- What is in this?
- Caramel?
It's got caramel in it too?
(upbeat music)
- Today, we're about to do
the ultimate Reese's taste test.
We're gonna find out which one is the best.
Which one's the king of Reese's.
Which ones the Reese champion.
- Mmmm - Reese star.
- Mmm. - Reese ultimate.
- I'm deeply passionate about this subject.
I have a big Reese's head.
- There never really is a Reese-on to choose,
but you know, we're just gonna do it.
- So, we started out being team cup over team Pieces,
and then I tasted the pumpkin version.
Like, little pumpkins.
Then I was like, wait this is better than the cup.
Then I tasted the big cup with the Pieces in it,
and I was like, this is better than the pumpkin.
- So, you're favorites are just which Reese's
you've had recently.
We're not gonna have all of them.
We tried, but we couldn't; because some are seasonal.
You know, pumpkins, they're in the past.
We're beyond that.
- We're passed the pumpkins
- Exactly.
You know, winter solstice. - We're on to trees.
- Where they at?
- But, if we're missing your favorite,
Apologies. - Tweet a video
of you eating it to us.
First up, we got the Classic cups.
- Oh yeah, classic for a reason baby, mmm.
- This, bringing back so many memories.
- Yeah you got the - - It's in it's own.
- Oh, we weren't gonna cheers?
- Oh, (mumbles)
- Fine.
- It's your classic ratio.
It's hard to judge the classic, because this
is the standard.
- I know, this is like, this is gonna be number one,
and we'll just see if anything beats it.
You gonna finish that one?
You're not gonna - - Yeah
- You're not gonna pace yourself?
We've got a lot, a lot to try.
- Next Reese's, lets go.
Wooo!
Reese's stuffed with Pieces.
Now, this is not the big cup, but it's quite similar.
- This is like, the baby cup.
- On the outside it looks the same.
- Yeah I will say, presentation wise,
we got a little breakage.
- Well, a little hint of what's to come.
- Fine, we won't cheers. It's fine
It's fine. - I want to cheers.
I just get so excited with this chocolate.
Mmmm - Mmmm
Is it terrible that I'm already convinced that this is
better than the - Yeah, oh yeah.
I was gonna say yeah.
Oh my God, yay, We're in agreement.
It's the cup you know and love,
with a little bit of added crunch.
So, I would say yeah, I would say it's
definitely enhanced by the Pieces, and it's one
step above, I'm sorry.
Apparently it's really hard to track down
every single Reese's in stores.
There's probably like, over forty variations.
Moving on.
The white chocolate version of Reese's.
Have you ever had this one?
- No, but I, you know, chocolate is overrated.
White chocolate slaps.
So, I'm ready.
- I haven't had this because I don't like,
I don't think white chocolate is
better than normal chocolate.
Yay!
Not my favorite, but it's good.
You can't go wrong.
Nothing's gonna be bad today.
- It overpowers the whole Reese's.
You don't have, you know, symphony.
We're gonna put that below the original?
- Next. - High ya!
- Woo, so, we got only apparently, one representation
of the big cup family;
because Matt Real, who went out to go buy them,
didn't find my favorite big cup.
He just found his favorite big cup,
and then was like, that's fine.
It's not fine Matt.
I wanted an ultimate Reese's and I blame you.
- Cup it out Matt.
Looks like there was a hiccup in our big cups.
- Cheers. - Boop.
- This is really good.
- My mind is going a million places because--
- It's so, the crunch though is much
stronger than the piece crunch,
and as you can see from this cross section.
It's just stunning.
It's a work of art, really.
- This is great mouth feel.
Nice pops and crunches.
Small bursts of flavors.
Almost like when you eat the kids toothpaste.
They have the little flavor, they have the
little flavor bursts in there. - No.
You lost me at the kids toothpaste part.
- You haven't ate kids toothpaste?
- This might be above the stuffed with Pieces for me.
- [Matt] Oh, so I might be right?
- No, you're only right because mine isn't there.
- I'm give it the first spot too.
- So we're gonna put it here,
but with an asterisk.
- Yeah, it should of been the Pieces one but you know,
the cookie crunch,
not bad. - Cookie Crunch is
really good though.
But,
Next - One, two.
Oh.. - That was good.
So now I have the, what are these?
- [Matt] They are called the miniatures.
- Do you like these ones?
- Oh yeah this is a classic right here.
Bink.
- The peanut chocolate ratio feels a little different.
I think I'd rank it below peanut butter cups but
above white peanut butter cups.
- That's fair.
- If we're talking about superiority.
- Yeah. - You gotta hand it
to the original.
- I mean this is just a derivative.
(laughs) (chair scrapes floor)
- Oh we got the trees!
There's other ones too.
This is representing all holiday shaped Reese's.
It looks more like a leaf.
