Why are you an atheist?
I'm an atheist because God is very weak.
And what do you mean by God?
Well, God doesn't exist.
What do you mean by God that doesn't exist?
That creator of heaven and the earth doesn't exist.
It's a part of an idea.
So why does something exist rather than nothing?
What was the question?
I'll tell you again.
How do you differentiate between what makes sense and what doesn't?
Don't just tell me all because it's BS.
I need to know a criteria that one can use
every single one of us to say that, yes, it seems reasonable.
How do you understand and differentiate
between what is sensible and what is not sensible?
Okay, common sense here.
Well, let me answer this question;
How I Answered this question a thousand times
when people like you asked me that question.
People like me?
Why are you an atheist?
I'm an atheist because God is very weak.
And what do you mean by God?
Well, God doesn't exist.
What do you mean by God that doesn't exist?
That creator of heaven and the earth and doesn't exist.
So it's a part of an idea.
Let's understand something.
So why does something exist rather than nothing?
I don't understand what you mean.
You do understand, something exists today and we need to have an explanation.
Why does something exist rather than nothing?
Remember, you don't believe in the creator of the heaven and the earth.
So I'm going to ask you this question.
Why do the universe exist?
Because there's nothing like heaven and earth.
Why do the universe exist rather nothing?
Why don't you speak to me?
Why do universe verse exists rather than nothing in existence?
well, I've said it a thousand times.
and the answer is, a rational reasonable answer is...
You are here to score points.
You are flapping agian.. [No, I am not flapping..]
a rational reasonable answer is...
Why does the universe exist rather than total non existence,
Nothing, why?
Okay, honestly, will he explain why the universe exists?
You don't believe in God? I'm asking you that question.
Why are you asking me?
Because you don't believe in God.
Because I don't believe in God, I have to explain the universe?
Yes. Let me tell you why, [exactly.]
Let me tell you why.
This is my point; because you guys don't understand the evidence, the universe..
the evidence?
You believe in God...
I know that's the diversion Tactic.
Learn, this is the division tactic, running away from rational enquiry.
God is used to filling the gap. Listen,
[According to science...] Everybody that believe in God,
uses God, explain what they don't know, what they don't understand,
Everything is God does...
Brother, where is the patience that you're going to demonstrate to us?
He doesn't have patience....
No, don't repeat that's what I'm saying
so that he doesn't get away from the hook.
So now, according to our scientific methodology, we see existence of matter and space.
But that doesn't explain the existence of God.
I haven't finished my question yet.
Listen.
Why is there matter and space in existence?
Who knows?
So that is your reasonable answer?
I am mad enough to say I don't know.
What if I told you I know?
But this guy, I can tell you, he will say, God created everything...
What if I told you.... [that's your easy answer] Do you want to know...
Yes from you? Yes.
Okay, so how would you know the answer is correct or not?
What robust criteria have you set up to ascertain
and understand and assess the evidence that I'm going to give you?
First of all, you talk too much.
ascertain and understand... this....
just explain the thing for what all these are...
Let me tell you in simple words then,
because you understand simple language, right?
If I were to tell you why something exists,
how would you understand that what I'm saying is correct?
If it makes sense, [makes sense, Good.]
So how do you determine what makes sense or not?
What criteria do you use?
As long as it's not bullshit, it makes sense.
What is bullshit and what is not?
How do you determine something is and something isn't making sense?
Okay, let me tell you.
What I hate in people is when they say it is written in the Quran.
Who's talking about other people?
No, talk to me.
I'm answering your question. You see...you can't even do...
So why go and talk about other people?
You are so fragile...
you asked me a question and i'm answering
they get offended when you answer the question...
I don't want to talk to this..
So his evidence is the other people? What other people say in their weaknesses..
Why does he keep talking to me? Exactly, so come on this side...
So now talk to me... Go ahead... be a man enough and talk like man to man
What I am saying to this.... what is the Question again...
I'll tell you again.
How do you differentiate between what makes sense and what doesn't?
Don't just tell me all because it's BS.
I need to know a criteria that one can use every single one of us to say that?
Yes, it seems reasonable.
How do we understand and differentiate between
what is sensible and what is not sensible?
Okay.
Common sense.
Let me answer this question. How I have answered this question a thousand times.
When people like you asked me that question..
people like me and people.. [Yes]
So there's an element of already, some kind of judgmental value already.
Why do you feel I'm being judgmental? [People like you.]
That's what it says. People like you.
People like you. Stereotyping, isn't it?
No.
When I say people like you, I mean believers like you.
You are a believer. Are you not a believer? [I'm a Noah.]
You're a believer not a Noah..
I'm telling you, I know God exists.
Exactly.
You believe in the holy Quran...
And what happens is,
whenever I meet people like you, I don't know why you are offended, Right like that,
He's answering the question about
how he assesses between what makes sense and what doesn't.
Go ahead.
I won't answer the way you want me to answer.
The way I answer. [sensibly] Exactly.
