considered but along
with the similar issues that the Americans found, the Soviet thought that the stations
and tracks would need to be built like airports and away from residential areas because of
the noise. After the tests were complete the jet railcar
was left to rot in siding for years. It was going to be moved to a railway museum in St.
Petersburg but was in such a poor state of repair that just the front of the car with
the engine pods was cut off, renovated and placed outside of the TVZ carriage works where
it was originally built. With the advances of electric trans in the
1980s and beyond the idea of jet-powered trains was dropped because it was just not economically
viable to build the infrastructure to support them and to put up with all the issues of
noise and jet blast they produced. So I hope you enjoyed the video, and if you
did then please thumbs up, subscribe, click the bell and share.