This episode is brought to you by Brilliant ... click the link in the description below.
Imagine traveling inside a levitating capsule within a vacuum tube while going 200 mph faster
than a 747, powered by renewable energy. Could Elon Musk and The Boring Company be digging
cost efficient tunnels to lay the groundwork for a system like that? Let’s explore the
Hyperloop, where things stand, and the future of high speed mass transportation.
I’m Matt Ferrell. Welcome to Undecided.
The world has always been looking for faster, cheaper, and more efficient methods to transport
goods and people around the world, but combating climate change is amplifying that quest for
a solution that's also environmentally friendly. Electric vehicles have been a promising solution
for small-scale transportation with reduced carbon emissions, but when it comes to mass
transportation there still are uncertainties.
An ongoing technology is Maglev, which is a system used by trains that uses magnetics
to improve efficiency. It takes advantage of the lack of friction to achieve speeds
up to 430 kmh (~267 mph). To do that, Maglev uses two sets of magnets: one set to repel
and push the train up above the track and another to move the elevated train horizontally,
but it has its limitations due to the aerodynamics of the train itself. That leads me to the
Hyperloop, which combines magnetics, vacuum tubes, electric motors, air compression, and
renewable energy to reach ultra-high speed with low carbon emissions.
Hyperloop is a new technology for ground-level transportation where people could travel in
a hovering, windowless, bullet-shaped capsule inside a vacuum tube that travels from one
city to another at speeds as high as 1,220 kmh (~760 mph). This ultra-high speed is achieved
through a vacuum tube to lower friction and air resistance, which is the big stumbling
block for normal vehicles to achieve such high speeds. It's similar to a rocket flying
through space. For some additional propulsion enormous air compressors are installed on
the capsule to re-direct air to the back of the capsule. This redirected air can be sent
to the air bearings, which assists in levitating the metal capsules above the surface of tube
reducing friction. The redirected air also solves the problem of air pressure building
in front of the vehicle that could decrease its speed. And speaking of speed, to control
the speed of the capsule, linear induction motors are placed along the tube to speed
it up and down to the appropriate velocity for each section of the tube. If you’ve
ever ridden the PeopleMover at Walt Disney World, you’ve experienced this ... on a
much, much smaller and slower scale.
Although it seems like ultra-futuristic technology, transportation vacuum tubes have a long heritage.
In 1845, Isambard Kingdom Brunel, a British engineer, proposed building a tube in southwest
England that would propel trains at a speed of 110 kmh (~70 mph), which was stunning at
that time. But, the project proved unfeasible due to a lack of materials. Similar in design
was the 'vactrain' concept, which was presented by Robert Goddard in the early 1900's. The
main difference between vactrains and hyperloops is that the vactrains have an airbag suspension.
But it took almost a century before Elon Musk proposed combining various aspects of these
as the Hyperloop.
Although people often refer to hyperloop as Elon Musk's invention, it's not exactly a
new idea. In 1978, Rand Corporation published a paper by Robert M. Salter titled Trans-Planetary
Subway Systems – A Burgeoning Capability. In 2013, Musk published a 58-page white paper
titled Hyperloop Alpha, which set out the design of Hyperloop. In his paper, Musk mentions
the Rand Corporation’s Planetran concept as inspiration for the hyperloop – and expressed
disappointment that it didn’t move forward. The Planetran was imagined as a system of
tubes “deep underground”, but the building cost was enormous – $750 billion.
Elon described the Hyperloop as "a cross between a Concorde, a railgun and an air hockey table."
I mean ... who doesn't like air hockey? Musk claimed that the vehicle could make the 560-kilometer
(350-mile) trip from Los Angeles to San Francisco in only 35 minutes for $20 a ticket. He projected
a total cost of $6 billion for the infrastructure, which is a little dubious ... but I'll get
to that in a minute.
