(musical note plays)
- What's going on guys?
Hanging with me right now,
I have the cast of 13 Reasons Why,
and we're about to play a game
of rate and debate on fan theories
of who killed Bryce Walker. Are you guys ready for this?
- [Christian] Oh no.
- Wow.
- Hang on. So we just put the number up
of how much we like the theory?
- You're getting ahead. I got you.
I'm gonna explain how this is. (all laugh)
- [Alisha] Calm down.
- [Nicole] Calm down, Christian.
Okay, so this is how it goes.
You're each going to take a turn,
read the fan theories out loud to each other,
and then you're going to rate the theory.
One is the worst, five is the best.
And then you guys can debate together
on why you think it's the best.
or the worst or eh, whatever you want to say.
All right?
Here we go, Justin. You're up.
- [Justin] Okay.
- From Sarcastic Express, two days ago.
(Timothy laughs)
- [Christian] Winner. - If it's not the Clay,
if it's not THE Clay Jensen
who killed Bryce Walker, I quit Netflix.
(all laugh)
- Yeah, so how on point were are they with that?
Ooh.
- Not just Bryce, not just Clay Jensen
but THE Clay Jensen.
- [All actors] THE Clay Jensen.
- That's what makes it a five.
- Yeah.
- [Nicole] You guys agree on that?
- [Christian] Yeah, I'm with that one.
- [Alisha] Wow, we were in unison?
- [Justin] Well, you're a four, so-
- [Nicole] Yeah, pretty close.
- [Justin] But.
- I was a five.
- Oh, okay.
- [Christian] Just because they quit Netflix.
- [Nicole] All right, I like it. Toss this one out.
All right, Christian.
Here we go.
- Oh, this one.
- [Nicole] Your fate is in my hands, technically.
- Ooh.
(Nicole laughs)
- Hashtag, oh, from Kassy, Kassidy Desnoyaire.
- [Nicole] Ooh.
- [Timothy] Who was that?
- I don't know. #WhoKilledBryceWalker.
Tyler literally has a closet full of weapons.
Like a FULL CLOSET.
(all laugh) - [Nicole] In all caps, right?
- Come on, you guys.
He was obviously Tyler. #realtalk, #fantheory
@13 reasons why
(all laugh)
- Well, Kassidy.
- [Alisha] Yup.
- [Timothy] Yeah.
(all actors debate on score)
- [Nicole] Five? Wow.
- It's really good.
- [Nicole] Okay.
- I just love the hashtags.
- I love the reiteration.
- What hashtag?
- All caps, a full closet.
(Alisha laughs)
- Come on, guys!
- If we're being technical, it wasn't a closet.
It was a trunk.
(all actors exclaim)
- Okay, wait, wait, wait. I redact. I redact.
- Is she docked for that?
- A four.
- [Justin] It's a one.
- [Alicia] Is she docked for that?
- I'm going with three. I'm going with three.
- [Nicole] Oh, wow. Okay. Details.
They're about the details.
- [Christian] Sorry, Kass.
- All right, here we go. Alisha, you're up.
- Okay.
- [Timothy] Oh, A fault!
(all laugh)
(Alisha laughs)
- Okay. This is from-
(all laugh)
This is from my KnedLz. LZ.
Who killed Bryce Walker?
Liberty high students, it was a group project.
(all laugh)
- [Nicole] Yes. Okay.
Do you guys know what that is, what it means?
- For extra credit. - That goes from the internet.
- [Alicia] Oh, really?
- It's a meme where it's like, us. It's a group project.
(all actors confess they didn't know)
- [Alisha] That's really good.
- It's a five.
- We're very in touch.
- [Nicole] In culture. Wow.
- You guys are rating really high. I like that.
- Dang, you just went-
- Ow! You cut my cheek!
- [Alicia] I'm so sorry!
- [Justin] It's okay. - I tried to be slick.
- Slick? Slits my retina.
- Could you imagine if that actually hit your eye?
(all actors talk about Justin's retina)
- Okay, What are your guys' reasonings on that?
Besides you really liked it.
- [Justin] Um.
- [Alisha] Meme culture is just very,
it's important in this day and age, I think.
- [Justin] Didn't know it was a meme.
I just thought it was funny, group project.
- Yeah.
- [Justin] It's clever.
- [Christian] I feel like the whole show
has been a group project.
