When was the last time you watched porn?
Honestly? What's today?
Wednesday. Wednesday.
Monday.
Welcome to a fiery edition of May the Best Twin Win.
I'm Jessica. I'm 27 years old,
and I'm here because I want to date seriously, not just like,
"Oh, we're on a couple of dates so that we can sleep together."
Jessica has been single for three years.
I'm bisexual, so I'm sure there's a broad range
of who it could be on the other side of that table.
Today we are setting Jessica up on a blind date with two people.
Hi. Hi.
I'm Ani, nice to meet you.
Jessica, yeah, let's hug.
We should hug. Nice to meet ... Ani?
Yeah, Ani, Jessica.
Jessica, nice to meet you.
Nice to meet you.
But there's a catch.
Hi.
Oh, hi. Oh my God.
Oh, they showed up in the same outfit.
Oh, [inaudible 00:00:46]
there's two of them. Maybe it'll end dirty or something.
I'm Athena.
Athena, nice to meet you. Yeah, sister.
That's so cute.
Oh, this is interesting. Have you guys ever ...
touched tips?
Oh my God, we both like this person?
Totally.
We definitely have. It can be a little competitive, too, right?
Yeah.
I like the competition.
You can fight over me. That's fine.
Ani caught my eye first, and every time she talked,
she looked me directly in my eye.
And I'm really attracted and turned on by eye contact.
This gold envelope has been tempting me since I sat down.
So, let's open it and see.
"You're going to be playing the dirty secret twin quiz,
Snitch On Your Sibling, and answer questions about yourself.
If you don't want to answer the question, drink.
Ani and Athena, why don't you start?
You already have a dirty secret, don't you?"
We do.
Wait a minute. Should I get a drink first?
Hello.
There's three of them. What a curve ball.
Am I going to have to choose between all three?
Is this going to break up a family? What's your name?
I'm Arianna. Yes. But I have to tell you
I'm not bisexual and am in a relationship.
So I'm here to help you pick what your sister
is right for you.
Let's do the dirty secret twin quiz.
Why is your sibling still single?
Oh.
This could get ugly.
Okay. Well, Ani's still single aisle because she,
I feel like is always picking the wrong person,
giving way too many chances.
Uh oh.
You ignore the red flags.
Ignore the red flags.
Until it's too late.
Really hoping to kind of change them.
Do you care that they're a fit? I don't think so.
Oof. How will she recover from this?
I don't agree with that at all. I thinking I'm still single
because I meet really cool people
and they seem really promising,
but then something happens or they do something
and it's like, "Whoa, maybe they're not."
I know for Ani that's come up a lot recently.
She's been dating a lot and it has not been going well.
When was the last time you watched porn?
Oh my god. This is going so deep.
Oh no. I don't care. Honestly, what's today?
Wednesday. Wednesday.
Monday.
Do you think your sibling has ever cheated
on a significant other? Oh my God.
There was a time in high school. There may have been a little...
A gray area.
I really didn't want that to come up.
It seems like Jessica's not totally turned off by it.
What about you, Jessica?
There's been an overlap.
Okay.
Can't let a boyfriend stop you
from getting your husband, you know?
Or can't let girlfriend stop you from getting your wife.
What is the oldest person you've hooked up with?
Oh, I want to hear this.
When I was 20 going on 21,
I dated a guy that was 28 going on 29.
Oh. That's not that bad.
And I think that she leans with younger people.
Yes. Oh, guilty.
I'm about to be 28. I feel like a grandma.
Well, everyone was so honest. We didn't get to drink.
So do you all want to...
Yeah. [crosstalk 00:03:49].
Drink together? Cheers.
Look each other in the eye, look each other in the eye.
Okay let's do it.
Oh yeah. Show him how it's done, Jessica.
Oh. Hm.
Any of you want to get some alone time with me?
Yes.
Jessica has picked Ani for some alone time.
Maybe they'll watch some porn.
Have you dated more guys or girls?
Honestly, I've dated more guys.
I've also dated more guys. I'd love to date more women.
Me, too.That's what I'm trying to get into.
And I think maybe coming out to my mom was that last hurdle.
You're ready?
Yeah. Yeah.
I know what it feels like to just come out to your mom,
and I think that's really sweet that she's sharing that with me.
So what is a red flag for you?
My hair. My hair is a red flag.
What I'm all learning is just selfishness
is something that I kind of write off.
So I'm trying now like,
"Okay, are you making time for me?
Are you putting an effort?" You know?
So tell me, out of your sister, why should I choose you?
I do feel like we have a lot in common,
and I feel like we would communicate really well,
and just really have fun together.
I really enjoyed your company today.
Me, too.
Ani's cool. I like her.
Oh, so now it's Athena.
They've swapped sides to make it easier for us.
I learned a lot about you and your sisters together.
What do you do in your spare time when it's just you?
I like to dance. I did ballroom in college.
Oh, nice.
Very newbie levels. It was so fun.
Nice. That's awesome.
We're huge karaokers. Like very. Did my sister tell you that?
No.
I feel like that's like a love-hate thing with people.
Either, they're into it or they're not.
No, I love karaoke. Really?
Are you sure, Jess?
Not really. I was just being polite.
I know.
So why should I choose you for your sister?
I am more extroverted than her.
Okay.
A little bit wild.
Am I what you're usually attracted to?
Yeah, you actually are my taste.
I'm not surprised.
AM I your type?
Physically, you are.
Okay.
When you guys walked in I was like "Oh my god.
This is my middle school fantasy."
Lindsay Lohan was my bitch.
Yeah, totally. Yeah.
Yeah. I can't say what my decision is,
but I think I know where I'm going.
I'm sweating. Now, it's time for the verdict.
Hi, ladies. It was so nice meeting both of you.
Ari, thank you so much for your help.
You're welcome.
You were like my own love guru. I love it.
Ani, I feel like we have the same expectations and goals
as far as relationships and love.
Athena, I feel like you're my party girl.
You speak to my wild side, which I appreciate.
I want someone that's down for whatever.
I am so nervous right now.
Public rejection is top five biggest fears in my life.
I think...
Who is Jessica going to pick any?
Ani, if you would like,
I would love to go on a date with you.
But what do the ladies have to say?
Should we flip it?
Let's do it. Ready?
Let's see.
1, 2, 3...
OH, yay!
Two yeses! Hallelujah!
No public rejection!
It's cool. At least it's my sister.
I'm so glad that you picked me.
I know.
Let's start talking.
Let's go grab a tree without the cameras.
I agree. And see how it goes.
Or sisters.
I'm not surprised that she picked Ani,
but it does kind of hurt a little bit.
After the show.
Jessica searched for Ani to get her number,
but she was nowhere to be seen.