In Elon's white paper model, the air pressure inside the Hyperloop tube is about one-sixth
the pressure of the atmosphere on Mars. This reduces the drag force of the air by 1,000
times compared to sea level conditions, and would be equivalent to flying above 150,000
feet. On top of that, the train would float above the tube's surface on a set of 28 air-bearing
skis, and the pod generates the air cushion to keep the tube as cheap and straightforward
as possible. Other Hyperloop versions employ magnetic levitation rather than air skis to
sustain the passenger pods above the tracks.
Since Elon's paper there have been several notable companies trying to make it a reality,
like Hyperloop Transportation Technologies (HyperloopTT) which launched quickly after
Musk’s publication in 2013. Even though they're based in the US it's made the most
progress in Eastern Europe, India, and South Korea, where feasibility studies are taking
place. Its capsule can reach over 1,200 kph (~760 mph), carrying anywhere from 28 to 50
passengers. The company developed a carbon-fiber smart material with embedded sensors for the
fuselage skin, which can send information about stability, integrity, and temperature
instantaneously with no cables hooked up. And I can only assume someone at the company
must have been watching a lot of Marvel movies because they called this technology Vibranium™.
On top of that, HyperloopTT's system integrates solar panels and other renewable energy sources
to create a net energy positive system that produces more power than it consumes, which
lowers the environmental expense of such a large-scale infrastructure project ... and
it should also help keep operational costs down. In theory.
HyperloopTT also utilizes a passive maglev technology called Indutrack, which enables
the capsule to levitate over an unpowered, conductive track. In the event of a power
failure, the capsule automatically slows down and settles on its auxiliary wheels at low
speed.
The California-based company, Virgin Hyperloop, is another company trying to make this a reality.
They've developed technologies to ensure safety and comfort. The Pod Safety Controller continuously
monitors all onboard sensors and computer systems to ensure passenger safety, and the
data is transferred through a certified safety protocol. They also integrate technologies
to detect rapid tube depressurization, automated fire suppression, emergency egress along the
tube, and a Pod Safety Controller that continuously monitors the air inside the vehicle.
Some of the biggest pros for Hyperloop technology are speeds up to 1,200 kmh and using renewable
energy to run, as well as reducing freight shipping times, which could help reduce shipping
costs. But, there are some challenges delaying its release.
First, the initial cost of building a Hyperloop infrastructure is huge ... massive. Virgin
Hyperloop One has estimated an average cost for Hyperloop between $25–27 million (£18-£20
million) per mile, not including land costs. A study carried out by Transpod, another company
in the Hyperloop game, showed a cost breakdown that tube construction would make up about
38% of the cost.
In 2013, Elon Musk estimated that building a route between Los Angeles and the San Francisco
Bay area would cost $11.5 million per mile. In comparison, Hyperloop One estimated that
a 107-mile loop around the Bay Area alone, either by tunnel or a mix of the tunnel and
elevated track, would add up to between $9 billion and $13 billion. That's a whopping
$84 - $121 million per mile. Just a smidge above Elon's estimate.
In addition, similar to high-speed rail systems, Hyperloop has inherent risks that need to
be carefully engineered. Even a small earthquake or the slightest damage to a vacuum tube would
cause a big disaster at high speeds, which has required a huge amount of research and
development money to make it safe. Those risks haven't dissuaded the companies
that are currently developing studies and testing prototypes. Since 2015, for example,
SpaceX sponsors the yearly Hyperloop Pod Competition, allowing student and non-student teams to
participate in the design and implementation of small-scale prototypes to demonstrate the
technical feasibility of various characteristics of the Hyperloop concept.
Among all of Musk’s investments one can be easily correlated with Hyperloop technology:
The Boring Company. It goes right back to Rand Corporation’s Planetran with tubes
“deep underground.” Elon founded it in 2016 to quickly construct safe and low-cost
tunnels for transportation, utility, and freight. The Loop technology proposed by the company
isn’t in a vacuum. Instead, the Loop will carry passengers on autonomous electric vehicles
traveling up to 200 - 240 kph (125 - 150 mph). While their tunnels don’t currently use
a vacuum inside, they’ve said that their Hawthorne test tunnel can support Hyperloop
R&D, so it could be modified to support a Hyperloop in the future. Most interesting
part though ... the Boring Company's Loop tunnels are currently priced at around $10
million per mile.
