Denis Villeneuve has rightfully been celebrated for his directorial acumen, as evidenced by
his beautifully crafted rendition of Frank Herbert's "Dune" in the first installment
of his ambitious two-part cinematic endeavor.
His nuanced direction and keen attention to detail in "Dune Part 1" demonstrated his commitment
to portraying a world that is as engaging as it is intricate.
However, as much as I admire his work, I find myself rather skeptical of some recent comments
he made regarding the role of Lady Jessica, played by Rebecca Ferguson, in the upcoming
"Dune Part 2".
In this video I’d like to cover Villeneuve’s comments and how I respectfully disagree with
his thoughts about Lady Jessica in the second half of Frank Herbert’s Dune.
In an interview with Town and Country, Villeneuve explained his approach to adapting Lady Jessica,
stating that, "Rebecca's a passionate, warm human being who loves to quickly break the
ice.
She has a huge imagination…
she can fly high."
He went on to say, "Lady Jessica kind of disappears in the second part of the book, and I made
sure as I was writing the screenplay to do the opposite, to make sure that she will be
active, to bring her back to the front of the story."
Such comments about "expanding Jessica’s role" echo similar sentiments expressed during
the lead-up to "Dune Part 1."
Reports hailed the evolution of Lady Jessica's character, seemingly given greater prominence
and significance in Villeneuve's adaptation than in the original novel.
The actress herself praised her character's expanded role, attributing this in part to
Villeneuve's respectful yet innovative adaptation of Herbert's work.
She said, quote "Denis was very respectful of Frank’s work in the book, [but] the quality
of the arcs for much of the women have been brought up to a new level."
I found myself slightly perturbed at the time those comments were made, believing them to
be ill-informed at best, as the novel's first half already showcases Lady Jessica as a formidable
figure who many feel is just as much of a main character as Paul Atreides is.
Walking into the film, my expectations from these comments were anchored in the hope of
witnessing a portrayal of Lady Jessica that was attempting to capture her remarkable power
and resilience as demonstrated in the novel.
However, to my astonishment, the version of Lady Jessica that ultimately graced the screen
in "Dune Part 1" was a stark divergence from these expectations, contributing to my feelings
of disappointment.
Instead of seeing the reported amplification of Jessica's character, what we got was a
portrayal that felt underwhelming and starkly diminished.
This was particularly disconcerting, considering the depth and complexity of Jessica’s character
that was offered by Herbert's original work.
Looking back on the film and considering what we now have seen from Dune part one the remarks
made during the marketing for the first film seem to have been nothing more than media
fodder filled with the right buzzwords that mainstream entertainment outlets love to feature
in headlines.
While there is so much that I enjoy from Villeneuve’s part one adaptation when it comes to the character
of Lady Jessica it is not my favorite portrayal mostly due to how many of her scenes and actions
showcasing her deep love for Duke Leto, and her varied abilities of perception and insight
as a Bene Gesserit were cut from the first film.
Herbert's "Dune" masterfully illustrates Lady Jessica's discernment, making her privy to
the existence of a traitor among them, though their identity remains unknown to the members
of House Atreides.
The film adaptation's disregard for this storyline consequently reduced her role, depriving us
of her astute observational skills and deductive powers.
Critical conversations with characters such as Dr. Yueh and Thufir Hawat are absent, diluting
not only Jessica's character but also the depth and complexity of the plot.
Furthermore, the inclusion of the book's banquet scene could have done much to showcase Jessica's
political savvy and perceptiveness.
While Jessica was not the only character to suffer such a diminishment, I think that the
exclusion of these scenes and subplots from the book were a massive missed opportunity
if their intention truly was to showcase the power of her character.
When it comes to Villevenueves comments about Jessica in Part 2, I find myself at odds with
the director's assertion that she "disappears" in the second half of the book.
Even in the book, she remains a vital force throughout the narrative.
She is the central focus of the entire water of life ceremony and its preceding events.
As the Fremen tribe’s new Spiritual Leader as Reverend Mother she continues to be a character
of great significance to the unfolding narrative as her son Paul grows to fulfill his prophesied
role as their messiah.
She has a very impactful and intense scene upon Gurney Halleck’s return.
There are also a couple of interchanges in the book that Jessica has with Chani, who
Villeneuve has separately touted as a primary character for Dune part 2.
Add to this her scenes with her daughter Alia, who plays a pivotal role toward the end of
the novel.
Far from disappearing, Jessica is present during many significant events in the second
half of the novel with consistent lines of dialogue occurring through the climax of the
book.
Jessica’s words to Chani even serve as the closing lines of the novel.
While I will concede that she is not as heavily featured in the second half of the novel as
opposed to the first, that is simply due to the fact that the large ensemble cast of characters
have more time afforded to their development, like chani, stilgar, Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen,
Count and Lady Fenring.
Time spent fleshing out these other characters and their journeys however in no way diminishes
the significant role of Lady Jessica.
Considering all of this, it is with respectful disagreement that I receive Villeneuve's statements
about Lady Jessica's supposed "disappearance."
That being said, even though these comments stir up a measure of skepticism…
Just as I had anticipated with part one, I hold out hope that Villeneuve will attempt
to stay true to Lady Jessica's character.
For now I will regard the director’s words simply as marketing jargon reflecting his
excitement for the role her character will have in Dune part 2.
There are many opportunities granted by the source material for him to acknowledge and
portray her significant, albeit more nuanced, influence in the progression of the later
parts of the story.
Her presence in the book is indelible and profound, and the portrayal of her character
in the film adaptation should be no different.
Only time will tell how this all will play out in "Dune Part 2".
But I’m curious to know what you think of Denis Villeneuve’s comments for Dune part
2.
Do you agree that Lady Jessica disappears in the second half of the book?
Do you feel that she needs to be featured more prominently or given more scenes than
what she already has in the source material?
Let me know your thoughts in the comment section below.
I hope you enjoyed this video.
Leave a like if you did and be sure to subscribe for more Dune and other sci-fi and fantasy
news and lore.
Thank you all so much for your support and as always have a very nerdy day.