- What does this look like, a leaf or tree or?
- Turd.
(both laughing)
- I think the mouth feel
- It's so good.
- Is great.
- I know!
- I'd say I rank it higher than the classic.
- I think I would too.
- After Pieces in front of classic.
- Agreed.
Wow, we're like, we haven't fought about anything yet.
- [Matt] There's that.
(laughs) - Perfect
Its the Reese's outrageous stuffed with Pieces.
This sounds almost like it could either be
the best or it could be a wittle little bit too outrageous.
- Went too far, we gotta go back!
- Yeah, do you wanna just split one?
- Yeah, yeah let's share it.
- What is in this?
Caramel?
It's got caramel in it too?
Whoa look at that!
Cheers. - Cheers.
- This is really good.
I think there is so much going on
I don't really taste a ton of peanut butter.
- To me this is like one of
those songs or rap songs where you're like
oh I like that rapper,
I like that rapper, I like that rapper, I like that rapper
and then you're like wait there's too many rappers on
this song, it's too long.
No one is getting to rap long enough.
- It hasn't taken the top spot for me.
- To me its taken the last spot.
- Oh yeah. - Okay, this is where
we're gonna disagree. - Yeah,
I'm thinking it goes - Uh no.
- Behind the white chocolate. - No, no.
- It goes behind - No, white chocolate
No, white chocolate was trash.
- No, its going - This is above
- Behind it. - White chocolate
- No, no, no. I will not yield.
Okay, yeah we need a tie breaker here, Matt.
- Yeah.
(laughs)
- Yeah.
- Yes! (laughs)
- Wow, Matt.
You burned me twice today. (both laughing)
- Yeah I'm like starting to get sugar high and
I'm ready for it, next!
♪ It's the Reese's called Pieces ♪
♪ It's the Reese's Pieces thesis ♪
- No, I made it up right now.
- Oh my God!
So we got the Reese's Pieces, the classic.
Wait I like these better than I remember.
- These are great, they really are but after, you know,
- That sounded like the beginning of a break up.
(both laughing)
You're great, you really are.
- I'm learning so much from you.
They definitely are good,
they're amazing, I might put it after the classic.
- I'm put it beneath the classics but before the--
- Yeah me too. - Me too!
Okay.
- We're back y'all. - Team, Team.
♪ It's Kelsey, MBGK have a good day. ♪
♪ It's Kelsey MBGK, yeah. ♪
- That was lovely - Yeah, yeah.
Thanks so much, Ify! - Of course.
- Yeah, good representation.
OOh, Reese's dark chocolate.
- This is going to be interesting right out
the gate because this is antithesis to the white chocolate.
This is visible darker.
Bink.
- I think its better darker chocolate,
but that's just because I'm a dark chocolate fiend.
- The chocolate on the regular Reese's is too sweet and
this is a step back. - Is how it should be
- Off rip its probably going to be above classic so
we're looking now
where it sits - Yeah where in this
area. - I'm even gonna punch it
up a little more, and put it right here.
- I can't believe were so in sync right now.
- Yeah so.
- [Matt] One, two.
- I am a huge fan of nutter butter.
- Oh.
- And I forgot about these.
- Oh. - This may 'cause a rift,
because I'm might, this might be a inflated ranking.
- Well I love kit-kat.
Kit-kat is pretty much this but with out peanut butter.
Right?
That looks like kind of a big kit-kat to me.
- Beep.
(both laughing)
(chewing loudly)
- This pretty good.
- Oh yeah.
Every bite I take it gets better.
- It takes a little bit like a kit-kat,
I would say its not as firm as a kit-kat is.
Its a little softer.
- Yeah its all there,
You got your mouth feel,
you got your flavor,
you got a subtle notes,
you know, your peanut butter notes.
Like I said right out the gate as soon as I tasted it,
that this is going to be controversial.
Boom, that's where my potential pick.
Right there.
Right up with the cookie, - Whoa.
Over the Pieces, right there.
That's a nutter butter.
Whoa!
Whoa - I don't think it's
- Whoa. - better than the Pieces.
- Whoa. - But I don't think it's bad.
See like we said, like this isn't bad.
This is really good, - Yeah.
- its just that these are all so amazing
that its really hard.
- And this is amazing. - Yeah.
And I don't know if you were watching me
as I was eating that.
- I know, but I just I don't know.
It didn't feel quite as satisfying to me as
either a kit-kat or Reese's.
- I'll split the difference. - We could split
the difference.
- And I'll put it right above the Pieces.
- Oh that's nice of you.
(both laughing)
- This is dense.
Oh my (thuds)
- Oh no.
- It's like a drumstick. (laughs)
So Reese's fast break,
this is a king size again,
so I think we can split one. - Yeah.
- It is milk chocolate, peanut butter and nougets.
