hi everyone and welcome this is the
apostate prophet
as we all especially the followers of
islam know the quran is the unchanged
perfect eternal and infallible word of
allah allah is almighty all-knowing
and free of any flaw that is the islamic
belief
if you are a muslim or if you are a
muslim
what would you do if you found out that
the quran has very obvious mistakes
that don't even need very much
inspection to call them mistakes
would you look for new and incomplete
explanations to defend your belief
or would you have the courage to doubt
the quran contains a verse that i cited
very often before
and that i will cite very often in the
future i think it's one of the most
important quran verses
chapter 9 verse 30. it reads
the jews say ezra is the son of allah
and the christians say the messiah is
the son of allah
that is their statements from their
mouths they imitated the saying of those
who disbelieved
may allah destroyed them how are they
deluded
if you have any knowledge on the bible
judaism or christianity
you might spot the problem in this verse
right away
i will try to simplify it briefly for
all others
this verse mentions beliefs allegedly
held by jews and christians
such as believing that ezra or jesus
were the sons of allah
or god then it likens them to
disbelievers without specifying what
disbelievers
then in a weird way even though it's
supposed to be the word of allah itself
it says may allah curse them and calls
them deluded
other prominent translations deliver the
same thing
only the cursing and deluded part differ
slightly but the message remains
christians and jews are deluded
sincerely
almighty dude of religion of tolerance
according to islamic belief
allah is the same god of the jews and
the christians
the god of the bible and therefore
whenever the quran says allah
it means the god of the bible too the
quran is pretty much correct about what
christians believe
that the messiah jesus is the son of god
well at least it got that one right
what it is not correct about at all is
the first part of the verse
that jews say ezra is the son of allah
this verse confuses
everyone even muslims so much that you
can see muslims online asking what this
quran verse is
and what we are supposed to do with the
weird information given in this quran
verse
the confusion is very well justified
jews believe in the one god of the bible
jews also believe in the sanctity of
rabbis and prophets
jews do not believe that there is an
actual son of god
according to biblical beliefs ezra is
only a priest
an important one since he played a big
role in restoring the law
and initiating a lot of old and current
jewish practices
in some jewish traditions he was held
higher than in others and seen equal to
moses
but no credible proof at all shows us
any jewish sect that ever
idolized ezra or thought that he was of
any supernatural nature
so the quran verse says jews not many
jews or some jews
it says jews apparently muhammad wanted
to make a quran first that blasts both
christians and jews
because the former verse declares war on
christians and jews
but he didn't really figure out what
jews actually believe in
so he just made something up no one
would notice right
this can be seen as a clear mistake and
ignorance on allah's part
since the quran is supposed to be the
perfect and direct
word of god of allah sorry but muslim
scholars can't accept it of course
because the islamic belief is built upon
the notion that it is perfect it is the
final religion
it is directly from allah and so on and
how could all knowing allah make such a
mistake
the defense they make is that there were
some jews in arabia who apparently
worshipped ezra
but why would the quran first then talk
about jews collectively
would it be accurate to generalize all
muslims because one tiny sect
somewhere in madagascar believes that
the moon was split in two
oh wait most muslims believe that they
make even more ridiculous claims
one that i have seen online on a
fundamentalist islamic page
is that when this quran verse was
revealed there was no major reaction
among the jews in arabia
who must have heard of this verse and
therefore the quran was apparently right
so we know that the statement in this
quran verse is objectively wrong
but because jews didn't collectively
oppose to this statement
the statement becomes right that's like
me saying allah doesn't exist
if no muslim comes to me and objects to
my statement
it means that it's universally correct
that allah does not
exist that's how allah and muhammad's
logic work apparently
according to those islamic scholars a
third claim made by respected early
scholar al-muardi
was just like the second one but also
shamelessly claimed
that because jews didn't object to this
verse collectively
it was right and it was attributed to
all jews
and all jews shared the sin of the
statement
wow in this case if i
say that muslims are terrorists and no
muslim finds me and makes an objection
to that
that means that all muslims are
terrorists and they need to be judged
accordingly
this is not an exaggerated comparison if
you think about the revelation of the
quran
it was not a book that was written and
sent to all people
over the world it was just spoken by a
loonie merchant in arabia
and turned into a book only after
muhammad's death
i'm sure if 50 jews came and objected to
muhammad saying such a wrong thing
we would have never learned of that
because all sources about the beginnings
of
islam are islamic sources another
explanation
that non-muslims think of which sounds
reasonable to me too
is that muhammad just had a huge
misunderstanding here in jewish
tradition
the title son of god or child of god
was used as a title of honor and piety
if someone was very pious
respected and good they would be called
son of god by the regular jews
that was just a jewish way of speaking
it didn't mean literally that
this person is the offspring of god
similarly jews and many christians call
themselves children of god
that doesn't mean they are all god's
semen walking around on earth it just
means they belong to god
muhammad apparently heard that and
didn't even know what jews mean when
they say such things
he just made up his opinion a wrong
opinion
and sold it as a last divine message a
horribly embarrassing and wrong one
as said we have no credible evidence at
all to prove that ever that any jewish
tribe ever
held such a belief that ezra was the son
of god
muslims try to explain nowadays that
some did but there is no
source to that there is no evidence and
why would we trust islamic scholars
islamic scholars try everything to
defend islam
truth is not their objective islam is
there is no proof but even if some jews
had had such a belief
one must be completely hypocritical to
claim that this quran verse is
totally correct because some jews
somewhere in arabia
like a 0.00001
percent of jews had such a belief at
some point
also claiming that jews believed in such
a thing
that ezra was the son of god is like
claiming that
some some muslims believed that muhammad
was the
um adopted disliked
disabled son of god of allah lastly if
we were to examine if the quran verse is
just using a confusing language
we could make all of this much easier we
can find the same allegation
in an authentic hadith about the day of
judgment
some companion of muhammad asks him
about the day of judgment
then muhammad goes on and explains what
happens to christians and jews first
according to muhammad allah will ask all
christians what they worshiped
and they will answer with jesus and will
be punished for that
as for the jews quote then the jews
would be summoned
and it would be said to them what did
you worship
they will say we worshipped usair ezra
son of allah it would be said to them
you tell
a lie no allah they are not lying
you're just muhammad's alter ego and
muhammad just made all of this
up dear muslims do you really want to
follow this religion that claims to be
flawless and wise in its message
and then make such a huge mistake that
can't be explained in any reasonable way
what are you going to do with this
information do you want to find an
explanation that you would never accept
if it wasn't defending islam when is it
time to leave this religion behind
just be honest to yourself have some
courage and think for yourself
then it won't take much time believe me
thanks for watching
if you like this video please don't
forget to like to subscribe and to share
my videos are not monetized so you can
watch everything without ads
if you want to support me and my cause
you can support me on patreon
the link is below in the description i
appreciate all your support
very very much thanks again for watching
have a great weekend and stay away from
islam
you