a 50-year-old Cold Case homicide with ties to Mid
Michigan appears to be solved a man has been arrested for the stabbing death of
Nancy Anderson who at one time lived in Bay City with her family [Music]
thank you [Music]
hello everyone and welcome back to another True Crime Mysteries video thank you all for being here
today we're discussing four more solved cold cases but with that being said let's get into it
number one Nancy Elaine Anderson
on January 7th 1972 19 year old Nancy Anderson was in her apartment getting a
demonstration from two silverware salesmen when her roommate came home around 2 30 pm
her roommate 18 year old Jody Spooner joined as the men finished with neither woman buying any
silverware Jody then went to her room to have a nap Jody woke up around 5pm she went to the
kitchen when she noticed that water was running in Nancy's bathroom which he thought was odd as
she thought Nancy would have left for work by that time she discovered Nancy's bedroom door
ajar and found Nancy on the bedroom floor bloody Jody immediately went to a neighbor's apartment
and said they needed to call 9-1-1 because Nancy had killed herself their apartment was in Waikiki
Hawaii and Nancy had just moved there in October 1971 to have some time before she started college
she was a 1970 John Glenn High School graduate in Bay City Michigan she had just returned from
a trip home to visit family for Christmas and New Year Nancy worked at a McDonald's and was
known to be very friendly to anyone she met when police arrived they discovered that Nancy had
multiple stab wounds on her neck chest Stomach back and sides she also had what looked like
defensive wounds which for police eliminated the chance that they were self-inflicted
please collected evidence including several bloody towels and multiple sets of fingerprints
police interviewed Jody who said that she'd heard something odd around 4 15 PM but hadn't thought
much about it because there weren't any further disturbances after that she also believed that
all the doors had been locked including Jody's bedroom please talk to several people in the
surrounding area but no one had heard or seen anything suspicious neighbors and acquaintances
of Nancy said that she'd been known to be very friendly and often had men come over or to go out
on several dates since moving to Hawaii police had found evidence that Nancy had opened a bank
account at the Bank of Hawaii that day when they talked to the teller who had assisted her they
said that she'd arrived sometime around 2 15 to 3 P.M but believed it to be closer to 3 P.M after
the police walked back to the apartment they put Nancy's time of death between 3 10 p.m and 5 15 pm
at first the two salesmen were suspects they were identified as Parker Graham and Jeffrey
Alward and they volunteered fingerprints and took polygraphs eliminating them as Suspects
other friends ex-boyfriends and co-workers in both Nancy and Jody's life were interviewed most giving
fingerprints and taking polygraphs eliminating them as suspects as well during the autopsy it was
discovered that Nancy had been stabbed 60 times with a total of 63 wounds three being Exit Wounds
the murder weapon was believed to be a knife 10 millimeters wide and six millimeters long
after months of no leads Nancy's case went cold in 2001 a DNA profile was made of the blood samples
found in 1972 three different DNA profiles were found two male and one female between
2001 and 2004 all past suspects DNA was tested and were all eliminated as possibilities again
law enforcement in Honolulu also used DNA that they sent to parabon nanolabs which specializes
in DNA phenotyping which is the type of processing of predicting physical appearances and ancestry
from unidentified DNA evidence they were able to produce a projected sketch of the suspect
in December of 2021 Hawaii Cold Case detectives got their first break in the case in almost 50
years an anonymous tip came in that Tudor cherila should be a suspect in the case
the suspect now 77 years old was a lawyer in Reno Nevada and had previously Run for
the Nevada Supreme Court in 1972 sharilla had lived less than three miles from Nancy
Anderson at the time he was working as a graduate assistant attorney
in 1995 shirella was charged with kidnapping and assaulting a woman that he was in a relationship
with she alleged that he had severely beaten her trying to render her unconscious to
sexually assault her she managed to escape and press charges but the case was never convicted
the Hawaii Police Department in February 2022 requested the help of the Reno Police
in getting a sample of sharila's DNA but they were unsuccessful in getting the DNA covertly
so in March of 2022 they tried something different and they enlisted jarilla's son and got DNA from
him the following month in April he provided the sample and his identity was confirmed
a warrant was issued on September 1st to collect DNA from sharila himself on September 6th
they finally got the sample two days after law enforcement collected the sample tutor sharilla
attempted suicide however he was found in time and sent to the hospital where he made a full recovery
on September 12th it was confirmed that the DNA founded the scene was sharillas
he was arrested and held in Reno Nevada without bail Hawaii authorities are
working on extraditing him and that hearing is set for early December
number two George Clarence Seitz
it was in early March 2019 when NYPD detectives got a phone call from an anonymous tipster
the now adult said that when she was 11 years old she saw her mother and
stepfather burying black garbage bags in their backyard in 1976. the tipster
believed that the garbage bags contain the body of a person and gave the exact location
on March 12 2019 investigators began searching the property and human remains were discovered
under a concrete slab in the backyard of a home on 11 15th Street in Richmond Hill Queens New York
it was determined the body had been dismembered at the neck shoulders and hips
over the next few years NYPD and the FBI worked to identify the man eventually they would use
DNA from the remains to attempt to identify him using genetic genealogy in 2021 they were
able to finally identify him and in doing so were one step closer to solving his murder
the man was identified as 81 year old world war one vet George Clarence Seitz who on December
10 1976 had left his home in Jamaica Queens to go get a haircut and was never heard from again
once George Seitz was identified police did extensive interviews and scoured records trying
to find as much evidence as they could to point to a suspect and they found a suspect and it was the
owner of a barber shop that cites frequented 74 year old Martin Motta was identified and confessed
he was later charged with second-degree murder Mata had stated that he had killed sites and
robbed him for the seven to eight thousand dollars he had on him Seitz was known to
distrust banks for more times and he was known to carry large sums of money on him at all times
Mata claimed that he stabbed sights in the head dismembered his body and buried it in the backyard
