- What's up guys,
Saf here on SuperSaf TV and welcome to another SuperSaf
style camera comparison,
this time, it is between the Google Pixel 5
and the Samsung Galaxy S20 FE.
These are priced similarly
so I thought it would be a good comparison to do.
We're using the front facing cameras on both devices
but we'll be testing out all aspects of the cameras,
front facing, rear facing,
images, video, low light.
Do also look out for the audio icon
in the corner of the screen that will tell you
which device the audio is coming from
and I'll also try to leave some timestamps down below,
because this will be an in-depth long video.
Current using the front facing cameras,
we can film at 4K
from the S20 FE but only 1080P from the Pixel.
Come on Google,
you should have given us 4K.
I'm going to test out stabilization
but I'm going to switch to 1080p on both
just to make things fair for front facing stabilization.
All right, so for the stabilization test,
we're at 1080p on both devices,
I am walking
and I'm going to now run.
We're now testing video from the rear facing cameras.
On both devices, we are at 4K, 30 frames per second
and we're going to test out stabilization
at 4K so I'm just walking right now.
Generally, if you're vlogging, this is what you'd be doing
and just to test a bit of an extreme,
we're just going to run.
(car engine revs)
Now we can go to the ultra wide cameras on both
and again, we are at 4K,
we can see what the difference is like here
and we're going to test out stabilization
with the ultra-wide cameras so once again,
just a light walk
and now a run.
The final thing we're going to test for video is the zoom.
So we do have three times optical zoom
on the
S20 FE.
We've got digital zoom on the Pixel
so we're at three times of both right now,
now, we can go in further on the Samsung
up to 12 times,
you can only go up to five times
at the Pixel.
A quick test at 4K, 60 frames, a second as well.
For those of you who are interested in seeing that,
we're walking right now
and just for a quick extreme stabilization test,
(cars rev past)
Quick low light video test for those interested.
Note the text.
Move slightly more.
I'm just going to walk a little bit
for light video.
Quick auto focus test on the Pixel 5,
very, very fast.
Same test on the FE,
also seems to be doing fine.
So that was the video.
Before we move on to images,
if you are liking what you're seeing so far
and you want to see more videos like this,
then be sure to subscribe and hit that bell icon,
it will mean a lot to me.
Let's now have a look at what we're working with.
So for the front facing cameras,
the S20 FE does have a high resolution
but generally you're going to be shooting at
around 10 megaPixels anyway,
so that does make it quite similar
and for the rear facing cameras,
we have a dual rear facing camera
on the Pixel, on the S20 FE,
We actually have three rear facing cameras.
So both have a primary camera
as well as an ultra wide camera.
The Pixel does have a high resolution ultra-wide camera,
but S20 FE actually has a much wider field of view
and the S20 FE also has a 3X zoom camera,
a dedicated optical zoom camera,
this is something that you don't have on the Pixel.
Now all images that you see have been shot
on automatic to keep things as fair as possible
however, the S20 FE does have a pro photo
as well as a pro video mode.
So if you are somebody who likes to tweak your settings
and things like that,
that option is available out of the box,
straight away on the S20 FE.
Right, now let's have a look at the images.
So when it comes to the primary camera,
I think both perform really, really well in good lights.
We do see some differences however.
The S20 FE does tend to go more towards the vibrant side,
it does pull out the colors a little bit more.
On this example,
you can see that there is a hint of blue in the clouds,
which really wasn't there 'cause it was a very gray day
but nevertheless, the S20 FE tries to give you
what some may call a bit more of a pleasing shot,
whereas the Pixel does that give you much more natural tones
and here's another shot.
Here, I do prefer the Pixel.
If we look towards where the sun is coming from from,
we are getting some pink color coming on the S20 FE
but the Pixel is overall, I think, doing a better job
but nevertheless, both are pretty decent here.
Now here's a situation with very tricky dynamic range.
We've got a lot of sunlight coming in from the background
and here I do prefer the Pixel,
which has maintained the highlights in the clouds more
compared to the S20 FE while still having detail
in the foreground in the shadow areas.
So I did find myself leaning more towards the Pixel
on lots of outdoor shots with the primary camera.
However, as soon as we switched to the ultra-wide camera,
for me, it was a very easy pick with the S20 FE
and that is because we get a much wider field of view
and for me,
that's really what ultra wide cameras are about,
capturing a lot more into your shots.
Here's another example.
I just think the S20 FE
is giving you a much more pleasing shot
with that ultra wide camera
and I also found that it does give you better dynamic range.
