Ruling to recite with a loud voice in the mosque
Can you read the Quran with a loud voice in the mosque?
Mehmood sahab from India
If someone does not mind, if there is no disturbance in the worship of someone, then you can read, if there is a disturbance then you cannot read.
Nikah rule on conference call
If married on a conference call and then divorced, then what is the rule. Was that marriage done right or not?
Sara Shaikh from karachi.
See if the marriage took place on a conference call this way
Suppose the witnesses are present, the girl or the boy has made someone a lawyer to accept.
An example, the girls are in America, the boys are in Karachi.
Now where the boy is sitting in Karachi on mobile or on skype, if there is a witness with the boy.
What did the girl do now, the boy had someone present here, Qazi sahab was present for example
She told that I allow you to get me married on my behalf with this man who is sitting beside you.
Then what will be the Qazi, he will become the lawyer of the girl.
Hence it's like a witness is present between them, the girl is not here but her lawyer is present.
So this is what we call nikah on video call, but in reality this is not called as getting married on call
On call, girl is making someone her lawyer to accept.
In reality, by physical presence of witnesses at the time of nikah, so this will not be considered nikah on conference call,
it's just considered a proper nikah which commonly happens.
Turn it upside down, witness is present in America, witness is present with the bride.
The boy made Qazi sahab a lawyer on a conference call and told to marry him with this girl.
Now Qazi sahab is lawyer and hence two witnesses are present as well.
So it's just like a conference call but in reality this is not called as conference call marriage.
It is just like physically two witnesses are present, where the confession is taking place.
Hence this nikah will be considered, if divorce given that will be considered as well.
If this is not the case, suppose the girl is in America and the boy is in Karachi.
Witness are present with the boy, girl accepted on the conference call and the witnesses heard, then we call this as getting married on video call.
Suppose witnesses are present, the girl is accepting on call or witness is present with the girl but not with the boy
But the witness is listening to them, or the winess is not physically present with any of them, but the witness is listening on the call.
Then this marriage is considered or not according to scholars, this marriage will not be considered because witnesses need to be present physically.
All this situation where boy is somewhere, girl is somewhere and the witnesses are somewhere, directly accepting on call and witness is listening to them,
then according to scholars the nikah will not be considred.
But some senior scholars do accept, the method is not acceptable but nikah is considered.
Not acceptable because against the precaution.
Few scholars accept it but few don’t, then there is a confusion because later on, even they got divorced.
If nikah is considered then even divorce will be considered.
If nikah is not considered then even divorce will not be considered, hence again they can remarry.
So it's better to take a legal opinion in written from reliable Institute of Islamic Jurisprudence, which ever is nearest.
Follow the fatwa given.