- [Key] These are definitely dupe adjacent, not for me.
- Not my ministry. - Not my ministry.
(laughing)
(energetic music)
- Hi I'm Key.
- Hey I'm Destinee.
- And today we're gonna be trying makeup dupes.
- For black women.
- We're trying four products,
that are black girl friendly and shade inclusive
which is why we picked those out.
- Yes. - The right side
would be the expensive side,
and the left side would be the lower end side.
(energetic music)
This is the Studio Fix Fluid SPF 15
and it's $30 at Ulta.
- It's certainly up there.
- I used to use Mac back in the day
but I did not like it that much
'cause they didn't have enough shades
for me growing up.
I got the NC47 which apparently
this is part of the new brand that they have
with the shades outside of NC45.
- Okay, I think for me this spreads very smoothly
but I feel like I have to use a lot more product
than I would like to.
- I also just feel like this is not my shade once again.
I feel like Mac just does not carry shades
for people like me.
- I think for me this matches kind of.
- Let me see.
Yeah it does - [Destinee] I think yeah.
- I'm comparing this side of my face
to this side of my face.
I've made it my shade-- - Yes.
- Even though it was not my shade.
- So now we have the inexpensive version.
We have the Fitme! Matte and Poreless by Maybelline.
- I love this product so much.
I use it every single day.
- If you say so, we're gonna find out.
- So this will be new for me
because I usually don't use the Matte and Poreless,
it's never failed me yet, so.
- Every black product it is named after some kind of food,
so I'm 360 Mocha.
- And I am 330 Toffee Caramel.
- [Destinee] I will say this one definitely has more
of a yellow undertone.
- Destinee, be careful.
- [Destinee] Why?
- 'Cause this is my favorite thing.
- The Fitme! has an instant mattifying look,
where I feel the Mac has kind of like this
natural matte if that makes sense.
Where I still feel like I have some kind
of sheen to my face.
- These two, do you think these are good dupes
for each other?
- I would say yes for the price that you are paying
this is doing a great job.
(energetic music)
We have the Tarte Shape Tape Contour Concealer,
which will run you $27.
- We're also gonna be trying the L.A. Girl Pro Concealer HD,
which is $4.99.
- So I have Deep Sand 53S.
- And I have Tan Deep Honey.
- I was gonna say oh okay, Deep Sand, it's not a food
and then you came with honey.
- Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, Tan Deep Honey.
- I am gonna say - Double duty beauty
- I'm nervous about this.
I've never used Tarte before but all the women I know
who use Tarte are white women.
- I just recently got into makeup
and so before I would just slap something on my face
and be like yeah this is fine.
But now I'm older, I'm wiser.
(laughing)
- This is a half of my mustache.
(laughing)
And half of my dark spot,
it goes all the way around my mouth.
Don't make fun of me.
(laughing)
- I'm not, I just, I was shooketh.
Okay, oh dear, oh darling.
- It is, look and I told you white women
(laughing)
are the only people that I've seen that wear Tarte.
- So this literally looks like sand on my face.
Like I've play- - You was talking about
me being ashy, you ashy too.
- I just don't think they're really is a shade
for dark girls and this is winter time.
So like - [Key] Oh yeah.
- We're as pale as we're gonna get.
So next - Good ol'faithful.
- [Destinee] This one's like hey sis
- [Key] Hey black girl.
- I came here to protect you.
I'm not mad at this.
- So color matching aside, I like this one.
It seems to be giving me look,
a lot more coverage on this side than this one did.
This is not a good dupe for each other.
This is a scam.
Black girls, don't do it. - Don't do it.
- White women this is all you.
Y'all snap when y'all made this,
but you were not thinking about us.
- [Destinee] The audacity to be like Deep Sand.
(laughing)
- [Key] The audacity.
- But then good old L.A. Girl.
- They're like "We got you."
- [Destinee] We got you honey,
and we know your price point, so.
(energetic music)
This is the BECCA Shimmering Skin Perfector
Pressed Highlight in Moonstone.
I used to swear by BECCA,
then Fenty came out I was like "Thanks sis."
- For the lower end, we're gonna be using
ColourPop in the shade of Lunch Money.
So Destinee's gonna do my highlight
because I never do highlight.
- Let's see, with a flick of the wrist.
That looks good on you!
One good swipe, just whoosh.
You'll have this for life sis.
Not for this black girl.
- [Key] Let me see, turn around.
- No. - No.
It's just not your ministry sis and that's okay.
- Give me your face.
(hushed mumbling)
We're gonna have to put a little bit more love to it,
there we go, bam.
- Okay, I can rock with this.
- [Key] Yeah I like it on you
- I think it's a good dupe.
- [Destinee] It is, I think it's a very great dupe actually.
- They look very similar.
(Squealing)
- It doesn't have enough glitter.
I think that's why I kept having to apply it.
- If forced to choose, I wouldn't pay $38 for that,
when I can pay $8 for this and get similar results.
- It's very matte, there is no shine.
(energetic music)
For our mascara on the luxury end,
we have Benefit's BADgal BANG!.
- If you're in my tax bracket,
we're doing NYX Worth The Hype for once again $8.
So this travel size is more expensive
then this full size NYX.
- Whatever just put it on woman.
(laughing)
So I have on fake lashes,
but what I can do is put these on my bottom lashes.
Maybe I should be a lash, bottom lash girl more often.
- [Key] You should, and for $13 I might pay, no I wouldn't.
Let's see what my girl NYX talking
about, I'm looking at it but I can definitely tell
a difference, maybe I should start wearing mascara?
NYX Worth The Hype 8 dollars.
- I don't trust you.
- I'm also just like not a makeup person
so this one looks just like the other one to me.
I see no difference at all.
- Now it could be you know human error,
but I think for me, the other side went on much cleaner
and this is a little more clumpy.
- I would agree with that but for 8 dollars.
- You would do clumpy for--
- I would make it work.
- You have no standards.
(laughing)
So we've topped off our looks.
I added my good ol' gloss.
- [Key] And I added this really cheap gloss
that I've always used this like 3 dollars from Walgreens.
Do you think people are gonna be able to tell
the difference between,
they'll definitely gonna be able to tell
by looking at my mouth. (laughing)
- [Destinee] I know a difference, I think only
because I know what's happening.
I think we should ask our coworkers.
- I think we should too.
- What do you think of my makeup?
- It looks great.
- Yeah?
- Yeah, why?
- Your eyelashes look different.
- Okay - You look really good.
- Yeah, I put a little mascara on.
Which side looks better?
She getting in deep here.
- This side. - This side?
This is the expensive side.
This is the side of wealth.
- You look very much like,
like this.
- This side is expensive makeup.
- Okay. - This side are their dupes.
- Really? - You can't tell?
- Oh you know what?
You do have this kind of weird two-face thing
going on right now, not in a bad way,
like the hottest two-face ever.
(laughter)
- It looks good.
- Does it? - You can't really tell
you're wearing foundation.
- Oh, that's always a good thing.
Can you tell that one side is different than the other?
It's two different brands.
- No.
- Well actually--
- Look at you out here, wanna play,
does it look good though?
- No it looks great.
- It's seamless? You can't tell the difference?
- I cannot tell at all.
- Maybe Key is onto something.
- Looks good.
- Aria approved?
- [Key] Aria approved. - Deal.
(energetic music)