- We are gonna need a bigger mouth.
- Hey, I'm Felicia Day,
and we are doing a Try Not To Eat: Supernatural.
- Supernatural!
- Shotgun shuts his pie hole!
- I am going to cry.
I have been praying to Chuck for this episode.
(Cassie laughs)
- Any favorite cast members in particular?
- Jensen smells good, and Jared will definitely give you a wedgie.
- (PvF) Dean or Sam?
- (both) Dean. (Ash gasps)
- ♪ Carry on my wayward son ♪
- ♪ There'll be peace ♪ ♪ When you are done ♪
- (Dean) Hold on a second, I got a surprise for you.
- Hey, it's Sam.
- It's Mary!
- That's my friend, Sam. (Chris laughs)
- Oh my gosh, is this the fricking... The like, casserole?
- It's Dean and Sam, but not, not Dean and Sam.
- Not really, her real name is Sam, yeah.
(Chris laughs)
- I love a good casserole. - I know!
- (Dean) I take all of that bologna, all that sliced cheese,
and I put it onto a hot plate.
- That's not his real voice? - It's a touch of Batman.
(Chris laughs)
- Ooh! - Oh my God!
- Oh my God, it's like a Frito pie!
- I know, right? This is, like...
- (PvF) Would you like some hot sauce?
- What do you think?
(buzzer)
- (PvF) Sharon, I haven't even got! (Ed laughs)
- She didn't even make it to her chair yet!
- (PvF) We've cooked up the Winchester family favorite,
a Winchester Surprise, filled with meat and cheese,
and topped with a crunchy garnish,
it's the perfect fuel for a hunt.
- Oh, it smells so good!
- The Fritos!
- I love macaroni, and I love cheese.
- Can you tell me how good that is?
- Mm-mm.
- You're not gonna even describe it to me?
- Not even gonna describe it. - You're gonna leave me out!
- Fritos, okay. Fritos, bacon, noodles!
- No, you know what, no. This is literally my show!
- I'm just gonna put some on.
- Just a little, just a little. - Want some?
(both laugh)
- (PvF) You should just enjoy!
- Just enjoy once in a while.
(buzzer) - Oh, you're doing it.
- Mmm.
- I hear the chef here is a big Supernatural fan.
I feel bad about neglecting her creation,
and this is delicious. - (Chris) Right.
- I'm gonna go in. (Chris gasps)
(buzzer) - (grunts) She did it!
She did it. - Mmm!
- I'm at a crossroads,
'cause I want to eat this so badly.
- Mm-hmm.
- It's a little bit like Hamburger Helper,
but like on steroids?
- This is a Supernatural prize, it's gotta be a good prize.
- Don't stare at me. - (laughs) Look away.
- Okay.
- You're just the devil on my shoulder.
Ooh no. - Cassie, you should eat it!
- I'm gonna resist, no, I'm gonna resist.
I gotta resist.
- I don't know, man. Why do I do this?
Why?
- There is a prize at the end, there is a prize at the end,
there is a prize at the end, there is a prize at the end.
- I'm going for the win-chester today. - I don't know what, okay.
- (PvF) Feel free to slap him.
- I really hate that. (Chris laughs)
- (Dean) Hey, Tuesday. Pig 'n a poke.
- Oh my God, time loop! - (gasps) Pig 'n a poke?
- Classic diner scene. Classic.
- Pigs 'n a poke.
- Oh, this is a good episode! - Yeah!
- This is the best episode. - The repeat, yeah.
- The Groundhog Day episode!
- So they do this like 15 times throughout the episode.
- Pig 'n a poke, I'll take the pig.
- Pig 'n a poke! - I don't need the poke.
- This is such a good episode. The Trickster, I love the Trickster.
- It's so, oh, a pig in a poke looks really good.
- It's so good.
- If you only watch one Supernatural episode, this is it, guys.
(Ash gasps) - Oh my God!
