Hey Eons fans!
We've released our second poster.
Enjoy this trip through the 1.8 billion-year-long saga of the supercontinents.
To get yours visit DFTBA.com
In 1975, a paleontologist discovered the fossilized cast of what was once an animal burrow, in
the KwaZulu-Natal province of South Africa.
Back in the early Triassic Period, 250 million years ago, that hole in the ground had become
filled with soft sediment that eventually hardened and preserved everything inside.
And in that burrow, researchers discovered the nearly complete remains of a small animal
called Thrinaxodon, one of the early mammal relatives known as cynodonts.
But it wasn’t alone in there.
Almost 40 years later, researchers took the cast from South Africa to France where it
underwent a high resolution scan, revealing another occupant in the burrow.
And it wasn’t another Thrinaxodon.
It wasn’t even a member of the same species.
Thrinaxodon’s roommate was actually an amphibian called Broomistega.
And that makes this burrow cast an incredible fossil, because it contains not just the animal
that probably made it, but also some unlikely company -- a very rare animal that might’ve
been among Thrinaxodon’s prey.
So, this burrow cast preserves a snapshot in time - one that’s given paleontologists
a wealth of information about animal behavior and interactions in the deep past.
But how did this odd couple end up together?
And what killed and preserved them this way for a quarter of a billion years?
Well, it looks like their luck ran out, when a behavior that usually would’ve helped
them survive just didn’t work.
To figure out how Thrinaxodon and Broomistega became entombed together, scientists looked
at the burrow itself, along with their fossilized bones.
They concluded that the likely cause of death was a flash flood that carried fast-moving
water and sediment into the burrow, encasing the animals.
This would explain the distinct layers of sediment found in the burrow, as well as the
fact that the skeletons of both animals were almost complete and fully articulated.
Thrinaxodon was found lying on the floor of the burrow, with Broomistega alongside and
slightly on top of it, probably from being moved by the flood waters.
But what were these two animals doing in the same burrow to begin with?
Thrinaxodon was a carnivorous proto-mammal and Broomistega was an early amphibian relative
- not exactly a common pair.
First off, we know that Broomistega is not the burrow creator, because it didn’t have
strong forelimbs for digging.
And you might remember from our episode on synapsids that Thrinaxodon was a burrower.
So the burrow probably belonged to Thrinaxodon, and Broomistega was just a visitor.
From there, the researchers considered five possible scenarios that might’ve brought
these two together - and they were able to use the bones of both creatures to figure
out which one was most likely.
The first scenario was that this was all just some kind of coincidence.
Like, say, Broomistega was randomly washed into the Thrinaxodon burrow, by a flood or
heavy rains.
But the burrow entrance probably would've been just big enough for Boomistega to fit
through head first, seeing how it's similar in size to Thrinaxodon.
So it’s unlikely that it could’ve just washed in.
Okay, so what if Broomistega was dinner for Thrinaxodon?
Thrinaxodon did eat meat, and, well, Broomistega is made of meat.
And the researchers had noticed that Broomistega had two small holes above its left eye, which
looked like bite marks.
But when they compared the distance between those holes with the distances between the
upper and lower canines in Thrinaxodon, they didn’t match.
Also, Broomistega’s skeleton was pretty complete, and it didn’t have any other tooth
marks on it.
So it doesn’t seem like Thrinaxodon was actively snacking on that Broomistega.
Ok then, maybe Thrinaxodon was just stashing it in the burrow to eat later?
Well, this probably wasn’t the case either.
Some modern animals do stash away some of their prey to eat later, but this behavior
is pretty rare, especially in hot environments like where Thrinaxodon lived, where food decays
quickly.
That rules out three of the five scenarios that were proposed.
And if this seems like a lot of possibilities to consider, well, that’s part of the scientific
process!
So, the fourth asked, what if Thrinaxodon was already dead when Broomistega wandered
in?
You can’t exactly object to an intruder in your burrow if you’re dead.
This scenario was also rejected based on the position of Thrinaxodon’s skeleton.
