hey brother J on Tuesday you went over seven of our top eight unanswered questions from fantastic
beasts and where to find them and today I'm going to be discussing the undisputed number
one top unanswered question is Ariane a Dumbledore and obscure you'll just a heads up there will be
spoilers from fantastic beasts you have been warned an obscure in case you need a refresher
from the movie is whenever a witch or wizard develops an obscurus inside of them by suppressing
their magical power and obscure us is a parasitic dark magical force that can literally erupt from
an obscure you in a dark amorphous cloud these eruptions are often very violent and occur when
the obscure eole is under immense stress typically an obscurest will kill off its hosts before they
reach age 10 the lone known exception being credence barebone in fantastic beasts who was
clearly older than age 10 but credence may not have been the only or even the first exception
the first obscure to live past age 10 may have been none other than Ariana Dumbledore who died
27 years earlier in 1899 at age 14 here is her story let me know if it sounds familiar at age 6
Ariana Dumbledore was in her backyard practicing magic when some muggle boys saw her when she was
unable to show them how to reproduce the magic they attacked the event left her traumatized and
here is the quote from Aberforth Dumbledore in the deathly hallows about ariana it destroyed
her what they did she was never right again she wouldn't use magic but she couldn't get rid of it
it turned inward and drove her mad it exploded out of her when she couldn't control it and at
times she was strange and dangerous but mostly she was sweet and scared and harmless the key
word there is wouldn't not couldn't it wasn't that she was unable to do magic she was just
repressing it and as a result it turned inward drove her mad and exploded out of her that sounds
insanely similar the greatest not not even similar that is what happened to Creedence Mary Lou beat
him for showing any interest in or signs of magic like Ariana he seems mysterious maybe but mostly
sweet scared and harmless until he just can't control it anymore and it explodes out of him
in a black cloud of destruction and just like credence Arianna was destructive when she was
14 she caused an explosion that killed her mother what been fantastic these takes place after Ariana
dies but newt still says no obscuri all has ever lived past age 10 if we know she lived to be 14
wasn't he have said 14 well if you saw our video on tuesday we speculated that credence was able
to hold in and eventually control the obscurus inside of him possibly due to the fact that he
is an extremely powerful wizard possibly even a descendant of Salazar Slytherin double doors
also seem to be a pretty powerful Wizarding family themselves so it's not impossible to believe that
Ariana would be able to hold hers in past age 10 and if she was an obscure you I don't think any
other wizards knew about it the double doors kept her out of school and most people didn't even know
she existed and those who did believed she was a squib but she was a squib just like graves thought
credence was a squib but just like credence she was not a squib the family kept her a secret
because of her father after she was attacked by the muggle boys her father Percival Dumbledore
attacked the boys back and was sent to Azkaban for it that might seem like a harsh punishment but
Percival never revealed the reason why he attacked the boys because he feared that Ariana would have
to be sent to st. Mungo's if her condition was discovered as it threatened the statue of secrecy
that is of reasoning why would Ariana being sick threatened the statute of secrecy plenty of other
Wizards have managed to get sick without the whole world finding out about it doesn't make much sense
unless Percival knows she's an obscure you'll and what can happen as a result because if you have
seen fantastic beasts his worst fears is exactly what happened straightens goes crazy and basically
reveals the Wizarding World to all of New York thank God it was there with his sweeping evil
Thunderbird rain serum very experimental highly dangerous kind of a miracle that it worked and
the similarities don't end there just like Newt and Tina were able to come credence down Aberforth
was the only one able to bring Arianna down from her rages I could get her to eat when she wouldn't
do it for my mother I could calm her down when she was in one of her rages and when she was quiet she
used to help me feed the goats seriously what even is the deal with the goats they never explained
that even Grindelwald involvement and interest in this latest movie makes more sense if Arianna
is an obscure you he is clearly looking for one in the movie he doesn't seem to know much about
them other than the fact that they are extremely powerful he could have initially learned about
them from Dumbledore himself after all he first meets him after Dumbledore returns home to take
care of Arianna because she had just accidentally killed their mother her condition as an obscure
Yeol seems like the kind of thing that might come up if you're trying to take over the world with
someone what brings you back to Godric's Hollow my sister is sick with a powerful dark magic that
my father fears could reveal the entire Wizarding World the muggles really I mean you want to like
hang out or something honestly guys I don't even know if we have to call this one a theory
everything lines up so perfectly and it makes so much sense but I guess we will only really get
true confirmation once the next couple of movies come out but for my question of the day what do
you guys think was Arianna and obscure you'll leave your thoughts in the towel section down
below also guys it is the holiday season and you guys have given us just so much to be thankful for
and we wanted to find a way to give back so every single day leading up to Christmas in the month
of December we will be doing a giveaway on our instagrams all you have to do to enter is follow
each account and leave a comment on the picture of the day and as an added bonus we will be donating
10 cents for every follower we get to our local chapter of Big Brothers Big Sisters up to 20,000
followers you have spent a lot of time picking out the items for each of the giveaways and they are
so cool so those will start on December 1st but we will start counting followers today so go follow
us just now guys as always thanks for watching this video be sure to like it and subscribe to
the channel if you haven't already if you'd like to see some more Harry Potter and fantastic east
action from us you can click right here to see the top seven unanswered questions from
fantastic beasts and where to find them or right here to find out whether or not Dumbledore created
a Horcrux but hey that is everything that I've got for you today man I will see you on Tuesday