- (PvF) Well, it may not be Tuesday,
but our special of the day, the pig 'n a poke,
is so tasty, that you'll wanna eat it hundreds of times,
just like Dean.
- Oh my God, it's like a pancake.
- Yeah!
- It's a little pancake. (buzzer)
- Yeah! - You're just going right in for it.
- This is so much wish fulfillment for me, Cassie.
- Pancake wrapped sausages. (buzzer)
I don't think I've ever done that.
- Mmm.
- Oh yeah, he had to eat it hundreds of times.
How did his poops happen? - Well, I... (laughs)
- Like if he, literally was like groundhogging it,
which is really gross to say, groundhogging it.
- Groundhogging it. (both laugh)
- I just... - It's a Winchester sausage!
(Cassie gasps) - (PvF) Ooh.
- That is an amazing selling point.
(both laugh)
- I don't know, I would need like a gourmet maple syrup
to really justify this.
- 100% pure maple syrup, just for you, Felicia.
- Oh my God! - Woah!
- Enjoy!
- Special treatment!
- No! (Chris laughs)
- Oh, thanks! - Ooh.
- (PvF) We'll do a nice little drizzle of...
- (Sharon) Oh yeah, that's right. - (PvF) Tree tears.
- We're both Dean girls, your name's Cass,
your name's literally Cass. - I know.
- You're the Cass to my Dean.
- Do you ever eat anything?
- I do, I have, and I've suffered the punishment before.
- Oh no, the way you put that...
- Come on, Cass! - (gasps) No, don't do the voice!
Don't do the voice. Something very weird will happen,
if you start doing a Dean Winchester voice. (laughs)
- How has somebody not picked up on that?
- Not just, literally just did this.
- It smells so good. This smells like...
- It tastes even better. - The per, shut up!
Oh no! (laughs)
- I'm not happy about this.
Now I'm making pancakes tomorrow.
- I'm gonna save this though. - Do you know the secret?
Goat yogurt. - Go-Gurt.
- Goat Go-Gurt.
- Charlie is my favorite character in frickin' Supernatural.
Charlie was here?
- (PvF) Charlie was here.
- So that's who I saw in the hallway?
- (PvF) You saw Charlie in the hallway.
- I'm gonna, I'm sorry, tree.
Can you pour this back in the bottle please?
(Chris laughs)
- My life is ruined. The day's over, the day's over!
- (Dean) Hey, Tuesday. Pig 'n a poke.
- Are you serious?
- Oh, what? - Are you doing this to us?
- That's so funny. Well done.
Alright, what is it really?
- (narrator) Supernatural is filmed before a live studio audience.
- Oh my God, this is one of my favorite episodes!
- Oh my God, is this the TV one?
(crowd cheers) - (laughs) I love this one.
- Look at the sandwich. - Oh my gosh!
- What is that?
- It's the giant sandwich! - Look at the sandwich!
- (Dean) I'm gonna need a bigger mouth!
- I'm gonna need a bigger mouth.
(Cassie laughs) Me too, Dean.
(both laugh) (crowd cheers)
- The live studio audience clapping!
- Are you kidding me? - (Ash) What the hell?
- Oh God! (laughs)
- (PvF) You're gonna need a much bigger mouth
for this comically large, but insanely delicious sandwich
that Dean makes with SMEAT when they're stuck in the TV sitcom.
- It looks very tasty. - It's very beautiful.
- We are gonna need a bigger mouth.
- This is an easy resist to me. - Yeah.
- Because ah, I don't know, ah. - Yeah, where do you start?
- There is absolutely no way I can even fit my mouth
around one of these layers, like...
- That's what she, that's what Dean said.
- (PvF) Ah! (buzzer)
(Cassie laughs)
- Tiny, tiny, minuscule bite.
(buzzer)
- (laughs) That's very close.
Oh my God. - (PvF) Oh my God.
- That's almost all of it.
- It's really good. - Aww, oh no!
- Are you really gonna hold out? - I want the reward, I want it!
