- Absolute worst season. They ruined the show.
They ruined everyone's character arc.
I'm so pissed, I wanna punch through the screen.
♪ (upbeat intro) ♪
- (FBE) How familiar are you both with Rotten Tomatoes?
- Pretty familiar. I like to look at them
before I watch movies.
- I usually don't look at the Rotten Tomatoes situation
until I after I see a movie.
- If it is low, I can't riot. I'll be like, I don't know
if I wanna go see it. - I like to form my own
opinions about movies.
- (FBE) Today, you're gonna go head to head in
a guess that Rotten Tomatoes score challenge.
- Oh [bleep], okay. - I'm not gonna do good.
- I don't think I will either.
- (FBE) How it works is I'll show you a famous
ending to a TV show and you both have to
write down if you think the TV show is fresh or rotten.
- Oh wait, we're doing TV shows, not movies?
- (FBE) And then whoever gets that correct gets a point.
Whoever's closest with the percentage
also gets a point. - Okay.
- If it's the last season of Game of Thrones,
it was rotten. - Are we a team
or are we against each other? - (FBE) Against each other.
- Going against each other, you know what I'm saying?
- Yeah. - I'm trying to knock it
out the box.
- Wait, are we guessing the critics or the audience though,
'cause those are two different scores.
- (FBE) The critics score. - Okay.
- I think I'm gonna do really bad at this.
I don't use Rotten Tomatoes nearly as much
as I feel like most people do.
- There have been times when I didn't agree
with what Rotten Tomatoes has said about season finales,
so we'll see.
- No. - GOT, baby.
- Oh God.
- When I hear it, I think it's gonna start up again.
- I can't believe this show is over.
This was such a big part of my life
for the past few years.
- The ending was very controversial, apparently.
- My boy, John Snow.
- I feel like you're not a Game of Thrones fan.
- Unless I caught everything before, that just looked
like people walking. - (FBE) You know, guess what?
If you watch eight seasons, it's still just people walking.
So, what do you think Rotten Tomatoes scored
the final season of Game of Thrones?
- I'm gonna say... - (FBE) Let's see it.
- Faith.
- Last episode was rotten to me, but the season.
- Oh, the season. - The season was pretty good.
Gave it a fresh 80.
- Okay.
- (FBE) Let's see them.
This season of Game of Thrones was rotten.
- What? - (FBE) At 55%.
- The whole season was good, though. The fighting parts,
all that was good.
- I don't care.
- Yeah, you were so close. - I mean.
- Oh wow. - Oh.
- They actually agreed with the fans.
My friends, at the end of the season, they said,
"I felt like I wasted eight years of my life."
- Absolute worst season. They ruined the show.
They ruined everyone's character arc.
I'm so pissed, I wanna punch through the screen.
- I don't have a desire to think for the critics,
but we're gonna do this for show's sake, okay?
- (FBE) Well, here's another one that may have devastated
some people. - Okay.
- Ay, Lost. - Nice, yes.
- After the third season, I got lost.
- The dog's gonna eat you the moment you stop breathing.
- I was actually kind of scared getting on a plane
for the first season or two after watching it.
- This was super controversial, I remember.
- Yes.
- I was really upset.
- It's been so many seasons. - He's been lost
for six seasons.
- Everyone's formed bonds with all these characters
for literal years, so when you're basically
saying goodbye to something, you're not gonna be
happy with it.
- Ready? What'd you say?
- (FBE) Season six was fresh at 82%.
- What?
- Wow, okay, okay.
- Whoa. - You got it right on.
Wow. - (FBE) I'm gonna give
extra points for right on the nose.
That's pretty insane. - That's crazy.
- Ooh, you beat me. Okay, all right.
- I'm stunned.
- I bet the audience rating is lower.
- Yeah, I think so, too.
- (FBE) Here is your third ending.
- Breaking Bad. - Yes.
- This show.
- Oh, okay.
- This is a show that did it right
throughout the whole thing.
- There's my show. This is my show right here.
Breaking Bad was the show, boy. That's what I tell you.
- So good. - That was some good acting,
that was some good shooting, that was some good storyline,
that was some good everything.
- Whoo.
- I'm gonna go super low. - Oh, really?
- Oh yeah. Head games.
- This one, I'm not gonna let you copy.
You're actually tied with me now, so...
- There you go.
- Ah, okay, all right.
- I gotta give it a fresh 99.
- (FBE) Breaking Bad season five, fresh at 100%.
