working for him?
>> Since March 10 of 2016
at that point,
so for four months.
>> Judge Judy:
And this was the first accident
that you've had.
>> Yes.
you owe him $1,000 for that.
>> Well, my understanding was
that the deductible was $500.
The $1,000 came out not
until he was telling me
that I owed him that money.
>> Judge Judy: What made you
think it was a $500 deductible?
>> Because when I was hired on
and had gone into his
original business,
Mr. Tux, to sign the paperwork,
he was talking
about the deductible being 500.
>> No, no.
>> And I said,
"Oh, well, really?
Because most
commercial businesses,
their deductible is 1,000."
I said that.
But he's like, "No, it's 500."
>> Judge Judy:
You should have ha
put it in --
>> You're right.
I should have put it in writing.
>> Judge Judy: You should
have put it in writing.
So that, you owe him.
Now, when do you claim
the second accident was, sir?
>> October 15, 2016.
>> Judge Judy:
And tell me about that.
>> Well, prior to that,
she had been driving all summer.
And she had two runs that day,
a Navigator, that's not a limo.
That's vehicle number three.
The large Escalade,
which is a 14-passenger vehicle,
was the second vehicle.
She was having frustrations
that day
because she had lost --
>> Judge Judy:
Don't tell what she's lost.
Just tell me about the accident.
Tell me about the damage.
>> Okay. So each driver,
as we've done that for years,
and that'll be my witness,
that they have to inspect
the vehicles before they go out,
or they're responsible
for any damage.
>> That's not correct.
>> And so --
>> Judge Judy:
But that would be smart.
It would be smart
if you looked at it. Go ahead.
>> Well, that's right.
And so the next run
on the Escalade was Brad here.
And he was doing his inspection,
and that's when he found the
side scrapes on the Escalade.
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
And did he report
that before his run?
>> Oh, yes.
>> Judge Judy: To whom?
>> Me.
>> When was that run?
>> Judge Judy: Shh. Shh.
>> The 18th.
>> Three days later.
>> But the vehicle didn't
go out.
>> Judge Judy: Oh.
>> How do we know?
>> Judge Judy: That's all right.
That's okay.
So it wasn't the same day.
It was three days later.
>> Correct.
>> Judge Judy: Just a second.
And three days later, your cars
are stored in your garage?
>> Judge Judy: How many cars
are stored in the garage?
>> Nine.
>> Judge Judy:
And how many of the other cars
went in and out
in that three-day interval?
>> None. None.
I have a run sheet to show
that there was no run.
So there was no business...
>>
>> Judge Judy:
...conducted whatsoever
between the time
she brought the car back...
>> Car clean
>> Judge Judy:
Nobody was in that unit.
I'd like to see that.
Business was that bad,
I might close up my shop.
go in and out of the shop.
There's half a dozen people
that have keys to get in there.
If he's going to have them
clean it, and there's a car
in the back, you have
to pull three or two cars out.
>> Judge Judy:
I'm glad you brought it out.
I will ask him that question...
>> Thank you.
>> Judge Judy:
...as soon as he finds the...
>> I think you already
have it, ma'am.
tells me that those carsda
are routinely cleaned
and that there are other people
who have access to that garage
for the purposes of cleaning
the cars inside and out.
Is that correct?
>> Yes. That's correct.
>> Judge Judy: Okay.
I'm going to come back to you.
On the day that
the first accident,
when you hit the side
of the garage door...
>> Mm-
>> Judge Judy:
...that was late at night.
I assume Mr. Mosby
was not working.
>> He was not working
at that point.
>> Judge Judy: Just a second
Was anybody else working?
>> No.
I was the only one
at the warehouse.
>> Judge Judy: When, if ever,
did you report
what had happened to Mr. Mosby?
>> I reported it
the next morning
because it was late that night.
And he does not like us to...
Okay.
>> Judge Judy:
You reported it
the next morning.
>> I did.
>> Judge Judy: And what method
did you use to report it?
>> I called him.
But he did not answer.
So I sent him a text.
>> Judge Judy:
And you said to him,
"I had an accident
with the car."
>> I said, "I had an incident
with the car. Please call me."
And you told him what happened.
>> What he said to me
when he called me was,
"Yes, I know.
My grandson has already taken it
to the body shop."
>> That's not true.
>> That's what you told me.
>> Judge Judy: Doesn't matter.
She self-reported because
she was responsible, right?
>> Mm-hmm.
>> Judge Judy: Did she cal
and self-report with regard
to either of the other two
incidents where
there were scrapes on the car?
>> Judge Judy: So one car
was driven three days later
and was in a warehouse
during those three days
where other people had access
to the cars
and had access to the warehouse
for the purposes of cleaning,
either inside or outside
of the cars.
Now, let's get
to the third incident.
>> Okay.
That was the little Navigator,
which was the first
run of that day.
And another driver
that the two of them together
with Brad had discovered.
>> Judge Judy: You can't tell me
what another driver
discovered, sir.
That's hearsay.
>> Well,
and then they reported it to me.
>> Judge Judy:
That's still hearsay.
>> Well, then I saw it.
I mean, that's when
I went to view it.
>> Judge Judy: Good.
You can tell me what you saw.