Since the hyperloop industry keeps growing with increased interest from many competing
companies, there's inevitably going to be many different standards and operating approaches.
A consortium of European and Canadian hyperloop companies are pushing an initiative around
international standardization. By developing common standards, specifications, and approaches,
a committee named JTC 20 will help to mitigate potential challenges when implementing these
systems across Europe. Leave to Europe to continue playing the long game here. They
standardized behind one EV charging standard and are already doing the same thing with
this.
However, there still are big challenges to make the hyperloop real and viable, and the
risks of the technology are significant. If the tube is punctured, outside air would aggressively
enter the tube as it attempts to balance the pressure. Also, the intense vibrations would
likely structurally compromise the tubes, either causing an implosion or even worse
yet, spontaneous decompression. In his whitepaper, Musk says: “The problem with this approach
is that it is incredibly hard to maintain a near vacuum in a room, let alone 700 miles
(round trip) of large tubes with dozens of station gateways and thousands of pods entering
and exiting every day”.
From the perspective of a low-carbon future, the benefits of hyperloop are clear. Virgin
Hyperloop One estimates worldwide flights alone produced 946 million tons of CO2 in
2017. The company estimated that if every passenger flight between 310 - 930 miles was
switched over to a Hyperloop running on renewables, it could decrease fossil fuel emissions by
58%. Not bad.
While the progress has been slow, there have been a couple of recent, impressive milestones.
But before I get to that, if you’re attracted to the idea of learning more about magnetism,
check out the Electricity and Magnetism course at Brilliant. This has been one of my favorite
courses so far ... and another great example of why I love having Brilliant as a sponsor.
This course really helped me wrap my head around how electric and magnetic fields work.
But even if you’re repelled by the idea of that topic (sorry, I couldn’t help myself),
they have over 60 courses including topics in computer science, physics, and mathematics.
They teach all of the concepts through fun and interactive challenges, which helps you
understand the "why" of something ... not just the "how." It helps to develop your intuition,
which is my favorite part about Brilliant and taps into the way I learn.
Go to www.brilliant.org/Undecided to sign up for free. The first 200 people will get
20% off their annual premium membership.
Thanks to Brilliant and to all of you for supporting the channel.
So there have been a couple of recent, impressive milestones. Virgin Hyperloop conducted the
first test with two human passengers in Las Vegas, using their Pegasus prototype, a two-seater-prototype
developed to test the system. The pod accelerated to 160 kph (100 mph) along the test track.
Jay Walder, CEO of Virgin Hyperloop told the Verge:
“No one has done anything close to what we’re talking about right now.”
“This is a full scale, working hyperloop that is not just going to run in a vacuum
environment, but is going to have a person in it. No one has come close to doing it.”
-Jay Walder, CEO of Virgin Hyperloop
The company has raised $400 million from private investors so far, and wants to start commercial
operations in 2030.
And just days after Virgin Hyperloop’s milestone, the Korean Railroad Research institute (Korail)
announced the highest top speed ever achieved in a Hyperloop test. They hit 1,019 kph (633
mph) in a scale model. South Korea is trying to launch a hyperloop network by 2024.
Will they? It's still too early to tell, but I'm holding out hope that I'll get a chance
to ride at 700 mph inside a capsule made out of the same material as Captain American's
shield. I can dream.
What about you? Do you want to live the sci-fi future traveling inside a hamster tube? Jump
into the comments and let me know. If you liked this video be sure to check out one
of the ones I have linked right here. Be sure to subscribe and hit the notification bell
if you think I’ve earned it. And as always, thanks to all of my patrons and to all of
you for watching. I’ll see you in the next one.