- I don't want you to have the reward though!
- Why?
Because you're not getting the reward?
- Yeah, yeah! - Oh, you petty!
- I'm petty!
(Cassie giggles)
Ah.
(buzzer) Mmm.
- (PvF) Oh. - Mmm, that was really good.
- Oh, she ate.
- I did. - Big thumbnail.
- What if I sat on you and force fed you some bacon?
(Chris laughs) Would that be okay?
- If you sat on me? - I don't know!
- You were like let's take a picture for the thumbnail,
and I was like yeah, one of me biting it, rawr!
And then I just did it!
And now I'm just eating the sandwich! (laughs)
Damn it, you got me!
- A meat sandwich. - A meat sammy.
- It's a meat cute.
- Mmm. (Ed laughs)
- Ah! - Ah, it did fall!
- It happened! - It happened.
- Sponsored by Bounty, the quicker picker upper.
(Ed laughs)
- I can't deal with it, its loins are exposed to me.
- Its loins? (laughs) - It's just ham!
- It's flashing you, it's mooning you!
- Oh, well, hey!
- (Death) Eat.
- Ugh, I love that actor! - It's Death.
- Oh, Death. - Oof.
- (gasps) Oh my God, it's... - Deep dish!
- It's the deep dish pizza - Pizza!
- A deep dish pizza? - Yeah.
- Wait, I could really go for a pizza.
- I love how all of these are Dean food moments.
- See, I don't really count deep dish as pizza.
It's good, but it's not really pizza to me.
- Best skull in the business, this guy, look at it.
- I would be so intimidated just being in the same room.
- That is just such a cool moment when he gives him the ring.
- The Mark of Cain.
- Oh my God.
- I'm folding like a piece of fricking tissue paper.
- And even got the ring. - (Chris) Ooh!
- Look at that!
- (PvF) We insist you try some of this deathly delicious
Chicago style deep dish pizza.
After all, it is Death's favorite!
(buzzer)
(Ed laughs)
- The Great Wall of China crust.
Like, it's like, nothing's getting through there.
You know what I'm saying?
- Put it on, how does it feel? How does it feel?
(thunder crashes)
- (deeply) I'm Death. - ♪ Ooh Death ♪
(both laugh)
- If you put this ring on, you have to do his job.
- Okay. (Ed laughs)
- They made it seem so hard in the show.
- Plug, I guess. - Yeah.
- Ooh, there it is! (buzzer)
- Do it, do it, do it, do it, do it, do it.
- No, 'cause then I have to eat something gross!
- I'm eating this whole thing. I'm eating it for lunch.
If there's extra in the back, I'm taking that home.
- Look at that! The layers!
- You're doing it!?
- I'm not doing it, I'm not, I'm just smelling it.
I'm just tempting myself!
- I've had Chicago deep dish pizza before.
- I know.
- (PvF) You haven't had Death's favorite Chicago deep dish.
- That's very true.
- Oh my God, oh my God, oh my God, wah.
(buzzer)
It all started with that damn sandwich!
- Ugh! - ♪ No no no, no, no no no, no no no ♪
♪ Carry on my wayward son ♪
- And now I'm off the fricking deep end!
- ♪ There'll be peace ♪ ♪ When you are done ♪
♪ Lay your weary head to rest ♪ ♪ Don't you cry no more ♪
Okay, no more. - Wow!
- I mean, people will be like well, you pick it up anyways,
but if I have to eat it with a fork and knife, it's a pie.
Sharon's like watch me!
- A healthy spin.
- (PvF) It was the custom one,
since the other ones all have like garlic and onions and...
- Oh yeah. (laughs) - No, really?
- (PvF) Pepper, yeah.
So we got this one just for you.
(gasps) (buzzer)
- Oh!
- I did it! - She went for it!
- Oh, it's really good! (Chris laughs)
It's really good.
- Given where I'm at right now,
if I didn't, I'd have been all ah, here you go. (laughs)
- (PvF) Chris.
