"Does Marijuana Cause Schizophrenia?"
Even as proponents of cannabis legalization contend
that marijuana is a harmless natural substance that improves quality of life,
a growing body of evidence links it in a small but significant number of users
to the induction or aggravation of psychosis.
Psychotic disorders are arguably the most serious of mental illnesses,
the best known being schizophrenia. Schizophrenia is an illness
characterized by delusions, hallucinations, odd behavior,
and is among the top 10 leading causes of disability in the United States
affecting approximately 1% of the general population.
Can cannabis cause it? Nearly 2,000 studies have been published
on this topic over the last half century, and we hear about
the pro-psychotic effects. But how clear is that link?
Well, population studies have consistently demonstrated a strong dose-dependent
association between cannabis use and the risk of psychotic disorders.
This is what they mean by a dose-response: studies showing
that the more cannabis people used the more likely they were to be psychotic.
But that doesn't mean cannabis is the cause;
it could just be a correlation or even a consequence of the disease.
Yeah, the link between cannabis and psychosis is well established,
but maybe that's just because patients with mental health problems
self-medicate with cannabis to relieve their distress.
But there isn't just a link between cannabis and psychosis
in snapshot-in-time cross-sectional studies, but in cohort studies as well,
where people are followed over time.
And so you can see the cannabis use often precedes the psychosis,
and not the other way around.
Now it goes without saying that the vast majority of people who use cannabis
do not develop schizophrenia, and many schizophrenics have never used cannabis.
But overall, these studies are considered to be strong enough evidence
to warrant a public health warning.
There is another potential explanation, though.
Even though cannabis use precedes schizophrenia, maybe whatever genes
drive schizophrenia also just make it more likely you start smoking pot?
The biggest strike against the cannabis-schizophrenia link is
country-by-country ecological studies that don't seem to show more disease
in areas where there's more use, and overall schizophrenia rates
seem to have remained stable or have even gone down
worldwide since the Sixties, even though there's been a big bump
in cannabis use since then.
If about 10% of schizophrenia cases are attributable to marijuana use,
and there's been a fourfold increase in use, why hasn't there been a 40%
increase in the prevalence of schizophrenia?
The problem with that argument is that there's, apparently,
little reliable evidence on the true trends
in the incidence of schizophrenia.
Or maybe it's more of a potency issue rather than just cannabis in general.
The bottom line is you don't know until you put it to the test.
You can't just randomize kids to cannabis,
but in a way Mother Nature set up a natural experiment for us.
There are genes that kids randomly get
that can increase their likelihood of smoking pot.
Do those kids then go on to have a higher risk of schizophrenia?
Yes, supporting all those population studies that suggest cannabis
plays a cause-and-effect role in the development of schizophrenia.
OK, but by how much? Let's break it down.
Even if cannabis use doubles risk, that would only mean going from like
a 7 in 1000 chance of going crazy to like 14 in 1000.
So, like a 1 in 140 chance to a 1 in 70 chance.
Now, if it runs in your family, that's different,
and that doubling could mean going from like 1 in 10 to 1 in 5,
but on a population scale it could take thousands of users quitting
to prevent a single case of schizophrenia.
So from a public health standpoint, addiction is a far more common problem.
And people are probably nine times more likely to become addicted to marijuana—
even though that itself is relatively rare—
than to develop psychosis in their lifetime.