- (React) I hear you like spooky stuff.
- (exclaims) - (React) Today, I'm gonna
test your spooky knowledge because I'm gonna show you
the top five horror TV shows of all time.
And we're gonna see if you can place them correctly
in order from one to five. - What?!
- Yeah, I know what this is. - Ooh! Walking Dead.
- Oh, see? Oh, this has to be Walking Dead or something, right?
- Oh!
Zombies are the one thing I cannot do. (chuckles)
- My mom loves this show. She's been trying to get me
to watch this for years. I'm just saying. I don't know.
- (Morgan) ...in a group all riled up and hungry.
- Oh, no! - (Morgan) ...you watch your ass.
- (Rick) All I am anymore
is a man looking for his wife and son.
- Ah, yeah. This is the first season.
This is when The Walking Dead first came out and they were
putting up advertisements for it. - (React) But you think
it's really high up there? - Oh, I think that's pretty
high up there, yeah. - (React) But you don't watch it.
- No, I haven't because sometimes I get too scared.
(laughs) - (React) It's too scary.
- It's too scary for Big Shar! - (React laughs)
- Big Shar turns into Little Shar. - (React) All right,
so The Walking Dead. Where do you think
it goes on the list? - I'm gonna put it as...
number two. - I think I'ma go one.
I think. - (React) All right.
- Because of the first couple that came to mind,
I know those are gonna be rated higher.
So, I'm gonna put Walking Dead at four.
- I'm gonna put it three. - I'm gonna give it a--
I'm gonna say it's three. - Ah!
- Oh! AHS. - Forgot about AHS.
- I loved Murder House. - This is definitely up there.
- This is one of the best shows ever. - I already know where this is going.
- So good. - And Evan Peters!
- That suit. (laughs) - I've actually never watched it.
- There. - I love her.
- All of the memories from watching this are coming back.
- I love this whole cast. - (Billie) This is a very crowded house.
- (people screaming) - Ah, this was such a good season.
- (Billie) You do know about the box.
A child born of human... - And spirit.
- (Billie) ...and spirit will usher in the end of times.
- Wow. I'm just gonna go ahead and put that at number one
because it is number one. And if it's not number one,
you guys are stupid. - Yeah, this is going on number one.
- This show, to me, would be my number one.
But I know other people are rating this.
And I think I know what the number one is,
so I'm gonna put American Horror Story at number two.
- I'm gonna put it as number two. - I think I'm gonna
put this number one. - Number one only because
I hear so many things about it and I hear more people
talking about it rather than The Walking Dead.
The Walking Dead kind of died off a little bit ago.
- The something zone. The... Spirit? (laughs)
- Oh, is this the Twilight Zone? - Twilight Zone?
- Twilight Zone! - (narrator) It is a dimension
as vast as space. - This is such a good show.
- "It's a cookbook!" - Oh, [censored].
I didn't even think about this. (laughs)
- Ah, I used to love this one as a kid!
- I've never seen this, though. - I watched it in sixth grade.
- My sixth grade teacher would play this.
- This is tough. - Ah. This is hard.
- (narrator) The Twilight Zone. - (React) What are you thinking?
- You know, here's what's happening here, Sierra,
now they're just going down. Now, I put it as three.
- We used to watch this in school randomly,
like when we had a sub. Yeah? A sub would come in and be like,
"I'm gonna play it." And thank you.
- Okay, this one's hard because it's been around for a while.
- I'm gonna put it as four. - It's at least two,
so I'ma put it on two 'cause I have no choice really.
- I'm gonna put it at five, but I have a feeling
it's not gonna be the fifth one. - Right now,
I'm gonna give it a three. But I think, at the end,
I might have to change it around. - (Sam) When I told Dad
I was scared of the thing in my closet,
he gave me a .45. - (Dean) Well, what was
he supposed to do? - Supernatural. (laughs)
- Oh, is this Supernatural? - (Dean) Don't be afraid of the dark?
