This episode was made possible by the YouTube Creators for Change program.
What does it mean when we say someone is a "good student"?
I figured for many of us,
a "good student" means someone who gets high, if not perfect, grades,
is never late to class, and always has a readily sharpened pencil close at hand.
We don't think of strugglers, stragglers,
or people with performances that fluctuate.
But, confession time.
At different points in my own academic career, I've been that person.
So, how did I go from the kid
who almost failed three classes in eighth grade to earning a PhD?
Looking back, my struggles with school
stem from adolescent mental health problems.
Luckily, I was able to get these under control early on
with help from teachers, counselors, and my family.
Yet, throughout the ups and downs,
I've always considered myself, at heart, a truly good student,
even when my grades and performance belied this feeling.
And that's the big question on my mind.
What does it mean when we say "good student"?
Who do we assume that good students are?
What's their look, their background?
And what factors keep certain groups specifically
from achieving academic success?
Specifically, I want to talk about young girls
because, look, this video started with me reflecting
on my own life and strife with our education system.
And that makes me wonder, "What are some of the barriers facing young girls today?"
"How are we assessing what young girls need in classrooms
throughout the US?"
One barrier to success for young girls
could be good old-fashioned gender bias.
Although, maybe that's the wrong wording
since there's nothing good, but plenty old-fashioned about gender bias.
A 2015 study from the Making Caring Common Project
at the Harvard School of Graduate Education
found gender bias over teen girls' leadership abilities was present,
not only in the adults around them, but also in their peers.
The research team, led by Richard Weissbourd,
found several key findings after surveying nearly 20,000 students.
First, almost a quarter of teen girls, 23%,
preferred male over female political leaders,
while only 8% of girls preferred female political leaders,
with 69% reporting no difference in preference.
Second, 40% of teen boys preferred male over female political leaders,
while only 4% preferred female political leaders,
with 56% expressing no preference.
And, third, as a specific group,
white girls tended to be biased against other white girls as leaders.
Although, in a scenario meant to demonstrate bias,
black and Latino boys and girls appear to face leadership bias as well.
This implicit bias against seeing them as leaders
could be one of the contributing factors that impede young girls at school,
and in the workforce after graduation,
because girls may be viewed as less capable
than their male counterparts.
Another challenge is gender bias coupled with racial bias.
Racial bias negatively impacts not only young girls in the US,
but all people of color who are moving through traditional academic roots.
One emergent issue that young girls and boys of color in the US today face
is the aptly named school-to-prison pipeline,
or a system where disciplinary infractions at school
lead to eventual imprisonment or time spent in juvenile detention centers.
And as this practice has become more and more common in schools across the country,
students of color and young girls of color are being disproportionately impacted.
A 2015 report found that black boys
are three times more likely to be suspended than white boys,
and black girls are a staggering six times more likely to be suspended
than their white counterparts.
The report also found that for young girls of color,
at times, the security rituals of entering a school,
for example, searches, metal detector,
and increased number of law enforcement officials,
sometimes contributed to girls feeling less safe.
They could even be deterrents to attending school altogether.
Additionally, girls of color and black girls were more likely to be referred
for punitive methods of conflict resolution in school,
which leads to greater involvement in the juvenile justice system
than if restorative responses like counseling and therapy had been employed.
Also, girls of color and black girls' other struggles
like trauma from interpersonal violence, harassment and bullying,
often go unmet or unnoticed in schools unless a punishable offence occurs,
meaning that these issues are only addressed through punishment.
And some girls in the study reported acting out
as a result of not having their needs met.
I can personally say that when I was a struggling student,
the fact that educators
used suggestions for restorative methods of addressing the problem,
instead of just suspending me or kicking me out of school,
made a world of difference.
Their focus was on addressing the underlying issues
and not just punishing me for falling behind in my classes and acting out.
And being overlooked or unfairly treated on the basis of gender or race
can lead to various negative mental health outcomes for students.
A 2016 report from The Jed Foundation and The Steve Fund
found that by the time they were in the early years of college,
these mental health disparities started to show amongst students.
The report found that
among the approximately 1,500 first-year students surveyed,
white students were more likely than their African American peers
to feel emotionally prepared for college,
and African American students were more likely than their white counterparts
to keep those feelings to themselves.
So, how do we solve all of these mounting problems?
In the case of leadership bias,
the study recommends checking our implicit and explicit bias about female leadership
and not passing on those biases to young girls
who are experiencing their first leadership positions in schools.
And for girls of color and black girls
who are being disproportionately impacted by the school-to-prison pipeline,
the answer could be looking for solutions that center care, outreach and help
over punitive measures like suspension, expulsion or prison.
And in all cases, access to mental health care and counseling
could have a positive impact for young girls and students of color
who are struggling with microaggressions, imposter syndrome
and depression in school.
On a final note,
I think that a lot of these solutions are actually asking us
to think differently about what it means to be a good student.
Part of the problem is that we start from the assumption
that there is such a thing as a prototypical good student
who has impeccable grades, no disciplinary issues,
and excels at everything that they do.
But what I've learned from my history,
both as a struggling student and as an educator today,
is that good students come in all shapes and packages.
A student can get really poor grades in class
and still be exceptionally talented.
A student can struggle or be misjudged or mistreated,
and still have gifts that exceed what we're teaching them in classrooms.
Being a good student doesn't mean that you never struggle,
rather, it should mean that in spite of the challenges you face
inside and outside of the classroom,
you still have a willingness to learn.
It was one of the greatest gifts
that at a time when I was a failing student,
my teachers, family and counselors never looked at me as a failure.
Instead, they saw that I was struggling with something
and worked to address my struggles.
If you take anything from this video, let it be this:
empathy in the classroom rather than antipathy
can yield incredible results.
After all, young students everywhere deserve every chance they can get
to be a good student.
So, what do you think?
Have any fun or challenging school-day stories
to share with me and your fellow Originauts?
Drop them down below, and we'll see you here next time.
We'd like to thank the YouTube Creators for Change program for supporting PBS.
YouTube Creators for Change is an ongoing global initiative
that spotlights creators who use YouTube
to foster productive conversations around tough issues
and make a positive impact on the world.
This year, YouTube Creators for Change is partnering with Michelle Obama
to highlight the global state of girls' education,
the value of education, and to drive action amongst viewers.
For more information, go to the link in the description.
Hey, Originauts, this is just a reminder
that you can become a member of our Patreon page.
Starting at $3 a month, you can gain access to a patrons-only feed
with all types of cool behind-the-scenes footage
as well as 24-hour early access to every new video.
And at some of our higher tiers, you can also get other great benefits.
So check out the link in the description. I'll see you soon.