hi everyone and welcome this is the
apostate prophet
hope you're all doing well we talk a lot
about how islam is morally very
problematic
how it causes backwardness in today's
world how it's logically flawed
and so on but we could talk endlessly
about these things without getting
anywhere
if we certainly find that the quran has
a very big mistake however
that the quran got something very wrong
that it misinforms people
that it is factually wrong we should
conclude that the quran
and therefore islam is wrong the islamic
belief in concept
is that the quran is the direct spoken
word of
allah the almighty god it is supposed to
be perfect in everything it says
if there is only one mistake then it is
wrong
in fact the quran makes that assertion
itself then do they not reflect upon the
quran
if it had been from any other than allah
they would have found within it much
contradiction
since the quran makes that very clear
let's get right into it without taking
too much
time in chapter 19 the chapter named
maryam
mary the quran makes a very weird
presentation
from verse 16 on it talks about the
virgin mary
the mother of jesus in the christian
faith and tells the story of her
receiving
jesus as a baby without a father while
she is still
a virgin of course the quran tells the
story in a slightly different and
heavily dumbed down way
but in the verses 27 and 28 it gets very
interesting
let's read then she brought him the baby
jesus
to her people carrying him they said oh
mary
you have certainly done a thing unheard
of what they are referring to is that
she suddenly has a baby
without being married which is a great
shame they continue
oh sister of aaron your father was not a
man of evil
nor was your mother unchaste now
there is a big problem in this last
verse
many christians will immediately see
what is wrong here
the quran refers to mary mother of jesus
as sister of aaron mary the mother of
jesus
didn't have a brother named aaron as far
as we know
the bible never mentions such a thing
and no one ever
thought she had such a brother it looks
like the quran is confusing mary with
someone else
right the only aaron we know is the
prophet aaron
who could have only lived more than a
thousand years
before mary mother of jesus and
referring to mary
as sister of aaron from a thousand years
ago
is very bizarre i am apostate prophet
brother
of genghis khan oh there is ahmed
brother of prophet muhammad
yeah this is ridiculous but since this
is pretty confusing
let's find another quran verse where
mary is mentioned
maybe that helps and mary the daughter
of imran
who guarded her chastity so we blew into
her
through our angel and she believed in
the words of
our lord and his scriptures and was the
devoutly obedient
okay this quran verse obviously talks
about
the same mary mother of jesus and now
refers to her as
daughter of imran so who is imran
this is getting very interesting because
muslim apologists
see that there is something wrong here
they claim that imran was
the name of the father of mother mary
so imran was jesus's grandfather on
mary's side
but mary's father's name according to
christian writings
was joachim or joachim and joakim
doesn't sound
like imran at all you're kim
imran you are kim imran
but wait if the quran refers to mary as
sister of aaron
and mary's father's name is imran let's
see what
aaron's thousand three hundred year old
aaron's
father's name was aaron's lineage can be
found in the bible
the sons of kohath were amram ishar
hebron and uzil the children of amram
were aaron moses and
miriam the sons of aaren were nadab
abihu eliazar and
so prophet aaron's father's name was
amram for which the arabic translation
is imran so let's get this straight
prophet aaron had the father called
amaram which is translated into arabic
as
imran and the quran also claims that
mother mary who lived more than thousand
years after that
also had a brother named aaron and a
father
named imran but there is more aaron was
also the brother of moses
and they had a sister named miriam which
sounds like
mariam in the quran this family
lived more than a thousand years before
mary
the mother of jesus who marked the
beginning of christianity 2000 years ago
so mary mother of jesus was alive 2000
years ago
and miriam aaron and amram were alive
more than three thousand years ago and
the quran confuses the mary's here
and thinks that mary mother of jesus
and miriam sister of aaron were one
and the same person this is not a
misunderstanding in reading the quran
this is a huge mistake in the quran but
let's summarize this since it is so
complicated
i see how a desert guy called ahmed got
this wrong
there are two characters known as miriam
and mary in biblical stories
miriam sister of aaron and moses and
daughter of amram
and mary mother of jesus there are at
least one thousand years
between these two women but the author
of the quran obviously thinks
these two people are the same person
mariam that the quran describes as
mother of jesus
sister of aaron daughter of imran and a
virgin
there is really no defense to this at
all but we are also not the first people
to
discover this in fact there is a hadith
a narration
in which this contradiction is mentioned
this is one of those hadith which you
won't hear during your islamic education
because it is simply embarrassing mugi
rabbin shabbat reported
when i came to najran the christians of
najran asked me
you read o sister of haron in the quran
whereas moses was born much before jesus
when i came back to allah's messenger
peace be upon him
i asked him about that whereupon he said
the people of the old age used to give
names to their persons after the names
of apostles
and pious persons who had gone before
them
so muhammad is confronted with this
mistake in the quran but then muhammad
says that it's no mistake
because people in mary's time apparently
referred to each other
with the names of old prophets and
pious people in the past from 300 years
ago and coincidentally they picked the
name aaron here
muhammad is making this up if you can't
tell not only don't we find
any information any reference to such a
practice
in the past at all it is also quite
interesting that the christians
who are far more familiar with
traditions than the new muslims
don't know of such a practice at all and
obviously think that the quran makes a
mistake here
this sounds to me like uh prophet
the christians told me that the quran is
wrong when it calls mary the sister of
aaron because
aaron lived a thousand years before mary
uh
no no no no no it's no it's it's correct
it's
it's correct it's no mistake people used
to do that back then
you know they used to do that are you
doubting the message
no but if all of this is not enough it
gets even more interesting
if we take ibn kathir's exegesis of the
quran
one of the most widely circulated and
respected interpretations of the quran
according to that commentary muhammad's
child bride aisha
who is respected as mother of the
believers and the great scholar of islam
was once confronted with this question
as well
and first she reacted with anger but
when her opponent pointed out
that there is at least a 600 year gap
between mother mary
and aaron she didn't know what to say
and remained silent very awkwardly
as awkwardly silent as many other muslim
apologists react
when they are confronted with this
question so what can we conclude from
this
when i was a muslim and i was already
deep in my skepticism and my research
into
islam i accepted the fact that if there
is one mistake in the quran
because it is considered the perfect
word of allah
then islam is wrong it takes a lot of
effort
thinking and courage to come to that
point but once you are there
and you find such a mistake which
reveals the author of the quran
to be an ignorant person your faith is
shaken
it looks like the quran wasn't authored
by an almighty all-knowing god
it looks like it was authored by a 7th
century man in arabia
who heard a lot of stories from jews and
christians
but he confused those stories because he
wasn't perfectly familiar with them
quite sneaky it definitely looks like
muhammad made all of this up
and he couldn't protect the quran from
containing a major error
and as said if the quran contains such
an error
then it is wrong this is why i don't
have any doubts at all
and why i don't sit down and think
what if islam is right and this is why
i'm quite confident
and want more people to know that islam
is not right
islam is very strong in controlling
and brainwashing indoctrinating
but it is definitely not strong in being
factually right
thanks for watching if you like this
video don't forget to like to subscribe
and to share
most of my videos are not monetized if
you want to see more videos like this
and if you want to help me
and this channel you can support me on
patreon or on apostateprofit.com
i'll be back with even more until then
have a great day
and stay away from isla
you