- [Nicole] Yeah.
- Aww.
- [Nicole] That's cute.
♪ We're all in this together ♪
- [Nicole] Can I sing some of it?
♪ Having fun ♪
(Timothy laughs) - Should we do the full-
(Nicole laughs)
- Do you know it?
- [Nicole] Do you know the dance?
- No. No one knows it.
- Ready to milk that cow?
- [Nicole] All right, Timothy.
(Justin laughs)
- I have like, next,
- Every time someone sings that song
I get, like, a visceral reaction. I just-
- In a good way?
No, a terrible way.
- This is for, I'm sorry. I'm going to butcher this name.
Tanvir Kaur.
- [Christian] You wanna try that, again?
- [Alicia] Nailed it.
A tanvir kow kower.
- That accent right?
- It was cool.
(all actors laugh)
- [Nicole] It's okay.
- All right. Tanvir Kaur.
Netflix, who killed Br-
(all actors laugh)
Says, Netflix.
(all laugh)
- Can't you read it?
- It says, who killed Brace Walker?
(all laugh)
- [Justin] Brace Walker.
- And then me, Arya Stark.
- [Alicia] Oh.
(actors moan at joke)
- [Nicole] All right. Game of Thrones right there.
- That's solid.
- We were gonna dock it for the Brace,
but its Game of Thrones.
(all laugh and discuss Game of Thrones)
- [Nicole] Okay. Do you guys watch Game of Thrones?
- Oh yeah. Religiously.
- [Nicole] Okay.
- Not anymore.
(all agree it's sad Game of Thrones is over)
- A girl has no name.
- A girl has no TV show.
- [Nicole] But now everyone can watch your show.
- She's empowered.
- [Nicole] Now that Game of Thrones is over.
There you go. I plugged it for you.
- We can fill the void of Game of Thrones.
13 Reasons Why is very similar.
- Here's a real spoiler.
- Yeah, very similar. We have dragons.
- White walkers this season.
- We got Brace Walker.
- Brace Walker!
- Waka walker. He's white and a walker!
(all laugh)
- Dang.
- Oh my God.
Wow. I think we just figured it out. White walker.
- [Nicole] All right. You can toss that one out. (all laugh)
Here we go.
Oh, wow. Nice throw.
- [Timothy] That was impressive.
- [Justin] He's been working on it. All right. Here we go.
From Gloss.myKitten.
(all laugh)
That sounds
oddly sexual.
- [Alicia] Okay. What does? It's, like, gloss my kitten.
- I don't like the way you looked at me when you said that.
- I know, it was, like, dead eye contact with Mon.
- [Nicole] All of your reactions
are gonna be turned to gifs.
I can already see this happening. It's gonna be great.
- [Justin] Geez.
All right. Trailer, who killed Bryce Walker?
Answer, his actions.
I mean, that's fair.
- That's serious.
- That's a very logical theory.
- [Alicia] Yeah.
- And you're not wrong.
- It's pretty on the nose, I'd say.
- Who tweeted that?
- Neil DeGrasse Tyson. Yeah!
- I'm gonna give it a four.
- Okay.
- [Nicole] So why is it a four, Alicia?
- I wanted humor. And it was just a bit too logical, but.
- [Nicole] Okay, there you go.
- It was the logical fault.
- [Justin] You can't fault logic, Gloss.mykitten.
- Gloss.mykitten deserves a five.
- Oh.
- [Nicole] So for the username, but not the theory.
All right.
- I'm not giving it for the username.
- That was a three.
- [Nicole] Okay. Three. Alright, fair enough.
Gloss.myKitten. - [Justin] I'm being too nice.
I'm giving all fives.
- [Alicia] Gonna give fives across the board.
- [Nicole] You have three more chances
to be a little bit more intense.
- I think you were compensating here.
- Be the Simon of our group, please.
- Okay. This is this kinda cool.
- Babes n' Brews Podcast.
- [Alicia] Uh huh.
#FanTheory.
Obviously the writers killed Bryce Walker.
- [Justin] Ahh.
- Duh.
- I mean.
- [Nicole] I mean, obviously, right?
- #13ReasonsWhy3.
I was just kind of bummed out,
- [Alicia] Yeah.
- because I wanted more, I wanted more, Babes n' Brews.
- I know. They were throwing
a lot of logic at you guys today.