he was arrested without incident in October 2022 he pled guilty to first degree manslaughter after
taking a plea agreement he was sentenced to 20 years in prison frankly you're like Queen's own
Jeffrey Donald White terrible years instead of getting a haircut he got robbed killed dismembered
and buried in the backyard where nobody would find him for 45 years when my mother died never knowing
what had happened to her brother my hope is that each day you spend in prison you will think of
your evil actions the suffering my uncle must have endured Melinda Katz district attorney for
Queens set at a press conference quote after 46 years a veteran of first world war gets Justice
the successes of modern technology and forensics made it possible for us to not only identify the
remains of the victim but also to find any Witnesses when I became district attorney I
created the Cold Case unit for cases such as this where time seems to be the enemy time allowed
forensic genetic genealogy and our investigators to catch up to this defendant end quote
number three Claire K Holman
on March 24 1994 a friend and neighbor came to deliver mail to her senior neighbor Claire K
Holman in berazio Springs San Diego California she knocked on the door but there was no answer
which was odd she peeked into one of the front windows and saw that the home inside was ransacked
Miss K Holman was found deceased in her home the 72 year old Widow and former hairdresser had owned
a shop in town for many years but was now retired there were no signs of force entry in her home so
investigators believe that she either knew her attacker or they were familiar with her routine
an autopsy showed that she had been strangled with a rope or cord and
her death was ruled a homicide after months of investigation and no leads her case went cold
in 2003 the San Diego County Sheriff's Department got a DNA profile from the evidence that was
discovered at the scene they entered the results into CODIS the federal database of
DNA for unsolved crimes but they didn't get any matches from that in March of 2021 they
would try again but this time with genetic genealogy in the hopes of finding a suspect
the evidence from the crime scene was re-examined and they found a single hair with foreign male DNA
with that they were able to find 118 distant relatives of the suspect for several months
they combed through and narrowed down all of the relatives until they honed in on a single suspect
in September 2022 it was announced that a suspect had been identified Jerry Dwayne
Robinson Robinson had been a plumber in the area and may have worked for Claire Holman on
occasion Robinson died 15 years ago in 2007 from cancer a paternity test was used to confirm the
DNA from the suspect matched Robinsons at the time of the killing he was 51 years old and is
also believed the motive was robbery and sexual assault both the Holmen and Robinson families
have been informed and the San Diego County Sheriff's Department considers the case closed
number four Sandra d Felice
it was the day after Christmas in 1980 when 25 year old Sandra t Felice was found in her
Las Vegas home brutally beaten to death and sexually assaulted around 9 30 pm
she was found in her bed under the covers she lived at the house with a roommate and her
three-year-old daughter fortunately the daughter was not at home at the time she had been staying
with her grandparents investigators collected a vast quantity of evidence including foreign
dark hairs a glass with a fingerprint and a sexual assault kit the young mother was recently divorced
and worked as a waitress to support herself and her daughter her ex-husband was initially
the lead suspect but was quickly cleared days of the investigation turned to months which
turned to years and Sandra's case went cold in December of 2021 the Las Vegas Cold Case unit
got a call from Sandra's daughter now in her 40s asking for any updates on her mother's case this
made Cold Case detectives re-examine the case with fresh eyes they found fingernail scrapings
under Sandra's sexual assault kit that could now be tested with new DNA technology available
they found male DNA in the sample the sample pointed to a suspect 64 year old Paul Nuttall
after Paul Nuttall was taken into custody Mike Cold Case investigators had the pleasure of
making the one phone call that every Cold Case detective wants to make and that was the call
the family members specifically Sandra d Felice's daughter and it let her know that there had been a
development in the case and that we had arrested the suspect who's responsible for the murder
Sandra d Felice I'm hopeful that in some way shape or form this provides some sort
of closure for the family and ultimately results in some type of closure and justice for Sandra
nuttle had been detained for questioning in the original investigation but had been released
police went and spoke with nettle showing him a picture of Sandra and asking if he
remembered her about her murder he responded by saying he didn't know what they were talking
about and at that time they also got a DNA sample from Nuttall he had been the initial
suspect as his fingerprints had been found on the glass received from Sandra's house
Sandra's roommate was a friend of nettle at the time and she explained that she had given Nuttall
the drink when he had asked for a place to stay for the night as he had nowhere else to go but
she had told him no because Sandra was sleeping and she didn't know him well the roommate claimed
that she escorted him out of the house before leaving as well the roommate is now deceased
not all would have been 21 years old at the time the DNA was a confirmed match for Nuttall and he
was arrested he's being held without bail and is currently waiting for his next court appearance
they believe sexual assault and robbery was the motive homicide Lieutenant Jason Johnson said
in a statement to the media quote after he was taken into custody my Cold Case investigators had
the pleasure of making the one phone call that every Cold Case detective wants to make they
were able to inform to Felice's daughter the man suspected of murdering her mother was in custody
there is a concern that nettle has dementia and will be undergoing evaluations before the
trial lvmpd is looking to see if there are any more victims linked to nettle who has resided
in Las Vegas his whole life after four decades Sandra de police say will finally get Justice
well that is it for this video as always thank you so much for watching if you like this content
and want to do over here please don't forget to subscribe and hit the notification Bell
so you don't miss my next upload you can give this video a like if you enjoyed the content
that would be much appreciated as it helps the channel to grow we also have Channel membership
patreon if you want to get more behind the scene content as well as exclusive
content or just to support the channel in the description box of this video you also
find links to all my socials to connect with me as well as other goodies but that is it for
me thank you so much for being here I will see you on the next one bye for now foreign [Music]