- Oh! - Wow!
- She can do this unfettered.
- Well, now you have to eat the punishment later.
- (Dean) The sandwich didn't do anything.
I don't know what you think you're gonna find.
- (laughs) Oh, it's this thing! (Sharon laughs)
- Oh my God, it's the Turducken Slammer!
- Look how young he looks!
- They say it's really good, but it turns you,
it can, it puts you into a trance.
- (Sam) Dude, you are completely stoned.
- He's very stoned.
- It's gonna be drugged.
- Oh! - Oh! (gags)
(both gag) (Ash laughs)
- (Dean) I think you pissed off my sandwich.
(Ed laughs)
- I think you pissed off my sandwich. (laughs)
- Look at his little beak! - Yeah!
- Look at his little face!
- Oh my God, that's so cute!
- (PvF) Why don't you take a bite of the new,
mind-numbingly delicious Pepperjack Turducken Slammer from Biggerson's?
It's so tasty, you won't even care what it's made of.
- I kinda care.
- Yeah, I'm like, I kinda care, because I don't wanna get
entranced by the Leviathan. - Mm-hmm.
- Oh, we're making out. - That's Destiel.
(both moan)
- I'm afraid to see like the gray.
- Turkey and duck and chicken.
- Mm-hmm, turducken. - In one patty.
- In one patty.
(buzzer)
- It's not a flamingo burger, by the way!
We just want to be very clear!
- I need this to flamin-go away.
- Oh God, I hate you. (laughs)
- (PvF) No. - This is so unpleasant.
- You hear that everybody?
- Finger guns? - Felicia Day says I'm unpleasant.
(both laugh)
- I wonder if it's actually filled with goo?
- See, that concerns me. (laughs)
- Ugh, look at all the...
Look at all the gray stuff in there.
- Oh, God, there's gray!
- Oh, there is gray in there! - Ew!
- What is that, what is that? - Ew, ew, ew, ew!
- Oh yeah, there's totally goo inside!
- (Cassie) Is there goo?
- Oh, that's an easy pass! Hoo, gro'!
- It smells very good though. - No, it does smell good.
- You don't wanna eat that?
- No, I think I'm good on this one.
I think I'm good on this one.
- (laughs) You think you're good on this one?
I don't need a Leviathan chomping my head off later.
- (PvF) Alright, well that is it, that is our challenge.
- No!
- Which means, I know what the prize is!
- (PvF) Congratulations, Ed and Chris!
You were able to avoid some Supernatural dishes,
and for that, we've got a feast Dean would be jealous of.
- What can I say, I'm a natural. - (PvF) Oh God.
- You might say I'm... - (PvF) Nope!
You are definitely not! - A...
- ♪ La la la la la la la la la la la ♪ - (PvF) No, no, no, no!
- Supernatural! (laughs) (bell rings)
- (Dean) Mmm, mmm, mmm.
- (Sam) Dude, it's a burger.
- (Dean) It's a treasure.
- Another insane Dean creation.
- Oh, is it all the burgers he eats throughout?
- Oh, that's really good.
- Aww, there's so much going on!
- That's so much food coming. - I'm getting so much Dean feast!
- It's a donut!
- A donut on top of a donut! - Burger!
- He is insane when it comes to his food, it's so funny.
- Oh no, pie! - Pies!
- Duh!
- Look at all that pie, aw! - All the pie!
- Yes. - I regret nothing!
- Ooh. - I'm doing that.
(Ed laughs)
(Felicia gasps)
- Two burgers?
(Chris laughs)
Chili cheese fries, whiskey and a beer.
- No! The Samulet!
- We could've had...
- (PvF) For our winners, we've got all of Dean's favorite foods.
A classic double bacon cheeseburger, Elvis's donut burger,
a pile of chili cheese fries, an ice cold beer,
a glass of whiskey, and of course, pie.
Lots of pie.
Oh, and your very own Samulet.
