THEY’RE REALLY LOOKING INTO IT.
>> Neil: GOT IT.
THANKS, ALEXIS.
TED WILLIAMS IS HERE TO PICK
THIS APART.
OUR FOX NEWS CONTRIBUTOR, FORMER
D.C. HOMICIDE DETECTIVE, DEFENSE
ATTORNEY.
TED, THIS IS A HEAD SCRATCHER,
WHETHER THEY WERE ALL TARGETED
OR WHETHER SEPARATE REPORTS THAT
ONE OF THE VICTIMS HAD A
STALKER.
WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF IT?
>> WELL, YOU KNOW, NEIL, THIS IS
A VERY COMPLEX CASE.
IT IS A HEAD SCRATCHER.
I HEAR THE CHIEF AND I KNOW THE
CHIEF WANTS TO RESOLVE THIS.
THIS IS A 35-MAN DEPARTMENT THAT
HAS NOT HAD A HOMICIDE OUT THERE
IN THE LAST SEVEN YEARS.
THEY ARE TRYING TO SORT OF --
THERE’S A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT
BELIEVE THAT THERE’S A LOT OF
INEXPERIENCE INVESTIGATORS
HANDLING THE INVESTIGATION.
NOW, I WAS OUT THERE ON BEHALF
OF FOX.
I CAN TELL YOU THAT THERE’S
REALLY TWO ENTRANCES TO THIS
HOUSE.
THE FIRST ENTRANCE IS ON THE
FIRST FLOOR AS YOU COME IN
THROUGH THE DOOR THERE.
YOU HAVE TWO OF THE SURVIVING
STUDENTS THAT SLEEP ON THAT
FIRST FLOOR.
YOU GO TO THE BACK OF THE HOME,
YOU HAVE A SLIDING GAS DOOR THAT
GOES IN TO THE SECOND FLOOR.
THERE YOU HAD TWO OF THE
STUDENTS THAT WERE KILLED, ETHAN
AND XANA.
THEY WERE SLEEPING ON THE SECOND
FLOOR.
ON THE THIRD FLOOR OF THIS HOME,
YOU HAD MADDIE AND KAYLEE
SLEEPING.
NOW, KAYLEE’S FATHER, STEVE, HAS
SAID THAT HE BELIEVED THAT IT’S
MORE LIKELY THAN NOT THAT HIS
DAUGHTER WAS TARGETED.
I HAVE TO BELIEVE, NEIL, THAT
THE LAW ENFORCEMENTS OUT THERE
SAID THAT SOMEONE WAS TARGETED.
IF SOMEONE WAS TARGETED OR
SOMEBODY WHEN THE KILLER OR
KILLERS ENTERED AND IF THEY
ENTERED THROUGH THE SECOND DOOR,
THEY WOULD HAVE COME IN CONTACT
IMMEDIATELY WITH ETHAN AND XANA.
IF THEY KILLED THEM AND THEY
WERE THE TARGETS, THE KILLER IS
MORE LIKELY THAN NOT WOULD HAVE
LEFT.
BUT THE KILLER WENT TO THE THIRD
FLOOR.
AND THERE HE ENCOUNTERED MADDIE
AND KAYLEE SLEEPING TOGETHER IN
A BEDROOM.
HE WOUND UP KILLING THEM.
WHEN I SAY HE, IT COULD BE A
SHE.
BUT THEN THE KILLER LEFT.
NEIL, THIS WOULD HAVE BEEN A
VERY, VERY VICIOUSLY BLOODY
CRIME SCENE.
THERE’S NO WAY THAT A KILLER
WOULD HAVE GOTTEN IN AND OUT OF
THERE WITHOUT SOME TRACE
EVIDENCE.
SO I HAVE TO BELIEVE THE
AUTHORITIES HAVE A LOT TO WORK
WITH.
>> Neil: WELL, YOU TALK ANT THIS
35-PERSON FORCE.
WE DO KNOW THAT THE UNIVERSITY
OF IDAHO STUDENT, KAYLEE
CONCALVES WHO WAS CALLED, WE’RE
TOLD THAT HER FAMILY PLANS TO
HIRE A LAWYER OVER WHAT THE
FAMILY BELIEVES IS A LACK OF
TRANSPARENCY AND AN ERRATIC
INVESTIGATION.
WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THAT?
>> NEIL, LOOK, BRINGING IN A
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR, HIRING A
LAWYER IS NOT GOING TO GET TO
THE BOTTOM OF THIS CASE.
YOU HAVE GOT TO TRUST LAW
ENFORCEMENT
ENFORCEMENT.
IT’S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT THE
IDAHO STATE POLICE AND THE FBI
IS INVOLVED.
YOU HAVE TO TRUST THEM.
THEY’RE NOT, MEANING THE LOCAL
POLICE OR THE FEDS, THEY’RE NOT
GOING TO SHARE ANYTHING WITH ANY
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR.
TO ME, IT’S A WASTE OF YOUR
MONEY.
YOU’VE GOT TO RELY ON THESE
INVESTIGATORS TO BRING THIS --
THE KILLER OR KILLERS TO
JUSTICE, I BELIEVE.
>> Neil: HOW LONG YOU THINK THAT
WILL BE?
>> I’M HOPING THAT IS SOONER.
I KNOW THE FAMILY AND THAT
COMMUNITY IS VERY FRUSTRATED.
THERE’S A LOT OF FEAR OUT THERE.
THEY KNOW.
THERE’S A KILLER OUT THERE AMONG
THEM.
ALL YOU CAN DO IS HOPE THAT THE
EVIDENCE WILL COME IN WHERE THE
INVESTIGATORS WILL BE ABLE TO DO
THEIR JOB AND GET JUSTICE FOR
THESE FAMILIES.
>> Neil: TED, THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
I ALWAYS LEARN SOMETHING FROM