So here you can see
that that is the same tricky situation
where you've got a lot of light coming from the background
but the S20 FE balanced that much better
compared to the Pixel.
Another advantage that you do get on the S20 FE
is that optical zoom camera.
So here is a shot 2X on the Pixel,
3X on the S20 FE,
these are just the standard buttons that you get,
so I just thought let's just keep it fair.
And the S20 FE, a much, much sharper image.
Now we can go to the maximum digital zoom of the Pixel,
which is 7X and if you compare that to, say, the 10X
of the S20 FE,
the S20 FE, much cleaner,
you can actually read the sign over here,
whereas you really can't make out the text on the Pixel.
On the S20 FE, you can go in even further though.
So you can go in 20X and even up to 30X.
Now, I'm not somebody who really shoots at 20 or 30X,
I think the results are not really usable
when it comes to sharing images on social media
and things like that but hey, they can be useful
if maybe you need to read a sign in the distance,
however, zoom, I mean, hands down the S20 FE.
Here's another example so this is standard.
Then we go to 3X on both,
you can notice that the S20 FE
is giving you a much sharper image.
Then if you go to 7X on the Pixel versus 10X,
that is a really good shot actually.
I'm very impressed with 10X zoom on the S20 FE.
Now can go even further.
So here is 20X and it's still a decent image I got to say,
it's a decent image.
I personally wouldn't go over 10X but even at 20X,
you're getting a decent image
and yes, the S20 FE gets a clear, clear win
when it comes to zoom.
Now for low light, things are a little bit more interesting.
So here, I think do prefer the S20 FE,
I think the colors are better maintained.
The Pixel is a bit more on the yellow side
and if you look towards the text,
the S20 FE does seem to be sharper.
So I do prefer the S20 FE here.
Now, if you use the ultra-wide cameras,
the S20 FE does seem to be sharper
but there's a lot of artifacting in the clouds.
So there is noise on the Pixel
but the S20 FE is doing some processing
and that's really obvious in the clouds
so I think I'm going to call this one a bit of a draw.
Now, this is a very tricky situation
because we've got a dark environment
but we've got a lot of light coming here
from this Bentley showroom
and here, the S20 FE doing much better.
You can see a lot more of those details inside the showroom,
it's not blown things out like the Pixel has.
Now using the ultra wide cameras in low light,
the S20 FE does seem to be doing a better job
with the showroom but again,
there is a lot of that processed artifacting going on
in the clouds whereas the Pixel, although it is noisy,
it's not giving you anything that looks quite artificial.
Now in indoor low light shots,
I do prefer the Pixel here actually.
It's a brighter image,
you've got more shadow detail.
So this is interesting,
it looks like the Pixel performs better indoors
in lower lights whereas the S20 FE
seems to overall perform better outdoors in low light.
Now let's look at some portraits.
So we actually have some key differences here because
the S20 FE actually gives you a wider angle of view
so it is using that primary camera.
The Pixel is trying to give you
more of a traditional portrait.
So it is cropping in
and I do prefer this angular view on the Pixel
a lot more compared to the S20 FE
but this might come down to your personal preference.
Now, in terms of edges
and in terms of the portraits themselves,
I think both are doing a really good job.
They have both got the area in between my arm
and just generally very, very good, happy with this.
The Pixel also gives you a 1.3 times crop
to give you even more of a portrait look,
this is something again that I do like.
It's not as sharp as the main one
but again, I do like having this option,
this is something that you don't have on the S20 FE.
Here's another portrait, once again,
the differences in angle
but I just want you to look at the edges,
I think both are doing a very, very good job.
I do prefer the Pixel here.
If you look at my skin tones,
they are much better maintained.
The S20 FE is going more towards that yellow side
because I am under direct sunlight
and this is something that I noticed
Samsung phones do a lot
if you are on direct sunlight.
Once again the Pixel does allow you to get
that further crop which gives you more of a portrait look
which I do like.
Again, it's not as sharp, I would say
as the main image but I do like having that option.
Now let's look at some selfies
and for selfies I mean,
generally it was pretty much an easy pick for me.
I think the Pixel just takes very, very good selfies.
Skin tones are much more accurate.
Here you can see that Samsung is doing its traditional thing
where it is softening up the skin a little bit
even when you do switch off beauty mode
and it is making me look fairer than I actually am,
which I am definitely not a fan of.
Now here is another example.
Once again, we do have a bit of sunlight coming in.
So the S20 FE has put me more on the yellow side
whereas the Pixel has maintained my natural brown color
which I am proud of.
