Welcome back friends to Top 10 Gaming, Im your host Johnny Rogers and with all the hype
surrounding Red Dead Redemption 2 we thought it would be apropo to bring you the Scariest
Red Dead Redemption Creepypastas.
Negative Reinforcement This creepy tale is about some unexpected
repercussions after a gamer takes the free will aspect a little too far.
Our protagonist was playing Red Dead and after the first mission he went on to kill every
bystander he could.
Even shooting the owner of the gun shop.
The game warned him that there was an honor meter and it would go down every time he killed
an innocent person.
He didnt care though, he slaughtered at least 30 more people before running out of bullets.
He was slightly disturbed though to find that someone had shot his horse when he returned
to the stable.
Almost seemed like an NPC had come back for revenge.
The gamer also began to notice that his character had a sad expression on his face and would
continue to sigh.
He just killed 30 people though so he didnt really care and as you could imagine this
massacre directed the police to his location.
While he was in a shootout with one of the cops he could hear a dying police officer
pleading for them to tell his family that he loved them.
After the shootout was finished and his character was alone he heard John say to himself - he
had a family and I just killed him.
As he looked at his honor meter he noticed he had reached the next level of evil which
was highwayman.
The following day while playing his character was in a prison cell.
He was being charged with 20 counts of murder and 33 counts of assault.
This was extremely confusing because he had never turned himself in so how could he possibly
be in a jail cell.
He lived alone so its not like anyone else was playing the game.
After he was released, his character continued to express his regret and guilt towards killing
the NPCs.
The gamer didnt care though and he would go on to commit an even bigger massacre in the
game.
One that wiped out every citizen in three different towns.
His honor meter would then progress to the next level of evil, except with each stage
John would feel guilt more and more.
This time he would turn his head away from dead bodies, refused to run and wouldnt pull
out his gun when the gamer prompted him.
Frustrated by this he restarts the game, except this time John is inside of a barn.
There were carcasses of dead animals and people all around him.
It was all of the people he had brutally killed.
Thats when he noticed a noose hanging from the center beam and as the gamer lost control,
John walked over and hung himself with the noose.
There was no wasted animation though, just John hanging there for the gamer to watch
in horror.
Thats when an option appeared that just said - try again - yes or no.
Put off by this he reluctantly hits yes, which was followed by a new text box that read - In
life, you dont get to try again.
Your choices are permanent and you must live with them, or attempt to escape them.
Furious by this, he returns the game and opened up the save files to delete them.
Thats when he noticed a file titled - Rockstar Games Negative Reinforcement Experiment.
He selects the file which opened it in his PS3 browser.
The first line was Subject PS3-244.
That was the randomly generated name that identifies the console on the internet.
It meant that he was the subject.
The next line was the date the game was last accessed along with his play time.
Beside the honor meter it said fully evil and next to result it read - fail.
Oh, Hi Marc This creepypasta is about a gamer named Marc
Grey.
He was given a copy of Red Dead Redemption Undead Nightmare by one of his close friends
who claimed that he couldnt bare to look at the game anymore.
Apparently it had been his brother Jims favorite game and when he died the game just brought
back a lot of bad memories.
When Marc put the game into his xbox 360 the screen flashed and what looked like a face
appeared on the screen.
Assuming that it was just a glitch because the game was old, he continued.
While fighting zombies in the graveyard he sees a tombstone that has the name Jim Connors
on it.
He was confused because that was the last name of the friend who gave him the game.
Thats when the screen flashed again this time showing more of a smirking face.
However this time the console shut itself off.
Annoyed by this he restarts the game and eventually returns to the graveyard.
Except this time he sees an open grave with HIS name on the tombstone.
Okay something is definitely wrong now.
Before he could do anything the screen flashes again this time the face on the screen is
laughing and the console shuts itself off yet again.
When he restarts the game to investigate this insanity he notices that every zombie in the
game is dead and when he goes into town the NPCs run from him.
However one brave citizen approached his character and pleaded with him by name.
Saying that he needs to run before Jim comes.
Now in complete shock he runs to his friends house to tell him about the game.
When he gets there his friend tries to console him and say that someone must have hacked
his xbox.
Thats when he sees a photo on the wall, its the face from the game.
He slowly points at the smiling photo hanging on the wall, his hand trembling - who is that
- he asks his friend.
The friend sighs and tells him that its his deceased brother Jim.
Without saying a word, Marc runs home.
He grabs the disc and destroys it, burying it in his backyard so that no one would have
to experience this nightmare.
That night he tossed and turned barely able to sleep because of a terrible thunderstorm.
He then hears a crack of thunder and then a flash of lightning meaning the storm was
closer than he thought.
He rushes to his window to see if it hit a tree in his backyard.
Thats when he sees a shadowy figure standing beside the hole where he had buried the game.
As the figure turns towards his line of sight he quickly ducks down, only to see that his
TV was on and so was Red Dead.
He sees what appears to be Jim in the game as an NPC.
Theres blood everywhere.
Beside Jim is a body hanging from a noose.
It was the citizen who warned him about Jim.
Thats when Jims character said - Oh hi Marc, if you dont stop playing my game.
Youll die too.
And that has been the Scariest Red Dead Redemption Creepypastas.
Thank you for watching, if you enjoyed this video hit that thumbs up button.
If youre new to the channel make sure to subscribe and click the playlist you see on the screen
for more videos like this one.
Also let us know in the comments below which one of these stories freaked out out the most.
From Top 10 Gaming, Im Johnny Rogers and until next time take care.