Ah.
- So I guess we'll take a bite?
- I kind of like it.
- Whoa.
- This is really good.
The chocolate on top is like weirdly crumbly,
which is kind of off from the rest of
the very smooth like gooey chocolate that
we've interacted with but
that texture on the bottom though,
the nougat, whoa!
- But the nougat itself is a little too neutral for me,
its so neutral that it just kind of
flat lines the whole experience once it's in your mouth.
I mean heres my pick right out the gate.
I was thinking this, but I'm give you this.
- I agree. - Okay.
- Yeah, but this is super good but
I don't think it can beat Pieces.
- Matt thinks this is the
second best under cups. - Yeah.
Because, you know, - Big cups.
since the vote saved my white chocolate from being last.
And it seems like y'all both are in agreement that
this is so good, I'm willing to make this trade.
(Kelsey gasps)
- Whoa! - So that's the trade
we're gonna make.
- You're too nice.
- Next!
What?
This is a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup,
frozen peanut butter dessert.
- Now with more Reese's peanut butter swirl.
- Wait they had to like add more because the
first time it wasn't good.
- Ain't enough peanut butter in there.
- Woah you already dug in there.
I haven't even opened yet.
- I'm too excited.
- Mmm.
- So the outer shell has like a Klondike bar like--
- See I was thinking like
magic show - integrity.
and this got like a fluffy,
- Oh yeah.
peanut buttery, ice cream.
I think we're veering off into a different land here because
you could pretty much go where ever with Reese's.
They're like literal Reese's peanut butter.
- That's just what, - We're not doing that.
- Reigning it in.
- There's like Reese's mixes - Yeah.
- We're not doing that.
- Do more than close representations.
- This is as close,
yeah this is pretty close to a cup but
like a frozen version. - Yeah.
- Okay, where would you place?
- See this is where it gets hard.
The more we start getting in this land,
we're now wondering is it good because its Reese's or
is it good because that's a dang ice cream snack?
- That's true,
Ice cream is its own game. - Yeah
- Ice cream's amazing.
I think I'm going to out it above Pieces.
I don't think its above original cup.
- We'll put it under.
- Let me just clarify though,
there are no losers, alright.
From here up its amazing.
And last but certainly not least,
a deviation,
can we say?
From the classic but also a classic in its own right.
- Oh yeah.
I Remember - From what I remember
I loved these. - Oh yeah.
Let's go.
- Yeah buddy! - Reese's Puff
- Reese's - Cereal.
- Puff Cereal.
Ify, would you say its almost unfair to
try to pit this Reese's Puff against it's brethren?
- Yeah, now this one, its above it.
- I think its like its own league.
I don't know how you
do it, you know? - If I ranked it
it'd be number one, I'd let that be known.
(Kelsey laughs)
But for one - Above the cup?
- Above the big cup, baby.
- Honestly this one probably could take it or leave it but
it makes more sense to rank its
brethren than it does to bring Puffs into this,
this thunder dome.
- Its just living on its own plane,
looking down at upon the Reese's thinking
yeah, y'all good,
I'm good too.
(Kelsey laughs)
(intense music)
- This is it.
- Yeah. - The final ranking.
Last chance to do any trades, any swaps.
I think the only trade and swap that come to my mind,
this guy with this guy.
- I think I'd actually be willing to make it too, honestly.
- Alright, then lets do it then.
- If you had these on the shelf next to each other,
I think I'd go for the Dark Chocolate Reese's
before the Reese's with Pieces.
(high pitched whistle)
- And alright, so we have one, two, three, four,
five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10, 11, 12.
- Great. - Reese's.
So coming in at 12, Reese's Outrageous.
Number 11, Reese White Chocolate cups.
- Number 10 Mini Reese's cups.
- Number 9 Reese's Sticks.
- Number 8 Reese's Pieces.
- Number 7 Reese's Fast Break.
- Number 6 Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
Frozen Peanut Butter Dessert.
- Number 5 Reese's Classic.
- Number 4 Reese's Holiday Shapes.
- Number 3 Reese's Stuffed with Pieces.
- Number 2 Reese's Dark Chocolate.
- Number 1 Reese's Cup the Franchise.
- Reese's Big Cup.
Woo, winner!
Congratulations to all the Reese's out there,
for all the Reese's we didn't get to taste today,
blame Matt.
I feel like I've don't need to have Reese's for like
another year.
But I've never felt so successful. (laughs)
I'm gonna go detox.
- Yeah I think that's a good idea.
Let's booch up.
- Booch up.
- Oh no! - I know this looks a lot like
Eugene from Try Guys' ranking videos.
I really tried to think of another way to display our
top choices, and I really couldn't think of any other way.
- This is the standard way to rank something, you know.
Before youtube that's how things were ranked.
(both laughing)
(upbeat music)