“Is the Atreides ready?”
Feyd-Rautha called, using the words of the ancient kanly ritual.
Paul chose to answer him in the Fremen way:“May thy knife chip and shatter!”
Frank Herbert’s Dune Saga presents a large assembly of diverse multifaceted characters
whose stories intricately convey the author’s various complex themes.
The story of Dune showcases the rise of a hero as we follow the journey of Paul Atreides,
however the path of another influential figure, Feyd-Rautha of the rival House Harkonnen,
stands as a dark reflection of Paul’s character arc, whose villainous nature provides a contrast
to the noble qualities in the young Atreides heir.
In this video I’d like to examine these two powerful characters leading up to their
epic clash and how their dynamic contributes to the rich mythology of the Dune Saga.
Spoiler warning if you are unfamiliar with Frank Herbert’s Dune.
Despite being arch-rivals, Paul Atreides and Feyd-Rautha are similar in many ways.
Both are born into nobility, heirs of their respective houses expected to carry on their
family’s legacy.
Paul who would one day replace his father Duke Leto Atreides, and Feyd-Rautha Rabban
chosen to succeed his uncle Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.
These young men are also pawns in a larger scheme, their lives predetermined by the manipulations
of powerful entities throughout the Imperium.
However, both attempt to forge their own paths despite the influence of others.
They are each a part of a centuries-long breeding program conducted by the Bene Gesserit intended
to produce a superbeing known as the Kwisatz Haderach, making their existence a major factor
in the sisterhood’s hopes to shape the political landscape.
In contrast to Paul, Feyd-Rautha was raised in an environment characterized by deceit
and cruelty.
Trained as a gladiator, Feyd's life reflects his uncle's insidious influence.
His ambition, intelligence, and physical prowess are all directed towards achieving power through
manipulation and violence.
At one point in the novel Paul is challenged in a duel to the death by the Fremen Jamis.
This is a defining moment in Paul’s journey as he must utilize every bit of his training
from his mother and his mentors to survive.
He defeats Jamis having reluctantly seen the Fremen challenge through.
This event was significant in Paul’s life as he had never killed anyone before.
His mother Lady Jessica made sure he felt the full weight of his action by asking how
it felt to be a killer.
Paul gave way to tears at the funeral ceremony of Jamis citing that the fremen warrior taught
him that when you kill you pay for it, indicating the heavy burden he now carried.
In stark contrast to this moment, Feyd-Rautha, in celebration of his 17th birthday and his
official status as Baron Harkonnen’s chosen heir, killed his 100th slave gladiator.
As the duel commences it becomes clear that though Feyd-Rautha is a fearsome warrior,
in actuality what makes him so lethal is his devious nature.
True to his Harkonnen upbringing Feyd never fights fair, making sure he has several advantages
over his opponent.
One of these advantages was a key word which had been implanted in the slave gladiator’s
subconscious mind that when spoken would immobilize his muscles.
Though Feyd’s usual opponents were gripped with drug- induced terror, in this particular
fight he faced a clear headed highly trained Atreides soldier.
Feyd accepted this risk as part of a calculated move to quicken the path to his succession
of House Harkonnen.
He ended up using every advantage he had over his opponent in order to achieve victory including
switching the traditionally poisoned tipped blade to his other hand.
The Harkonnen resolved to give those in attendance a show the likes of which they’d never seen.
Ensuring that all in the audience would remember that day and know to fear him whenever he
eventually became Baron.
These pivotal moments perhaps more than any others demonstrate several points of contrast
between the diverging lives of Paul and Feyd.
The upbringing, choices, and influences surrounding the Atreides and Harkonnen heirs set them
on drastically different paths, yet they are both destined to be hailed as saviors to the
Fremen.
Initially a young noble being groomed for a leadership role, throughout the course of
Dune, Paul experiences a series of trials and transformations that elevate him to a
status akin to a messiah.
Meanwhile, the Baron’s schemes center heavily around his nephew Feyd, who is considered
the ideal heir due to his intelligence and charisma, which starkly contrasts to the brutish
tendencies of Feyd’s older brother Glossu "Beast" Rabban.
After the people of Arrakis had been subjected to Glossu's oppressive rule, Feyd-Rautha was
intended to be introduced as a savior in the eyes of the planet’s inhabitants.
As their journeys continue, the differences in these two would-be heirs become even more
pronounced.
Paul’s rigorous training, coupled with an ability to embrace change and hardship, enables
him to adapt to life among the Fremen and eventually to walk the destined path that
leads him to religious and political supremacy.
Paul's experiences also afford him an understanding of his prescient abilities, allowing him to
see a broader picture of the universe and the potential paths that lie before him.
On the other hand, Feyd’s ruthless ambition and reckless bravado often blinds him, making
him vulnerable to manipulation and consequently driving him toward his downfall.
The climax of the novel brings the two characters face-to-face in a duel to the death.
In a symbolic representation of their contrasting paths, Paul fights with the sacred crysknife,
embodying his commitment to the Fremen and their traditions.
Paul is made aware of the Bene Gesserit conditioning Feyd-Rautha had likely received enabling him
to speak a key word rendering Feyd immobile and vulnerable to a lethal strike.
However, Paul resolves not to use any such advantage, other than the natural upper hand
Feyd’s overconfidence would grant him.
Conversely, Feyd’s penchant for using whatever advantage he has at his disposal to win is
well known.
Every bit the product of a Harkonnen upbringing, Feyd-Rautha is treacherous, relying on tricks
within tricks.
Not only does Feyd fight with a poison laced blade to slow the muscles of his opponent,
but on his person he’s also secretly equipped with a poisoned flip dart, a flagrant disregard
for the formal rules of their kanly sanctioned duel.
This deceit is emblematic of his contempt and disdain for honor and tradition.
Paul’s defiant refusal to resort to similar trickery was born out of his desire not to
owe anyone else for his victory over the last vestige of House Harkonnen.
Even though he came close to death he defeated his Harkonnen rival with honor bringing an
end to their families’ longstanding feud.
While the following books would further emphasize the pitfalls of Paul’s rise to power and
the dangers of blindly following charismatic leaders, Feyd’s death at the hands of Paul
in Dune emerges as a symbol of triumph over the Harkonnen’s ruthless governance and
unchecked ambition.
Ultimately, the clash between Paul Atreides and Feyd-Rautha stands as a testament to the
transformative power of adaptability, and the enduring importance of justice, integrity
and honor, against the perils of succumbing to greed and corruption.
But I’m curious to know what you think of the contrasts and final confrontation between
Paul Atreides and Feyd-Rautha of House Harkonnen.
Are there any comparisons between their individual characteristics or elements of their backgrounds
that stand out to you?
Let me know your thoughts in the comment section below.
I hope you enjoyed this video.
Leave a like if you did and be sure to subscribe for more Dune and other sci-fi and fantasy
news and lore.
Thank you all so much for your support and as always have a very nerdy day.