So, the Pixel definitely for me is doing better here.
Now, this is a very tricky situation.
We obviously have a lot of light coming in
from the background and both cameras
have handled things very differently.
So in the S20 FE defense,
it has exposed the background correctly
so it's not blown anything out,
but then you can barely see me
because I am completely in the shadows
whereas the Pixel has kind of noticed that,
hey, this is a person
so let me prioritize the exposure of the person
rather than the background.
So although it has blown out
things in the background a little bit,
I do prefer this image much more because, hey,
at least you can see me.
Now looking at portraits,
I think in terms of edges, both are doing okay overall.
I do see some issues near my sunglasses
but again, I just prefer the Pixel image a lot more.
It is a lot sharper
and it does give you much more accurate colors.
Here's another example.
Now here, the Pixel has kind of given a bit of a hue
to my top, I think the black on my top is better here
on the S20 FE in terms of edges,
I think both are doing an overall good job.
The Pixel once again, very, very sharp as it does.
Now, finally, some low light selfies,
so here's using both smartphones just like that
and the Pixel doing better here,
it's a sharper image overall.
The S20 FE quite soft
and it has washed things out quite a bit.
Now both smartphones do have the night mode
from the front facing camera as well
which I tend not to use that much
because you have to kind of like stay still
for a good few seconds while it captures everything,
which is a little bit weird to do
but here, the S20 FE I think is doing a better job.
It's a sharper image.
In capturing that longer exposure,
the Pixel has bled things out a little bit.
Now, when it comes to the front facing flash,
Samsung devices generally
tend to kind of like wash everything out,
give you a big flash.
So you can see, even though there is more light
in the foreground, I'm not a fan of the shot,
I do look very washed out.
Whereas the Pixel is actually giving a very, very good
low light front facing shot so I do prefer the Pixel here.
Right so those are the results.
What are my conclusions?
Well, overall, I think both did do really good.
Primary camera images I think both are very, very good
although I did lean towards the Pixel more
because of the more natural colors,
whereas the S20 FE, which some of you may prefer
does go towards more vibrant colors.
Now, the ultra-wide camera,
it was the S20 FE for me, you've got a wider field of view,
you've also got overall better dynamic range,
zoom, again, just a clear win for the S20 FE,
you've got optical zoom versus digital zoom.
For portraits, I think both actually did really good
in terms of edge detection.
Of course, you've got the different angles of view,
I prefer the Pixel, you might prefer the S20 FE
but one thing that I think the Pixel does do better
hands down is skin tones.
So that is something that I did like.
When it came to low lights,
it was a bit of a draw in certain situations.
I would say outdoors, I prefer the S20 FE,
indoors I preferred the Pixel and for video,
I think it was very, very close.
I think both record great quality video.
Stabilization was also really good on both.
For low light video as well, I did prefer the Pixel.
If you look at whenever I'm moving in the low light video,
everything kind of goes fuzzy and out of focus on the S20 FE
whereas things are better maintained on the Pixel.
Now, front facing camera.
For video, the S20 FE does have firstly 4K,
it's also got a wider field of view, which I do like
but the Pixel did have better colors
and it was also more stable.
For selfies, photos, I did prefer the Pixel overall,
even though the S20 FE did do okay in certain situations,
I think most situations, you're going to get better skin tones
and colors as well as lots of sharp details on the Pixel.
For slow motion, I think the S20 FE does get the advantage.
You firstly got 1080 at 240 frames a second
versus 720 and you also have the 720p super slow motion,
an option that's not available on the Pixel.
Now for audio, you can go back and have a listen,
I've listened a few times and for me,
my pick is the S20 FE,
I think you just had better sounding audio
and you also had better noise cancellation.
In particular, if you put some headphones on
and you listen to the clip of me outdoors at night
when it's very quiet,
you can hear more of a hiss on the Pixel
whereas the S20 FE was much cleaner.
That's what I think, what do you guys think?
Do drop me a comment below,
let me know which your pick was overall.
If you want to see lots more images
from lots of different devices,
then do give me a follow on Instagram,
I'm @SuperSaf, I post very regularly on there
and If you enjoyed this video and found it useful,
then a thumbs up and a subscribe would be appreciated.
These camera comparisons, as you know,
take a very, very long time to do
and there is going to be lots more SuperSaf style content
coming up so be sure to also hit that bell icon.
Thanks for watching, this is Saf on SuperSaf TV
and I'll see you next time.
(upbeat music)