Are you kidding me? Of course you should be
afraid of the dark. You know what's out there.
- Oh, Dean. Ah, don't talk to me like that.
- (Dean) Where is he? - (Meg) Dead!
- (Dean) No, he's not! He is not dead!
- I've never seen this either. - I-- no clue what this is.
- I don't know this one. - I cannot believe this show
went on for as long as it did. - Is this like Spirit House?
(chuckles) - Yeah, you do. Yeah, you do.
- I feel like this is definitely not as high.
- What is this? I don't know what this is.
- (Dean) You can burn in hell. - What is this?
Supernatural!
- Oh, Supernatural. I didn't even know
that was a TV show. Look at that.
- Did not see that one coming. Very popular show.
Really long-running show. I'm gonna give you a five.
But you're still the top five. - I think I'm gonna
give this one a five, I think. - I think it's gonna go five.
- I'm gonna put it on five just 'cause I've never heard of it,
so that really means something. - This one's definitely going second
because I know for sure it's a cult classic.
- It's not that you're bad.
It's that you're the worst of the five. (laughs)
- Stranger Th-- I've never watched it.
(record scratch) - (React, aghast) Danny.
Danny! How could you call yourself a horror fan?!
- I'm so sorry. - (React) Get out of my office.
I'm kidding. (laughs) - (laughs)
- (man) This is Hawkins. - Oh!
- This is what I think number one is. - It took me so long
to watch this. And when I finally did,
I was like, "Okay. Yeah." - (React) Right?
- Another hot take: Don't really like this show.
- Winona Ryder's so good in this. - People love this show.
- It looks really interesting, though. I definitely need to get into it.
- Him too, the little boy. I forgot his name.
- I like the fashion in it.
(dial tone beeping)
- He's grown up so much. They all have. Oh my gosh.
♪ (haunting music) ♪
Eleven. - I love that you're showing
the trailers from the first seasons too.
- (man) What the hell?
- They're so cute. They were so little!
- Yeah, they look so young. It's so weird seeing them.
- They're like 25 now (laughs) pretty much.
- Oh my gosh!
- I know they have characters on Dead by Daylight.
- Ah, such a good show. - I left my first space
for this show, because I knew it would be number one.
Or at least, I feel like it's number one.
- I think it's gonna end up being one,
but my only space open is three, so it's gonna go three right now.
- Well, I put it as four 'cause that's all that was left.
- I feel like four is pretty appropriate.
- Yeah, this is gonna go on four for sure.
- (React) Now, you can make changes. - Okay.
- (React) I'll give you about 30 seconds.
Let me know when you're locked. - Oh my goodness. (laughs)
- Okay. I'm leaving Supernatural at five, 'cause I never heard of it.
- I'm just gonna switch American Horror Story
and Twilight Zone. - Okay, so I think I'm definitely
making Twilight Zone number one. - I'm pretty set on Twilight Zone
and Supernatural. - I'm honestly pretty set with this.
- Okay, this is it. That's it.
- (React) Show us your list.
- I don't know if this is right or not.
♪ (dramatic chord) ♪
- (React) All right. Here we go.
Now, here is the actual order.
We'll go from number five to number one.
Number five is Supernatural. (ding)
- Okay! Right! Got that one correctomundo.
- (React) Number four is...
The Twilight Zone. (ding)
- Woo! (chuckles) - (React) Number three
is The Walking Dead. (ding)
- Yeeeeah! - (React) Number two
is Stranger Things. - (gasps)
(buzzer) - (React) That means, finally,
the top horror TV show of all time is
American Horror Story. - American Horror Story. (giggles)
Wooo! - (React) A perfect score!
♪ (celebratory band music) ♪
- In my opinion, what's the best series?
Funny enough, I would still go with American Horror Story.
- Hands down, American Horror Story. - Probably Stranger Things.
- Buffy the Vampire Slayer. - I'ma have to agree with the list
and say American Horror Story. (chuckles)