- Hello there.
I'm Colby Rebel.
I am a professional psychic medium.
- Hi, I'm Elisabeth South.
I'm a private detective with Kay and Associates.
- And, I have a job today.
- Today, we're gonna find out who the real person is
that committed a crime.
Which one of these guys is telling the truth?
I feel totally fine going head-to-head with a psychic.
If she's the best psychic in the world,
I think it's interesting
and I'd like to talk to her afterwards.
(suspenseful music)
- Let us see what we have here.
- All right, let's see how serious this crime is.
- When I was 17,
I got caught trying to throw a giant coed party
at my parents' house.
- While they were staying 15 minutes away.
- All right, well, obviously, not the brightest criminal
we've got back here,
but, let's see how this plays out.
(laughs)
- How funny, the same thing happened to me.
Let's see who is my sister or brother in crime.
- Here's the deal, look, lil' petite one here.
She looks like she'd be throwing a party
while the parents are 15 minutes away,
so, I don't think it's her.
- You look kind of malicious.
I don't know why you're like mean mugging me,
like, can you smile a little bit?
What's this?
He's like, don't ask me questions.
- I think we got little miss innocent, college girl here,
or here, I'm so sweet, smart, got my glasses on,
it couldn't 'a been me.
So, these are my initial feelings.
We'll see how they go.
- Hello.
- Hi there, what's you first name?
- Megan.
So, what did your parents do when they found out?
- I don't know (laughs).
I didn't do it.
- Oh, you didn't do it.
Okay.
- So, your parents caught you, or who caught you?
- No one caught me doing anything.
'Cause I didn't do anything (laughs).
- You're just trying to tell me that this was not you?
- Correct.
- How was the party?
- Really fun.
- Really fun?
So how could the party be really fun,
if you just said you didn't do it?
- I don't know.
I feel like every question you ask
is just going to be me going, I don't know.
I didn't do it.
- And then, where were your parents?
- When?
- Oh, at the time of the party?
If they were 15 minutes away, where we they?
- I don't know what party.
- Okay, all right.
- (laughs) This is so intense.
- And so, are your parents still together?
- Yeah.
- Tell me about how they were, their personalities with you.
- My dad is like the funny one,
and my mom is like the emotional, therapisty sorta one.
- And when you were 17, you were still in high school.
- Mm-hmm.
- So, when you had the party,
what made you decide that you could have the party?
- You know, doesn't make a lotta sense, so, I don't know.
- What would you describe their mantra
on raising a child as?
- Very, again, open, loving, understanding.
- All right, so,
they're not gonna be like, really strict with things.
- Yeah.
That's what made it so easy to just go do what I wanted.
- I'm so jealous.
My parents were so strict.
I had to lie about every,
I think I'd lied about what I thought, actually.
- But, you had the party, you weren't going to a party.
- Didn't have the party.
- Well that says you had the party.
- It doesn't.
It says, does it say Megan?
- I don't know.
You tell me.
You didn't even look at it.
- But you read it (laughs).
- (laughs) All right, thank you Megan.
- Okay, thanks.
- I'm gonna go with you, Honey.
What's your first name?
- Merle.
All right Merle, so tell me about how good or bad,
or what you didn't do or what you did.
- I did.
I did.
- What'd you do?
- I was 17, I had never thrown a party.
I was kind of like, the friend
who would like, go to my other friend's house.
They were like, the hosts.
So, I was like, I need to do this once
while I'm in high school.
- And then, where were your parents?
- My mom and my dad were at a hotel.
They were like, trying to rekindle things.
- So, are they divorced now?
- Yes.
- Did they do this often?
- No, it wasn't.
It was like kinda the rough patch, like,
it was getting pretty bad.
- Oh, this is so bad.
All right, go ahead, tell me about your fun party story.
- Okay, that's when I was like, all right,
I'm gonna through a party.
There was a guy who's like, he's in college now,
and he's a couple years older,
and I really wanted him to come,
'cause I wanted to hang out with him.
- You wanted to hang out with him.
- Yeah, so me and like, three of my friends,
Tiffany, Shayna, and Kathryn,
all were like, all right, tonight's the tonight.
- Did you get caught having the party?
- Yeah.
- Well how?
- Well, because of, so, I have an old dog,
or, we did have an old dog that passed away.
Her name was Lily and, so, she was sick,
and my mom wanted to come back and check on her.
She wanted to make sure that we like, gave her medicine
and like, took care of her.
And we almost got her to leave,
but then she decided to come in anyway.
- Why didn't she just text you to check on Lily?
- She had.
She'd actually called me three times,
but, I was so busy like, putting vodka in the freezer
and like, trying to spruce up the place,
that I just like, didn't have my phone,
and so, I didn't, I didn't see it.
- And how did your dad react?
- My dad is like, kinda more,
he knows my mom and I are super, super close,
like, we're fine, but he's kinda similar to your dynamic,
where he's like, the funnier one,
and so he knows I'm gonna listen to my mom more than him,
and he was like, disappointed
but, he wasn't like, you're the worst kid ever.
'Cause I'd never done it before.
- You're pretty good kid other than that?
- I was a pretty good kid.
- Did the boy come?
- The boy did come.
(Colby laughs)
But then they had to stop, because I got in trouble,
so like, nothing ended up happening.
- But with the party though,
how long did the party go on before you got caught?
- I would say probably like, an hour and a half, hour.
It coulda been two hours,
but, like, there weren't a ton of people there
for the first hour so, it kinda like, was just getting going
when my mom came back.
- I might bring you back down to sit down.
I'm good on you.
- Cool.
- Hi, Hair.
- Hi.
- What's your first name?
- Hair.
Rachel.
