- I believe that I am an eyeliner ho,
mostly because I love eyeliner.
- I feel like a makeup look isn't complete without eyeliner,
at least for me.
- I normally always wear bottom eyeliner.
It's a must.
It's the one makeup product that I can't
not have on my face.
- If I'm feeling a little bit edgier,
kind of wanting to do a more rockstar type of look,
I really like bottom liner.
- When I was younger, I used to wear eyeliner
on my bottom waterline a lot,
using expensive MAC eyeliner,
and it would always run down my face.
- I've stopped using eyeliner
like at the bottom of my eyes
just because it would always smudge,
look like I was crying,
but I'm hoping this eyeliner will make me fall in love
with wearing eyeliner at the bottom.
- I wear it for 20 minutes
and then my eyeliner just smudges.
I've tried MAC, I've tried Sephora, I've tried it all,
and I'm just trying to find the perfect eyeliner.
- The Sephora contour eye pencil.
I took off all of my liner,
so now we're gonna test this baby out.
- I'm trying the Marc Jacobs highliner gel eye crayon.
It's the fanciest eyeliner I've ever tried on.
I see you, Marc Jacobs.
- Aqua XL eye pencil, Make Up For Ever.
Wow, waterproof and extra long-lasting.
You know it's legit when it has extra in front of it.
- Perversion.
Whoa, that's an intense word for some eyeliner.
Let's relax.
- I even noticed my eye was watering a little bit,
and it didn't really smear.
- I think I have trust issues with expensive eyeliner.
- It goes on pretty smoothly.
- It's dark enough
that I don't have to go over it constantly.
- Let's see how it wears throughout the day.
- This feels like a very creamy soft eyeliner,
which doesn't really spell long-lasting generally,
but I'm just being a skeptic.
It looks really good.
- It's a couple hours in,
and it's looking like it's holding up pretty well.
- I'm not gonna lie, this eyeliner is slaying.
- I broke the rule and touched my eye.
- Doesn't look smudgy at all.
- Actually, it doesn't look that smudgy, nice.
- You're powerful.
- That's what my eyeliner
tells you about me. - You're a beautiful woman.
Yes.
- If more men can tell me this wearing this eyeliner,
I'm sold.
- What's different?
- It's longer.
- It's blue.
- You did the bottom ones.
- I can tell yours is smearing here,
and I can see where yours is smearing in the corner too.
- We're smeary ladies.
- It's probably 95 degrees out here.
- And my eyeliner is still on fleek.
- On point.
- I just came back from walking outside,
and it has smeared even more.
- Maybe it's my eyelids.
Maybe it's not the liner.
Maybe the liner is doing its job,
and I'm here, you know, with my oily eyelids.
- It's not sliding down my face,
but I think I feel like the line
has just gotten a little thinner.
- We're gonna test if my eyeliner is waterproof or not,
and I have Steven to help me out.
You got a spray bottle.
Okay, Steven's having a little too much fun with this.
As you can tell, there's water, and it's still on.
- It all feels like mess.
- Yeah, it's still off.
Sorry, Kelsey.
- I watched something that was super sad,
and now I'm crying, so let's see if it will hold up.
It looks like it's smearing a little bit more.
- So, it's the end of the day,
and honestly, it didn't last the work day
and I really didn't do much today.
So, it would definitely not last going out to dinner
or dancing or doing anything with friends on the weekend.
If I had to rate the Sephora brand out of five,
I would probably rate it like a one or a two, to be honest.
- I guess I could see why it was highly praised.
It did actually stay on, but it did smear.
And I didn't even really touch my eye at all.
I cried like a little bit,
but no tears actually streamed down my face.
I give this eyeliner a three out of five.
- It's like hardly on my waterline anymore like it was.
24 hours, my butt.
I'm sorry.
This is why I have trust issues.
Thumbs down for Megan.
- It looks like I just applied the eyeliner on.
It's still intact, the color's there.
Overall, a five out of five.
I think I found my perfect match and his name is Marc.
Thank you, Jacobs.