Okay. And the thing is this.
I've answered that question a thousand times from people like you.
And they always said to me the same thing.
It is written in the Quran.
And I say, the Quran doesn't mean anything to me.
What was my question I asked?
I'm getting there.
We don't want any kind of waffling beforehand.
I asked a simple question how do we differentiate between
what makes sensible, what makes sense and what doesn't?
Because if I were to give you an answer,
because I asked you a question why does something exist rather than nothing?
Why does the universe exist rather than absolute nothingness?
You said, who knows? I said, what If I tell you, I know?
Then how would you be able to understand
and accept my answer being correct and true?
You need to be able to differentiate
whether my answer is sensible, relevant, appropriate and acceptable.
Okay. Give me your answer if it makes sense...
Brother, How would you differentiate my answer is appropriate, relevant and acceptable?
I haven't heard your answer yet?
What criteria are you going to use to make sure my answer is correct?
My critical thinking. [Critical thinking?]
What does critical thinking involved?
This guy would go on forever... If I say something, He will say something else...
What does critical thinking involved? [Going on all day long] [Good question]
Then define it what it is..
What does critical thinking involved?
He was supposed to answer my question.
But now he's not going to answer it, is he?
Why should I answer each time If I say something.
You said critical thinking.
We want to know what critical thinking is.
I'll protect you, I'll guard you..
So now, what is critical thinking? [Okay]..
I guarantee you now.
Once I start to define critical thinking, you will pick a word in critical thinking.
And said, what is this?
I will go on forever. Let's see.
Go ahead. You understand?
Go ahead. What is critical thinking?
.. That's fine.
What is critical thinking?
[Laughter]
I am tired..
Because this guy .. i thought i was a wind-up artist but this guy's better than me.
Why didn't you answer?
No. Have I said anything that is unreasonable?
This guy is a a wind-up artist. You are.
Every time I say someithing, you pick up...
Have I said anything that is unreasonable? [Nope]
You get beaten up left, right and center. [By Who beaten me up...]
You don't understand even the language and physiology and idioms.
[Intellectually] Never... Do you know who I am.. I am an atheist.
If I tell you why something exists rather than nothing is something that
we can understand by looking at what something is.
Because if something exists now, if something exists today,
there cannot be a time in the distant past where there was absolute nothingness.
Because absolute nothingness has no energy, no potential, no quanta,
no fluctuation, no hadrons laptops and gluons.
I'm sure you know some of these things if you had, you're good.
Very good. Because of absence of everything
means something that exists today could not come from nothingness.
That means there has to be always something.
Something has to exist always.
Now here, we have to now understand what that is then.
If something exists always, there is no beginning of that something.
Correct? Yeah.
That means that's something that made our universe,
a self-aware, possessors of energy.
Nope
Let me finish..
Possessors of energy and will and knowledge.
Because if that something that existed always didn't will and bring this universe
through His power into existence, it will never happen.
Just give you an example.
Imagine you want to make tea at home, right? Tea.
If you don't will to make tea, your teacup,
your water, the milk and the tea and the sugar,
they're not going to assemble by themselves, would they?
They will remain in their places.
When you will to happen, you open your fridge, bring the milk out,
you turn the knob of your cooker, the heater goes on, they ignite.
And now you have fire. Put the kettle on.
But before that, get some water from the sink, turn the tap, the water comes in.
All of this assembly is required before tea is made.
This universe, which is so organized in its incredible position,
harmony and complexity tells us that there is someone
who has assembled all of this by will and by knowledge and by power.
This evidentially them is a proof
that there is a Creator of our universe Who is always there.
And this creator, by necessity, have to be absolute,
because no one brought this creator into existence.
No one gave power to this Creator.
Because The creator, this thing that exists always wasn't existent.
That is why, my friend, why we see something here is
because of a necessary being creator who have brought into existence.
Let's clap for this young man because he has...
But this is what you call philosophical fantasy
I am atheist... and I don't bother with what I don't know.
He doesn't keep me up at night.
I don't waste time.
I'm not afraid of death or afterlife or any other BS..
Are you sure about that? [I am not.]
What happens when you die? The worms come to eat you?
I said I'm not bothered, I'm not...
[So what happens?] Now He asked me what happens. I don't care what happens.
I just told you, I don't care.
And your heart is content with that?
Is your heart content when you don't even know what happens to you after death?
Do you feel peace and tranquility in your heart?
The difference between me and you,
You're you're worried about what happens to you after you die. [Yes, of course]
I don't care about what happens, I'll be dead
...... [You are spiritually dead] I don't believe in spirits.
I keep on saying it all the time.
I don't care what happens to me when I die but you can't accept what I said?
Do you accept now why something exists rather than nothing?
No, forget, that question is too philosophical. [Intellectual]
I think this is the end of conversation. We have given you enough information
to come to the conclusion that atheism is irration, atheism is irrational.
We have just given you a demonstration.
That why atheism is not irrational belief.
All living things die..