- Peach is probably gonna be my favorite here.
Apple would probably be my least,
just because I've had like a lot of apple pies.
And then this is gonna be fantastic.
Ugh, aww!
- You're welcome, audience! (laughs)
(Ed coughs)
- Oh yeah! - Why would you get three?
This is unfair, why would you get three pieces of pie?
Why would get that many? - Mmm!
- Stop it.
- There we go!
- Because this is the Elvis, to the culinary team,
and to Nicole, to everybody, I say
thank you, thank you very much.
- Wow it looks really good, there's peanut.
You got peanut butter and banana on the burger?
- Mm-hmm!
- Now a little bit of the chili cheese fry.
- You know you got a fork over here.
- No, I'm good. - Okay, fair enough.
- Just using my hand, I don't care.
- Does he realize it's not like an Eat In One Second Challenge?
- (PvF) No, I don't think so!
(Ed laughs) - I don't think so either!
- No!
- (PvF) Oh [censored], she's holding on to it!
- (laughs) Oh! - (PvF) Oh no!
- I'm not part of this!
- (PvF) That's not how this works!
- I can't be part of this! - No!
- (PvF) Well, unfortunately, Chef Ash, Cassie, Felicia, and Sharon.
- Yeah, well, we knew that one.
- (PvF) You were all tempted, and for that,
you must suffer the consequences.
♪ (tense music) ♪
- Oh golly! (Ed laughs)
- Oh! - Oh!
- Blood?
- Ugh. (gags) - Oh gosh.
(Ed gags)
- Oh, this is the demon blood?
- Oh no, no, this is not good. - They gave him like more powers?
- Yeah, yeah, this is not good.
- Jesus, Mary and John, are we drinking fricking demon blood?
- Well, I've gotta tell you, this meal, it's a mukbanger of a meal.
- Wow, just...
- Uh-oh!
- Rude!
- Ugh! (Ed gags)
- (PvF) And for our losers, you'll get a taste of Sam's vice,
demon blood, but we doubt it'll make you feel
as good as it does him.
- It's a little thinner than most blood,
but I don't know about demons, it...
(gags) (PvF laughs)
- Should put some blood thinner in it.
- Yeah. (both laugh)
- Ugh. (Ash laughs)
- This smells like you dropped a cigarette in here.
- It's not anything that should ever be in liquid form.
(Chris laughs)
It smells smokey.
- You are a demon!
- (PvF) It's good for you! - You are a demon!
(Sharon coughs)
- Oh boy. - I'm serious.
My stomach is turning in anticipation.
(gags)
- (PvF) Ed! - Ah.
Power!
- (PvF) I did eat a bite with you, so I will also do one sip with you.
- Yeah! - Oh, okay, okay.
- (PvF) So cheers! - Cheers!
- Oh boy.
- Ooh, it, ooh. - Right?
(Felicia gags)
- It's gross, right? This is not even a joke.
- (laughs) Okay, I'm doing it.
(Ash gags)
- It tastes like (coughs).
- I'm dead serious, you guys need to get some help for this guy.
- It tastes like a cigarette.
- You're licking the bottom of an old barbecue, right?
- (laughs) Oh my God!
- It fills your whole mouth with something terrible.
- What was in it? Can we get some ingredients?
- (PvF) It's pork blood, liquid...
- (gags) What, there's blood in here?
I drank blood? - (PvF) Yeah!
(carton clatters)
- I just can't with this guy.
(Ed laughs) I can't.
- Hey, I'm Felicia Day,
thank you so much for having me on the show!
I will never come back. Please like and subscribe.
If you wanna check out my work,
you can follow me @FeliciaDay everywhere,
or except felicia.day at TikTok, but whatever.
I have a scripted podcast that I have been working on for five years.
It's called Third Eye, Neil Gaiman is in it,
Sean Astin from Lord of the Rings, Wil Wheaton.
Preorder it now, it's out on October 5th,
and yeah, hear me then!