“Salmonella in Chicken & Turkey: Deadly but Not Illegal
When researchers last year at the Emerging Pathogens Institute
ranked foodborne pathogens to figure out which was the worst,
#1 on their list was Salmonella—
ranked the food-poisoning bacteria with the greatest public health burden
on our country, the leading cause of food-poisoning-related hospitalization,
and the #1 cause of food- poisoning-related death.
Where do you get it from?
Well, I’ve talked about the threat of eggs.
According to the FDA, 142,000 Americans
are sickened every year by eggs contaminated with Salmonella.
That’s an egg-borne epidemic every year.
But, Salmonella in eggs was only ranked the #10 worst pathogen food combination.
Salmonella in poultry ranks even worse—
the #4 worst-infected food in the United States,
in terms of both cost, and quality-adjusted years of life lost.
In terms of the burden of human Salmonella poisoning
attributable to various U.S. foods,
eating chicken may be eight times riskier than eating eggs.
Due to strengthening of food safety regulations
under the Clinton administration,
the number of Americans food-poisoned by chicken every year dropped from about
390,000 a year to 200,000, and rightly hailed as a significant accomplishment.
So, now, eating chicken only sicken about 200,000 people in the U.S.
every year.
But, isn’t that a bit like some toy company boasting that they’ve
reduced the amount of lead in their toys, and so, are now poisoning 40% fewer kids.
Not exactly something to boast about.
And the numbers have since rebounded back upwards.
In the late 90s, human Salmonella cases have increased by 44% since then.
The rebound in incidence of Salmonella infection in the United States is likely
a result of several factors.
But, one important risk factor singled out is eating chicken,
as the proportion of chicken carrying Salmonella infection has increased.
When people think manure in meat, they typically think ground beef.
But, when you look at E. coli levels in meat, which “is considered
an indicator of fecal contamination,”
sure, there’s fecal matter in about two-thirds of American beef.
But, that number is greater than 80% fecal contamination in poultry—
chicken and turkey.
Why have we seen a decrease in the Jack in the Box E. coli o157,
but not chicken-borne Salmonella?
In the last decade or so, the infection of beef, and subsequently children,
have dropped, like 30%.
But not only has Salmonella not declined in the past fifteen years,
it’s actually increased lately.
One reason is that there was a prohibition of contamination
with the deadly E. coli in beef.
What a concept!
So, selling contaminated beef is illegal.
Why is beef laced with E. coli- contaminated fecal matter
considered adulterated,
but chicken laced with salmonella- contaminated fecal matter A-OK?
It certainly kills more people than the banned E.coli.
It all goes back to a famous case in 1974,
when the American Public Health Association sued the USDA, saying,
wait a second—
you can’t put a stamp of approval for wholesomeness on meat contaminated
with Salmonella.
What could the USDA possibly say in meat’s defense?
As relayed by the Circuit judge,
the USDA pointed out that there have been Salmonella outbreaks linked
to dairy and eggs, for example, too.
So, since “there are numerous sources of contamination which might contribute
to the overall problem,” it would be “unjustified to single out the
meat industry and ask that the Department require it to identify
its raw products as being hazardous to health.”
That’s like the tuna industry arguing ah,
there’s no need to label cans of tuna with mercury levels,
because you could also get exposed eating thermometers.
The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the meat industry position,
arguing that you can allow potentially deadly salmonella in meat because,
and I quote, “American housewives are… normally not ignorant or stupid and their
methods of preparing and cooking of food do not ordinarily result
in [Salmonella food poisoning].”
What?
That’s like saying, oh, minivans don’t need seat belts in the back seat,
because, you know, soccer moms don’t ordinarily crash into things.
Now, 39 years later, 200,000 Americans, sickened every year by Salmonella
that continues to be legally allowed in chicken.