that you have is an old freezer.
First of all,
when did you buy the freezer?
>> July.
>> Judge Judy:
July of what year?
>> 2016.
>> Judge Judy: Show me the bill.
>> Well, I bought it
on Craigslist.
>> Judge Judy:
Show me the receipt.
Show me the...
>> I don't have
a receipt for it.
>> Judge Judy:
You don't have the receipt.
You don't have anything.
Got an awful lot
of papers there, Mr. Davis.
You have nothing.
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy:
You know, I'm not believing
a whole lot of what
you're telling me, Mr. Davis.
>> Yes.
>> Judge Judy:
So you bought the freezer used,
and then, for some reason,
you put it in her garage.
Why would you buy a used freezer
from Craigslist
and put it in her garage?
>> Because I was doing
construction at my house,
and I had nowhere to put it.
>> Judge Judy:
Well, what did you buy it for?
>> Well, at the time...
>> Judge Judy: No.
You bought it in '16.
>> ...it was
a good deal to buy.
>> Judge Judy: You bought it
because
you thought it was a good buy.
>> It was.
>> Judge Judy:
Is that what you're saying?
>> And I was going to use it,
so...
>> Judge Judy: Mr. Davis,
even you don't expect me
to believe that.
>> Oh, yes.
>> Judge Judy: You're in
the middle of construction,
and if you're in the middle
of construction, for one thing,
my husband does a lot
of looking for things
to buy on Amazon, you know.
Every two, three hours,
I get a package from Amazon
with two tubes of toothpaste
and mouthwash
and enough toothbrushes
to last me until I'm 140.
I get a lot of stuff delivered.
>> But at that time...
>> Judge Judy: But do you know
what my husband never looked up
in any time that we've ever
done construction or moving?
A used refrigerator
that he wasn't going to keep
in his house
but that he was going to put
in his sometimes
girlfriend's garage.
>> But it...
>> Judge Judy: He was storing it
in your garage.
>> It was in my garage.
>> That's...
>> Judge Judy: When did
he put it in your garage?
>> I would agree with him,
July 2016.
>> Yes.
>> Without my permission.
>> Judge Judy: Where...
>> I didn't know it was there.
>> Judge Judy:
Well, I don't care.
You had to know
a freezer was there.
You know, even if I come home
to my garage...
>> Well, I came home.
He didn't ask.
I didn't know it was there.
>> Judge Judy: Until when?
>> Until when I came home.
I came home about a week later,
and I'm like,
"Why is this freezer here
in my garage?"
>> Judge Judy: And he said...
>> How can I get it in...
>> Judge Judy: No.
>> And I asked him, I said,
"Well, why you ain't bring
the freezer to your house?"
>> Hmm.
>> Why you leave it over there?
Because you know,
if it's a storm,
I'm going to go down there
and park my car.
>> Judge Judy: Shh.
>> Okay.
>> Judge Judy:
Why did he tell you he brought
the freezer to your garage?
>> He didn't have
an explanation.
>> Judge Judy:
Where is the freezer now?
>> It's gone.
>> Judge Judy: I know it's gone.
It didn't walk out
of your garage.
>> Yes, Your Honor.
I understand.
>> Judge Judy:
What did you do with it?
>> I put it out there
on the curb.
>> Judge Judy: When?
>> April 3rd, this year, 2017.
>> Judge Judy:
So if he came to the house,
he wouldn't find it there,
with a marshal?
>> Nope.
>> Judge Judy:
She doesn't have your freezer.
What's next?
Nothing.
So you're done.
Okay.
Now, I have your counterclaim,
return of property.
What do you want?
>> I have a chair that's
at his house
that I personally took
over there from my house.
I have two glass tables
that is in his shed,
and I have four
original Lexus tires
with the tires on there,
the rims and tires
and two extra tires
in his garage.
>> Judge Judy:
What are they doing there?
>> When I moved with Mr. Davis
and my son rented my house,
my son had a washer and dryer.
And in the area
where I had my tires, I moved
my washer and dryer there.
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
Mr. Davis, where are her tires?
>> I do not have them.
>> Judge Judy: Shh.
They also, like your freezer,
they didn't develop legs
and walk out.
Where are they?
>> Well, I do not
have her tires.
>> Judge Judy:
That's not what I asked you.
>> I do not know.
I don't have them.
I do not know.
>> Judge Judy: Oh, you see,
that's the wrong answer.
She may have lied to me
when she said,
"I don't have it anymore."
I said, "Well, the freezer
didn't develop legs.
So you had to know
what happened to the freezer."
>> Well...
>> Judge Judy:
So she said to me, "I put it out
on the curb in April."
Whether it's true or not,
I don't know, but at least
she gave me an answer.
She didn't give me an
"I don't know,"
while it gave her time to think.
>> Well, we had a shed together.
>> Judge Judy: A shed?
>> Right.
We had a shed together,
and when she moved,
she took her property,
and I took mine.
>> Judge Judy: Just a minute.
Where is the shed located?
>> About six blocks
from my house.
>> Judge Judy: So you're talking
about a storage shed.
>> Storage shed, yes.
>> Judge Judy: A storage shed.
So this isn't a shed
that's on his property.
>> There's a shed
on his property,
and prior, Mr. Davis did have,
in my name, a storage unit.
>> Judge Judy:
I don't care about either
one of you, actually.
Assault.
>> Yes, ma'am.
>> Judge Judy: First of all,
I'd like to see a police report
about the assault.
>> They didn't make a report.
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
The assault took place
on what date?
>> 12/18/2016.
>> Judge Judy: I'd like to see
any medical evidence
of the assault.
>> Yes.
I have medical evidence.
>> Judge Judy:
I'd like to see it.
>> And I have pictures.
>> Judge Judy:
I'd like to see, first...
>> Okay.
>> Judge Judy:
...medical evidence.
>> Okay.
Let me get the medical evidence.
That's my doctor visit
on the 28th.
Does she want the pictures,
or we going one by one?
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
Mr. Davis, I want you to tell me
what happened on December 18th.
I've just read
the medical record that I have.
>> Well, whatever is
in that report, it's not true
because December the 18th,
we didn't have
no physical contact.
>> Judge Judy:
I'd like you to tell me
the reason that you separated,
then, on December 18th.
>> The reason we separated is
because she was accusing me
of not being faithful,
and it got so bad,
she had to leave,
and we had to separate because
it was becoming very unhealthy.
>> Judge Judy: So