♪ ♪
PICO HEARTBREAKING UNIVERSITY OF
IDAHO STUDENTS DANCING AND
CHOKING INSIDE THE HOUSE WHERE
THEY WERE LATER SLAUGHTERED.
THE VIDEO POSTED A MONTHLY FOR
THE KILLING AND THE POLICE STILL
NO CLOSER TO FINDING OUT WHO
MURDERED THEM.
IT HAS BEEN NEARLY TEN DAYS
SINCE THE STUDENTS BRUTALLY
BUTCHERED IN THEIR BEDS.
THE VICTIMS OUT SATURDAY NIGHT
TO A FRAT BAR AND A LOCAL
SPORTS BAR.
ALL GOT BACK TO THE HOUSE BEFORE
2:00 A.M. SUNDAY.
THE POLICE THINK THEY WERE
KILLED THREE TO FOUR HOURS
LATER.
TWO OTHER ROOMMATES IN THE HOUSE
THE ENTIRE TIME AND SLIPPED
THROUGH THE ATTACK.
NOW, THEY WERE GOING PIERCE THE
CRIME SCENE MAY HAVE BEEN
CONTAMINATED.
THE AUTHORITIES EXPENDING FOR
SEARCH AND COMING THROUGH THE
WOODS IN A PARKING LOT AND A NEW
AREA BLOCKED OUT BEYOND HOME.
EXPERTS TAKE CATCHING THE KILLER
COULD COME DOWN TO SMALL
DETAILS.
>> PERHAPS THE DEATHS DID NOT
OCCUR AT THE SAME TIME BUT
WHOEVER DID IT COULD HAVE BEEN
LYING IN WAIT.
ONE OF THE THINGS THAT HAVE
HELPED DETERMINE THAT IS THE
TIMES OF DEATH AND THE MEDICAL
EXAMINER AT THE SCENE MAY BE
ABLE TO TELL WHETHER OR NOT THE
FOUR VICTIMS WERE KILLED AT THE
SAME TIME OR DIFFERENT TIMES AND
SOMETIMES THE PERPETRATOR IS CUT
BY THE SLIPPAGE OF THE NIGHT.
SOME OF THE BLOOD AT THE SCENE
CAN BELONG TO THE PERPETRATOR.
HE MAY THEN BE ABLE TO EVALUATE
THAT.
>> Harold: JUDGE THIS IS
HEARTBREAKING STORY THAT I’VE
SEEN IN THE LAST FEW YEARS.
WE HAVE NO LEADS HERE.
YOUR EXPERIENCE IN THIS SPACE,
WHAT INFORMS YOU AND WHAT DO YOU
THINK ABOUT THIS?
>> Judge Jeanine: THE WHOLE
COUNTRY IS FOCUSED ON THIS
BECAUSE MOST PEOPLE THINK IT IS
2022.
WHY IS IT TAKING SO LONG?
WHY DON’T WE KNOW WHAT HAPPENED?
FIRST OF ALL, I’M ASSUMING
THERE’S NO EYE WITNESS, NONE
THAT WE KNOW OF YET.
WHAT DOES THAT TELL YOU?
THAT TELLS YOU THE MOST
IMPORTANT EVIDENCE IS THE
FORENSIC EVIDENCE.
THE FORENSIC EVIDENCE WILL
IDENTIFY WHO THE KILLER WAS.
NOT ONLY FROM ONE PARENT WE
HEARD DEFENSIVE ROOTS, OKAY,
WHICH MEANS, YOU KNOW, THE
KILLER MAY HAVE BEEN IN A FIGHT
MAYBE HE GOT CAUGHT.
BUT WE ALSO KNOW THE KNIFE THAT
IS A RAMBO KNIFE, WHICH PRESSED
IN THE HILLS WHERE THE BRUISING
CAME FROM.
SO THERE WAS TREMENDOUS STRINGS
OR A TREMENDOUS FIGHT HERE.
AND IF YOU GOT A LOCAL POLICE
DEPARTMENT THAT IS RESPONDING TO
A CALL OF SOMEONE BEING
UNCONSCIOUS, WHAT DOES THAT TELL
YOU?
