(ominous music)
- Nothing ever has ever happened like this before,
so I knew something was wrong.
That's the first thing I even told the investigators.
She would never run away, never.
- Well, when a child goes missing,
you're racing the clock,
because statistically, that child is not likely
to survive for a very long period of time
because of the dangers that are associated
with the people surrounding that child.
- I'd stay up all night, just kept calling her phone,
kept blowing her phone up.
I was like, please, Colie, call me back.
It's hard.
(ominous music)
- He's exercised his right to remain silent,
which is his choice,
and it was a very unusual time,
because I'm not asking him questions.
David is giving me that hateful stare,
and it's a very aggressive thing to do when you consider
David is just a 18-year-old college student
and I'm a 50 plus FBI agent.
(tense music)
After a time, David became less comfortable
with the silence of our waiting,
and David starts to want to talk,
and he starts volunteering information.
- It is very weird
to purchase a garden shovel
for shoveling snow
when Walmart does sell actual snow shovels.
(ominous music)
- Now we have another lead,
so those investigators grab that name and they run with it.
(tense music)
- I interviewed Natalie Keepers.
- Okay.
One suggestion that was made to me was
to actually physically write out her statement
and have her sign every page.
If we discussed a certain topic
that was discussed before, and she wanted to clarify it,
we would simply go to that page, rip it off the wall,
make the appropriate adjustments.
So in that manner, we feel
that we really got the best part of the story.
- [Scimeca] Okay.
(ominous music)
(mournful music)
- I had a good relationship with my daughter.
I've got a couple memories.
Just her telling me she loves me.
I miss hearing her say, I love you mommy.
I really do.