- I'm guessing you're gonna tell me
you were guilty for something.
- Oh, I'm like, guilty for a lot.
No, I did have a party in high school
that I did get caught trying to make,
I mean, the moment in which I got caught
wasn't that bad to me,
because I had thrown parties before.
This one was bad
because I was inviting a lot of people to it.
- What made you decide to have a party?
- So, my neighbor, who's like a cool girl,
and so, she moved in when I was like, 13
and I always wanted to do things to like, impress her.
So, she was friends with my cousin,
and my cousin was coming over
and they decided to talk about this,
and, I definitely went along with it.
- So, how'd you get caught?
- Okay, so they had went to my cousin's house for the night.
And like, my older cousin was over with me, my cousin Erin.
But her younger brother they went to like, babysit
because their parents had left
but then the parents came back
because they had booked the wrong date.
And so, my parents came back to the house,
and it was like, already an hour or two after they had left.
So, there was only a couple of people over.
- How many people were there?
- Okay, so, the silver lining is that I got caught
before like, the massive amount of people are coming,
so, there was only like, 25 people there.
So I was already in trouble for that.
- When they came back, they were just kinda disappointed
and that's it.
You didn't really get in trouble or--
- No, they were really mad about it.
I think, I don't know how exactly they had found out
that like, dudes were coming,
but I think it was either like, they walked in
and somebody was on the phone,
or like, somebody came to the door
like, while they were in the house,
getting pissed about this crap.
And that's when like, they were like,
who the (bleep) are these?
You know what I mean?
There was like, six guys that showed up,
and they were like, what were you doing?
- And, what was the punishment?
- I don't know.
I was grounded for like, a couple of weeks,
but, I mean, it was like, a screaming thing
in front of like, 25 people.
- All right, would you do it again?
- Yeah.
I mean, I got grounded for like, I don't know,
for like, three weeks, like, what, I don't care.
- Got it.
Okay, thank you.
- Thank you.
- Sir.
The very happy one.
- (laughs) How are you doing?
- Yeah, trying to be so quiet.
- I know, trying to play the part.
- I don't know what story you're gonna tell me so I guess,
give it to me.
- All right, so, this was around October.
I was 17 and, I wanted to throw a costume party.
I have two older brothers but, they didn't want to do it,
'cause they knew my parents were gonna be gone for,
not sure how long,
'cause it was just at my godfather's house.
So, I was like, you know what?
Whatever, I'm just gonna throw it.
- And did you get in trouble?
- I did.
- What was your punishment?
- Well my dad was one of those like, in front of my mom,
he had to like, look mad,
and then, when it was just him and I, he's like,
"Was it fun?"
I was like, "Yeah it was."
- Why were they at your godparents' house?
- They just throw random like, nights drinking
with my parents sometimes.
- How did they catch you?
- They were at my godfather's house,
and, they just randomly came home.
I was a little intoxicated and then, my friend was like,
"Yo, yo, yo, your parent's here."
I turned around,
my mom's face just like, jaw dropped and all.
- And so, it was just you who put it together,
and your brother--
- They bought the alcohol for me.
- Your older brother?
- Yeah.
- Okay, so they bought you the alcohol,
and then what happened?
- I mean, they used it as an excuse to party too,
but they didn't wanna be involved
in the ones, like starting it, like, the party.
So, when they told my parents,
they had nothing to do with it.
- Why did they randomly come home though?
- My dad sometimes wants to come home, just go to sleep,
'cause he works a lot, so it was like, 11 at night,
and he just came home.
- What was your punishment?
- My mom just didn't talk to me for a week,
and, I mean, I know it's not that bad,
but when your mom doesn't talk to you,
like, you can't, you literally can't do anything really.
- Go ahead, stand back up.
So glad you got nice.
Was so awkward for a minute.
- I feel pretty good.
There's definitely some good little liars back here,
that's for sure.
- I think I know who it is.
- I am not quite sure if I know who had the party yet.
- So now, it is time for the big reveal,
and, to see if either of us got this right.
(Colby and Elisabeth laughing)
- Do you feel confident?
- No.
This one, I thought was hard.
They're really convincing, these guys,
but, we're gonna give it a go, right?
- We're gonna show this?
- Yes.
Megan.
- Merle.
You know, Megan I got zero information from.
It was a hard one.
- Yeah, she--
- She's like, "I just didn't do it."
Well, have you done anything?
"Nope."
- "I don't have parties.
"I don't drink."
- I know! (laughs)
- "I've never seen a can of beer in my life."
I could be totally wrong, but, I just kept hearing it's her.
It's definitely not the guy.
There's no way.
It's not him.
- If it's him, I'm gonna laugh,
'cause I was like, yeah, it's not him.
- [Host] Okay, now, we're--
- Okay, I don't know if I could look.
Okay, culprit.
- [Host] Step forward.
(Colby screams)
- You know, it's really hard to prove a negative.
That's why I'm just gonna say like,
"Okay, well tell me about your history."
- I told a lot of truths, like, I never got in trouble.
I basically never drank,
so I had no good reason to throw a party,
but my parents were going 15 minutes away
to rekindle the romance
and, I just got convinced into it by some bad friends.
I had invited like, 20 people coed.
We had four handles of vodka and a rack of beer.
And I had a sick dog.
I told Merle.
- Did you just, yeah--
- How Merle stole it.
- I wanna let you know, I don't even like you now.
- Wait, wait, so, let's get this straight.
Merle is a liar and a thief.
- And she can copy anything.
She's not even original.
- Yes.
Way to go Merle.
- I'm just kidding.
- My name is Megan and when I was 17,
I got caught trying to throw a giant coed party
when my parents were staying 15 minutes away.
(suspenseful music)