In 2005, Missy Lagrange, a 16 year old high school
student in Johnstown, Pennsylvania went missing.
Her body was never found.
Two men were accused of kidnapping and brutally murdering her,
Nicholas Tooley and his nephew, Nephew Tooley.
They were tried and found guilty of the murder
Since 2009, they have been serving life sentences in the Caleb Anderson State Penitentiary.
But did they do it? Were they the ones who killed Missy?
♫ Ooh this is a spooky song ♫
♫ about a murder in the south ♫
♫ Cigarettes and bourbon in my whiskey ♫
♫ We couldn't get the rights to a T-Bone Burnett song ♫
♫ This is the best we could do ♫
♫ Dusty blood and dusk in the moon time haunted me ♫
♫ That sounds like something T-Bone Burnett would write ♫
♫ Right? ♫
Well,
when we arrested the two men they were covered and what appeared to be blood.
It ain't blood!
Yeah, it's jam!
We was making jam and the jam jars 'sploded.
Yeah the jam- it was like a jam-splosion all in our double wide.
It was blood.
We got the tip that they were responsible from their neighbor, but
the witness kept flipping and flopping and flipping and flopping and flipping
and flopping flipping flopping flipping flopping flipping
flipping flopping flipping flopping
and flopping and flopping and flipping and flopping and flipping and flopping and
flipping and flopping...
like a hot trout on a cold whore.
I saw him chopping up that girl I swear on my life and in God above in heaven
I did. If you come away with one thing I want you to know I saw them doing it.
I never saw nothing. I don't- I don't know why they say I said that.
I swear to God I- I never saw nothing.
I didn't say I saw nothing, swear on God.
I saw nothing.
I don't know why the cops...
Hey do you want me to suck your-
I defended Nic and Nephew in court, and honestly the prosecution made a very
strong case against my clients.
I mean they brought in some science experts who presented some very strong evidence against my clients.
We will now demonstrate beyond a reasonable doubt that Nicholas Tooley
and Nephley- Nephew Tooley
murdered this young woman beyond a reasonable doubt
represented here by this gourd.
Similar to that.
How do you fight that?
I'm genuinely asking I'd appreciate any input.
You know especially when you got an online law degree.
I only had to pay for shipping and handling.
Still can't believe those rats did that to Missy.
I just want to find her body. She was my little girl.
Sure she smoked meth and got arrested for beating up a male prostitute,
and participated in the occasional dog versus roach fight,
but she was my little angel.
We didn't do it! How could we do it?
Nephew ain't even know how to wipe!
I do now.
Yeah 'cause I showed yah!
Cut it!
That's where he has to sit when he does dumb stuff.
Did Nicholas and Nephew Tooley kill Miss Lagrange?
Will we ever know for sure?
Should we just toss a coin and call it a day?
He's my nephew so I named him Nephew.
Probably.