THAT TELLS YOU THAT THESE KIDS,
THE TWO THAT MADE THE CALL AND
WE KNOW THE CALL CAME FROM ONE
OF THEIR PHONES HERE ARE THE
KIDS ON THE FIRST FLOOR, WHAT
DID THEY SEE?
HOW MUCH OF THE ROOM DID THEY
SEE?
WHY DID THEY SAY UNCONSCIOUS
WHEN THERE WAS BLOOD RUNNING OUT
OF THE HOUSE ON THE OUTSIDE OF
THE HOUSE?
AND WHERE DID THEY GET THIS
UNCONSCIOUS FROM?
WHY ARE THEY SAYING THAT?
ARE THERE FOOTPRINTS IN THE
BEDROOM ON THE SECOND OR THIRD
FLOOR?
IF THERE WAS SO MUCH BLOOD THAT
WHAT YOU HAVE IS A KILLER THAT
IS STEPPING IN THE BLOOD AS HE’S
KILLING THESE KIDS.
BUT IN ADDITION TO THAT, YOU
HAVE THE OTHER TWO KIDS AND YOU
HAVE TO ELIMINATE THEIR
FOOTPRINTS.
YOU HAVE THE LOCAL POLICE
RESPONDING TO "UNCONSCIOUS."
I GUARANTEE THEY DIDN’T HAVE
SLIPPERS ON OR HAVE ANY IDEA
THIS WOULD BE QUADRUPLE SERIAL
HOMICIDE.
SO THEY WOULD HAVE MESSED UP THE
SCENE.
I DON’T MEAN TO CRITICIZE THE
LOCAL PD.
THEY CAN’T EXPECT TO UNDERSTAND
HOW THIS STUFF WORKS.
AND FOUR WEBB THEM KILLED.
WERE THEY BOUND AND GAGGED,
INCAPACITATED?
HOW DID THE OTHER TWO KIDS DID
NOT HEAR ANYTHING?
HOW DID THE OTHER TWO OF THE
FOUR DEAD DID NOT HEAR ANYTHING?
I’M SURE HALF OF THE GANG WERE
DRUNK.
BUT THEY WERE STRUCK A FEW
MINUTES BEFORE.
YOU KNOW, THEY WERE NOT DROPPING
TOWN DRUNK.
AND FINALLY, THE ONE THING I
WANT TO SAY IS THAT THIS SHOULD
HAVE BEEN A CASE WHERE THE FBI
WAS CALLED IMMEDIATELY.
THERE FORENSIC EVIDENCE OF
POTENTIAL IS UNPARALLELED.
>> Harold: THEY ARE INVOLVED
NOW.
>> Judge Jeanine: THEY ARE
INVOLVED NOW BUT THE CRIME SCENE
IS CONTAMINATED.
WHEN THEY GET TO THE TRIAL
ASSUMING SOMEONE EVER AND MAYBE
THEY AND NOT SOMEONE.
IT MAY BE MORE THAN ONE PERSON
BOUND AND GAGGED, STABBED AND
KILLED THESE POOR PEOPLE AND IF
YOUNGER WOULD’VE PUT UP A FIGHT.
THEN THE QUESTION IS THE
FORENSIC EVALUATION THAT YOU
HAVE COME OF CRIME SCENE WAS TO
DONATE CONTAMINATED.
WE DON’T KNOW IF IT WAS HIS OR
HERS.
>> Harold: BRIAN.
>> Brian: WE KNOW THAT UBER
DRIVER AND THE GUY IN THE WHITE
SHIRT WE ELIMINATE HIM AND THE
ROOMMATES WE ELIMINATE THEM.
WAIT A SECOND.
WHAT DID THEY DO TO MAKE SURE
THAT THEY WERE ELIMINATED INTO
YOUR POINT, I DON’T UNDERSTAND,
THEY KEEP SAYING ONE OF THE
PHONES.
INSTEAD OF SAYING THE ROOMMATE
USED ONE OF THE PHONES, THEY SAY
THE PHONE WAS USED.
WHO MADE THE PHONE CALL?
