if you join hey everyone how's your day going so far this video is one that I've
been thinking about for a long time and ever since seeing the rise of Skywalker
there wasn't really any answer to this question that arose from any of the
books or visual dictionaries or anything like that
it's a massive plot hole that goes into the entire Star Wars saga so I want to
talk about it the question is of course why kylo could bring back Rey from the
dead while Anakin couldn't do the same with Padme or even his mother the power
of force resurrection or being able to stop someone from dying is literally the
entire reason that Anakin turned to the dark side it's like the crux of the
entire Skywalker story it's the pinnacle of Sith desires and something that
supposedly has only been achieved by one Sith Lord in history of the galaxy now
we can argue that Palpatine figured out how to do it since well he's still alive
in Episode nine that's a topic for another video and the answer apparently
will be revealed in mando season two but those are just rumors today let's focus
on reloj and why they could do that when Padme Anakin could not to be honest it's
really frustrating thinking about this since it causes so many inconsistencies
with the prequel trilogy Xand original trilogy's to just revive someone from
the dead obi-wan and qui gonn Anakin Padme Anakin his mother heck even Evan
Pele and the clone wars when Anakin sees a vision of Padme dying in childbirth he
takes that vision at face value if he doesn't learn to use the Force to stop
her from dying then her death is inevitable and it can never even stops
to think of why she was going to die he never even considers that he would be
the cause of her death which of course we know he is his turn to the dark side
is an effort to save her which is eventually what kills her and as far as
we know neither anakin nor Vader ever learned how to stop someone from dying
or bring anyone back from the dead so how does kylo do it in the rise of
Skywalker after Rey defeats Palpatine she's so
drained of Force energy that she collapses and dies she essentially
sacrifices herself for the good of the galaxy performing a selfless act for the
benefit of others her life gives life to others which is pure light side with not
an ounce of selfishness or hatred which were hallmarks of the sift
by the time kylo gets to her side she's dead with no hope of resuscitation
through conventional medical means he must reach down deep inside the light
side within him and transfer all of his force energy into her to bring her back
to life shockingly it's successful now mannequins force ghosts must have
died again when he saw that happen because he was probably pretty upset
that she said well it's just this easy what the heck rain Kyle oh kiss and then
Paulo dies himself having given Rey his very own life essence to allow her to
live now while I believe this causes a lot of inconsistencies I don't want to
just nag and whine about it I think there are two reasons why kylo could do
this but Anakin could not otherwise I'm just gonna go crazy wondering why
couldn't Anakin do this he is the chosen one after all okay so the first is that
Rey and kylo make up what's known as a force dyad kylo tells Rey in the movie
my mother was the daughter of Vader your father was the son of the Emperor what
Palpatine doesn't know is we are dying in the force two that are one now a diet
in the force is a pairing of to force individuals as if they were the same
beam it spanned a space and time which allowed kylo and rey to speak and
interact with each other so closely over vast distances it allowed them to see
each other's innermost thoughts and feelings thus becoming one in the force
according to Palpatine this power was a power over life itself and had been
unseen for generations even taps into their diet connection to restore himself
to full vitality and then some this dyad connection allows kylo to bring ray back
to life since they shared the same life force he was able to transfer his life
into hers after her death it's as if they shared the same special
blood type that only the two of them had but in the end there was only enough for
one to survive that's one reason kylo could do what he did and I'll get into
the force diet more in depth and how it relates to other aspects of their
connection in another video the force diet is only one reason why this power
worked the second reason is much more applicable to Anakin and his fall to the
dark side and you guys know I really love Anakin so I always try to find ways
that star was relates to the chosen one because well Star Wars is all about
Anakin as George Lucas has said whether or not kylo and Rey formed dyad kylo was
able to save Rey because he sacrificed himself to save her it was a pure light
side move without even a hint of the dark side a
dark side user would never self-sacrifice to save another person
the darkness requires complete control over the force not subservience to it
and sacrifice is anything but control Palpatine knew this and knew that he
needed to break Anakin's connection with Padme if he were to ever win Anakin as
an apprentice palps promised Anakin the ability to cheat death and save Padme
from certain death if he would turn to the dark side and since Master Yoda
essentially tells Anakin to let go of all he fears to lose thus saying to let
Padme die Anakin saw no choice but to follow the person who was promising to
help him save Padme now on a side note even if Yoda knew how to bring people
back from the dead the Jedi wouldn't perform this power since they were
taught to always let go of those who died even to the point of rejoicing in
their transformation into the force and if she were to die then as qui-gon would
say it was the will of the force now back to Anakin what he didn't realize is
that by turning to the dark side he was sealing Padme death if he had stayed
with the light he wouldn't have killed younglings he wouldn't have brought the
destruction of the Jedi or have done anything else that drives a wedge
between him and Padme that led to her death it's no secret that by turning to
the dark side in an effort to save his wife and it can inadvertently kills
what's precious to him and most importantly his turn to the dark side
removes any ability he would have to sacrifice himself for her let's assume
for a moment that she's about to die and Anakin is with her except he's now a
Sith Lord is a Sith Lord ever going to be able to tap so much into the light
that he's able to sacrifice himself for another no of course not Anakin no
longer had the potential to save her even if he wanted to sacrifice himself
for her he was so cut off from the light side that he no longer had the potential
force he'll was not in his cards anymore while Annie thought he still loves her
he reveled in the dark side for himself he straight-up tells her that he loves
his new powers would he have sacrificed his new powers to save Padme he doesn't
even do it when give him the chance when Padme tries to get him to leave
everything behind with her he rejects her idea and lusts for more power
Palpatine was brilliant with this not only does he make Anakin cause Padme
death but Palpatine also makes it impossible for Anakin to save her by
taking away his selflessness and vestiges of his light kills two birds
with one stone either way Palpatine wins plus let's state the
obvious one here if Anakin had sacrificed himself to save Padme then he
wouldn't be around anymore so we can easily see why that's not the best
option so in the end the reason that kylo can save Rey I think my theory
helps me sleep at night is because of the selflessness and sacrifice of self
something that Anakin loses after turning to the dark side and the diet
and the force what do you think of these two reasons that kylo could bring ray
back from the dead but anakin couldn't do the same with Padme or his mother I
think both are true but I especially like reason - because it's more
character based than simply chalking it up to a forced diet now as for him
bringing his mother back he wasn't fully in the dark side at that point but I
feel like as she died that was his first entrance into the dark side and I guess
it just took over his mind and he completely lost it and that's where we
hear qui-gon yelling Anakin Anakin no and and it can just goes to town not
just the men but the women and the children too let me know what you think
the reason is in the comments below let me know what you thought of the movie in
general and let me know what you are most excited about going forwards with
Star Wars is a Clone Wars mando season 2 the Obi one show or the High Republic
movies that we're going to be getting have an awesome rest every day thanks
for watching today's video leave a like if you did and I'll see you in the next
one until then remember the force will be with you always
fulfill your destiny
you