Its spine was curved against the wall of the burrow, which suggested that its body was
still pliable at the time, not stiff like it would be if it had died and then became
rigid, in that process known as rigor mortis.
Instead, the flow of sediment and water were able to mold Thrinaxodon’s body to
match the curve of the wall.
So it either died during the flood or just before it.
OK, so!
The final scenario is that maybe Thrinaxodon wasn’t dead, but instead was just... sleeping.
I know this sounds like some kind of euphemism, but this is what researchers think is the
best explanation, based on the skeleton itself and on what’s known about the environment
that these animals lived in.
First of all, the position of Thrinaxodon’s forelimbs, to the side of its skull, looks
like a natural resting position.
And the Early Triassic climate of southern Africa was dry and warm, and in these conditions
today, there are many animals that do what’s called estivation.
This is similar to hibernation, except it’s done in hot, dry conditions, not cold ones.
Animals enter a deep sleep, or torpor, to slow down their metabolism and reduce their
activity during hot periods in order to survive.
And it’s likely that Thrinaxodon would have done this, too.
Several burrows have been discovered from the Karoo region of South Africa with Thrinaxodons
found curled up inside, suggesting that they were preserved while asleep.
So, with Thrinaxodon in a deep sleep, Broomistega must’ve crawled into the burrow on its own.
Living amphibians, especially juveniles, which this Broomistega was, are known to retreat
into the burrows of other animals for protection.
And this amphibian would’ve needed a quiet place to hide out.
Because, it looks like it was having a tough time.
The scans revealed several partially healed broken ribs, suggesting that it was likely
crushed just a few weeks before it died.
Although this wasn’t a lethal injury, it was probably really painful for Broomistega
to move and breathe.
So, based on all of the evidence we’ve managed to find from this remarkably preserved fossil
pair, we can finally play back their final moments:
It was a super hot day in the Early Triassic, and Thrinaxodon was sleeping deeply in a cool
underground burrow.
Its heart beat slowly and its forelimbs were sprawled out on either side of its head.
It was in a deep enough sleep that it didn't notice an intruder entering the burrow.
Broomistega was struggling to breathe and to move.
It had been injured a few weeks ago, but it slowly made its way across the dry landscape,
looking for somewhere cool to recover - a safe haven from predators.
Finally, it spotted a burrow and crawled in.
There was already something inside, but it didn't move, so the young amphibian lay down
to rest.
Both of these creatures should’ve been safe in the burrow, but it was actually a death
trap.
Suddenly, muddy water came rushing in, pushing their resting bodies against the wall of the
burrow, and killing them.
The sediment covered their bodies, and over time they became fossilized, only to be found
together, 250 million years later.
And this fossil burrow tells us something about South Africa’s Karoo ecosystem and
how species interacted, even in the distant past.
Different species sheltering together, especially in spaces that are as confined as a den or
burrow, is pretty rare, even in living animals.
So this discovery is unique, because it allowed researchers to investigate the interaction
between, and the behaviors of, two very different animals, one an early relative of mammals
and the other a possible forerunner of modern amphibians.
Thrinaxodon’s burrowing skills are likely what allowed it and other early mammal relatives
to survive the End-Permian Extinction, with many mammals still burrowing today.
And this amazing find also shows the potential ancient roots of a behavior still seen in
living amphibians - the habit of retreating to burrows in tough times.
Both of these behaviors - ones that their relatives still do today - were probably important
for the survival of these species.
This odd couple of the Early Triassic is a snapshot in time, preserving a moment between
two completely different species just trying to survive another day in our planet’s history.
If you wanna learn more about Thrinaxodon and mammalian evolution, check out our episode,
“When the Synapsids Struck Back”.
We really dig this month’s Eontologists: Lucan Curtis-Mahoney, Sean Dennis, Jake Hart,
Jon Davison Ng, Patrick Seifert, and Steve!
Become an Eonite at patreon.com/eons to nerd out with us on our Discord.
And as always thank you for joining me today in the Konstantin Haase studio.
Subscribe at youtube.com/eons for more adventures in deep time.