WHAT DO YOU MEAN UNCONSCIOUS?
YOU CALL SOMEBODY BECAUSE
UNCONSCIOUS AND HOW CAN YOU BE
BLEEDING TO DEATH AND
UNCONSCIOUS?
THAT IS IMPOSSIBLE.
>> Dana: CAN I ASK THE JUDGE A
QUESTION AS PART OF MY TIME?
>> Harold: YES.
>> Dana: IF SOMEBODY COMMITS A
MURDER OF FOUR PEOPLE, WOULD
THAT BE THE FIRST TIME THEY EVER
COMMITTED A CRIME OR LIKE WE
HAVE SEEN BEFORE, CAN THE
COLORADO SPRINGS SHOOTING THERE
HAD BEEN TROUBLE AND PLACE AN
ELECTION IN THE PAST.
>> Judge Jeanine: IS THIS A
FIRST TIME KILLER?
I SERIOUSLY DOUBT IT.
I REALLY DO DOUBT IT.
THEY KEEP SAYING HE WAS SLOPPY,
HE WAS SLOPPY.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
DID HE LEAVE FINGERPRINTS?
SHOW IT, DO SOME DNA.
IT DOESN’T MEAN IT WAS SLOPPY AS
A RESULT OF WHAT HAPPENED, KIDS
SLIDING IN BLOOD.
YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT HAPPENED AND
WHERE THEY WERE FOUND.
THE CHANCES ARE KILLED FOUR BUT
NOT FOR THE FIRST TIME.
>> Jesse: HE IS NOT THAT
SLOPPY BECAUSE THEY HAVEN’T
CAUGHT HIM YET.
MY PROFILE OF THIS PERSON IS A
POLO STUDENT AT THE UNIVERSITY
WHOSE HOW THIS GROUP OF STUDENTS
WHO WERE POPULAR IN GREEK LIFE,
WELL PUT TOGETHER AND HAD A LOT
OF POTENTIAL AND GOING PLACES
AND HE WASN’T GOING PLACES.
HE WAS NOT IN THIS SCENE AND HE
WAS JEALOUS, ENVIOUS AND FLEW
INTO A FIT OF RAGE, TARGETED
THEM, SCOPED THEM OUT, WENT IN
THERE WITH A KNIFE WHICH IS
PERSONAL, AND HE WANTED TO SEE
THE FEAR IN THEIR EYES.
WHEN HE STABBED THEM HE WANTED
TO PROCESS THAT CAN FEED OFF OF
THAT.
GOD KNOWS WHERE HE IS NOW, BUT
LAST NIGHT, YOU LOOK AT THE
BLOOD SPLATTER AND YOU CAN TELL
IF SOMEONE IS RIGHT-HANDED OR
LEFT-HANDED AND YOU HAVE TO GET
A PRINT HOPEFULLY BECAUSE YOU
CAN TELL THE SHOES SIZE, THE
TYPE OF SHOES.
BUT THERE IS NOT A LOT OF THINGS
TO GO ON RIGHT NOW.
AND A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE SAYING
THAT THE POLICE -- AND YOU KNOW
BECAUSE YOU MADE THE POINT YOU
HAVEN’T SEEN A HOMICIDE IN SEVEN
YEARS IN THIS TOWN.
THEY NEED A LOT OF HELP.
>> Harold: THERE IS NO WEAPON,
RIGHT?
>> Judge Jeanine: THERE IS NO
WEAPON.
THEY JUST SAID ONE WEAPON AND
ONE GUY.
THE WHOLE IDEA...
>> Harold: THEY THINK IT IS
ONE GUY BUT ARE YOU CONVINCED OF
THAT?
>> Judge Jeanine: NO!
BY THE WAY, WHY DIDN’T THEY KILL
THE OTHER TWO?
THEY WERE IN BED AT THE SAME
TIME.
>> Harold: UPSTAIRS FROM A
DIFFERENT FLOOR.
>> Judge Jeanine: SO EVERYONE
WAS ON A DIFFERENT FLOOR.
>> Harold: ’S TERRIBLE STORY,