- Holy [bleep]. - What'd you put?
- Oh, 100. I should have gave it 100.
- Oh yes, it was that good. - It was pretty perfect.
- Yeah.
- Whoa. - Let's go.
- Really? - Yeah.
This was the best show of all time from beginning to end.
- It was just so perfect. The ending, all the characters,
that's how you make an ending to a show.
- (FBE) Here's ending number four.
- Okay.
- Dexter.
- Serial killer.
- I believe it or not, got so uncomfortable
liking this character that I had to stop myself.
- Trinity killer season was amazing.
- ♪ I'm a lumberjack and I'm okay ♪
- This ending pissed a lot of people off.
I feel like when you binge watch something
and you don't spend years and years investing,
you're not as upset as when fans are like,
"I've spent seven years on this show
and that's how it ends?"
- (FBE) So, what do you think Rotten Tomatoes
rated Dexter season eight?
- I have no clue on this one. - Yeah.
- Fresh, 75.
- (FBE) Dexter season eight is rotten at 35%.
- Yes. - Whoa.
Damn it. I mean, good job.
- Wow. - I had it at 45.
- Dang.
- Wow, she got it. Damn.
That's a fail, not even a D. They had to redo
the whole season.
- Eight seasons? Jesus Christ, end it already.
- With a lot of these dark anti heroes,
you either gotta kill them, make them go good,
or atone for what they've done in some way.
He's a lumberjack now.
- (FBE) Here's the next one.
- Oh, finally.
- Classic, classic. It's classic [bleep].
♪ Hold on to ♪
- ♪ Feeling ♪
- I remember being so young and my parents not
letting me watch this.
- Wait, it literally ended like that?
- I thought we lost-- - The connection?
- The connection. Lost the TV show.
I'm like, wait, wait, wait, flipping to another channel.
No, I still have it. Is HBO working?
What's going on?
- How do you end something like that?
- Horrible. Everybody was so pissed off.
- The reveal.
- Fresh, 100.
- (FBE) For the season six part two, they thought
it was fresh. - No, no!
Oh, hell no. - (FBE) At 83%
- Whoa. - Shut up.
- Yes. - Damn.
- Oh.
- I got it by one percent.
- Oh, 83? They gave it an 83?
- Was not a great season finale.
- When that screen went black, all hell was breaking loose
all over New Jersey. - Drop the names.
Who said that? Jen wants to know.
- Listen. I actually am still mafia
connected.
- (FBE) All right, here's the final one.
- Oh.
- Oh, How I Met Your Mother.
- The blue horn.
- It's a tragic, tragic love story. Stupid.
- Oh my God, this was the most controversial ending.
- You spend a whole season building up to their wedding.
- The whole life, the whole show.
- The guy wasted his life. He wasn't with the right person.
- I have no idea what the critics said about this.
- I'm gonna go with what my feeling is.
- (FBE) Okay, let's see your scores.
- Rotten.
- Ready?
- (FBE) So, actually not rotten. - What?
- (FBE) And they rated it a 75. - What?
- Really? - Oh no.
- Oh.
- Critics, man.
- We wasted an entire [bleep] season on a divorce.
- Stupid blue french horn that they stole.
How would Benny and Rafi feel if I stole this thing?
- Probably not happy. - Right?
- (FBE) You swept it. How does it feel?
- Feels pretty good.
- Oh, you beat me. - I did.
- (FBE) Generally, were you guys surprised by these ratings?
- A little surprised. Critics versus people's
opinions different as we saw with Jen and the Sopranos.
- Critics, they're getting paid and they might have
some kind of grudge or something.
That's why sometimes, I don't go with critics
and tomatoes and stuff. I'ma go to see the movie myself
and get it for myself. - Exactly.
- How do you end a show to make everybody happy?
- Yes, you can't. No matter what.
- The longer they drag stuff out, the more people are like,
"That doesn't really fit their character"
'cause they try to force people into scenarios
which doesn't work and I think that's where
a lot of fans get snuffed and real hurt about it.
- I think the moral of this story is
if you wanna watch something, watch it.
Be your own critic. - That should be on a t-shirt.
Be your own critic. Okay.
Did you guess the right scores like I did?
- If you like this episode, hit that Like button.
- Hey fam, React producer Mary here.
Are you subscribed to the React Channel?
If you aren't, you should do that
and you should also hit that bell icon
to join our notification squad. We're in the comments
for the first 30 minutes after every video comes out,
so come say hi. All right, have
a great day, everyone. Bye.