- [Justin] Is that a podcast? Babes n' Brews?
- I think I've heard of it.
- [Nicole] Babes n' Brews? Yeah.
- I'm just guessing. Oh, yeah. It says podcast.
- Yeah. Babes n' Brews.
- You guys should call in and be like,
what was with that really logical answer?
- [Alicia] Yeah.
- Like, oh duh. Okay.
- The writers did, so you're right.
- I'm gonna change it to a three 'cause it's a podcast.
I like podcasts.
- [Nicole] All right. Fair. I liked that.
You guys are giving points for other reasons.
- 13.
- [Nicole] 13 points.
- It's off the charts. - What did you give it?
- [Nicole] Wow.
- It's probably five again.
(all laugh)
- Timothy, so you liked the logic.
- [Timothy] Yeah, it was good logic.
I forgot what it was already, but.
(all laugh)
- [Nicole] So glad you're here with us. Okay.
- Tons to spare.
- [Nicole] Love it.
Okay. Two left. Alicia, your turn.
- My God!
- It's a novel!
- Do you want your reading glasses, or.
- I actually. Hazeleyes said, @13ReasonsWhy.
I think Jessica,
She snapped and Justin goes down for her.
Clay had the gun at the end of season two.
Exclamation mark, exclamation mark.
Jessica and Justin were the only other two
that were out there. Ooh.
Can't wait to find out. I know that seems typical.
Hannah has to live on, somehow, though.
- Woof.
- [Nicole] Wow. You performed that. I like it.
- Thank you.
- There was a lot of info in there.
- [Nicole] There was.
- She's all over the place.
- So, they think you did it,
because Clay had a gun, and something about him.
(Nicole, Alicia and Justin laugh)
- Yeah, like, I mean.
- What?
- She snapped, and then Justin goes down for me.
- [Justin] Oh, I see.
- And Clay had the gun.
- Yes.
- And you got, Justin got the gun.
- Jessica and Justin were the only other two
that were out there.
So we got the gun.
- Mmm hmm.
- Ooh. Can't wait to find out. I know that seems typical.
But also, Hannah has to live on, somehow, though.
- [Justin] Could you read it one more time from the top?
- Yeah, hold on.
- [Nicole] Perform it again, though.
Perform it again, 'cause that was great.
- I'm gonna try not to.
- What you are doing with that one. I don't know.
I'm gonna go with two because I'm left confused.
(all laugh)
- [Nicole] Okay. Here we go.
- [Justin] I like the high energy of the post versus-
- [Nicole] Are you giving another five?
- I'm giving Alicia a five for reading.
- Oh. Thank you.
- Maybe like a three, but five, 'cause of Alicia's.
- I don't wanna give anyone lower than a three, man.
Like, that was.
- Oh shoot.
- That was a lot.
- A two? Yeah, that was a lot, man.
- I gave a three.
- I give it a three, as well.
- Three, three, two, five. All right. Pretty good.
Last.
- [Timothy] Here we go.
- Okay. From Susan.
(all laugh)
- Just Susan.
- Oh, wow.
- Wait, that says Suzanne.
- I realized that after I said it.
(all laugh)
- What is it?
- It's Suzanne.
- Susan, Suzanne. Tomato, tomato.
- [Justin] Tomato, potato.
(all laugh)
- [Nicole] That's really what that was.
- Alright Here we go.
Maybe Monty killed him in a fit of rage,
and karma will get him in prison.
- Whoa.
- [Nicole] How close were they, hmm?
- Susan or zan?
- [Nicole] One. Ooh. Wow.
- [Christian] Geez.
- [Justin] I'm gonna give it a five,
'cause Tim fucked her name up.
I feel bad.
- Yeah, me too, me too.
- Wow. Is it because it's personal to your character?
Yes. That hits too close to home.
- [Nicole] I like that you two both got the ones
that were very directed towards your character.
- I know.
- [Nicole] That played out interestingly, right?
- That was an accident.
- I feel like that's something to do with the card holder.
- Yeah.
- [Nicole] All right.
(all laugh)
- This game is rigged.
- All right.
- All right, you guys.
Well, thank you so much for playing rate and debate.
We cannot wait to see you guys.
13 Reasons Why.
Season three.
(actors cheer)
- [Nicole] Thank you guys so much.
(upbeat music)