want to show me on the video?
>> Yes, ma'am.
>> Judge Judy: I'd like to see
it.
>> Byrd: Me, too.
>> And in the video after the
crash, ma'am, you can clearly
hear the defendant calling his
dog Sharday back to his yard.
And the woman in the car asked
me if I'm okay.
Come on, let's go!
Come on! Good girl!
>> That's the 40-pound dog,
Callie --
>> Judge Judy: Shh!
>> Car!
>> Sharday! Get back here!
>> Ma'am! Are you okay?
>> Yeah.
>> You sure?
>> Yep.
I just wish people would keep
their dogs in their yards.
>> I know. Oh, my goodness!
>> Thanks for asking, though.
>> You're welcome.
>> Judge Judy: Can I play that
again, please, Byrd?
I'm stilling listening for the
Shih-Poo's barking.
I hear your dog panting, but I
don't hear a Shih-Poo barking.
I don't hear a little dog
barking.
>> I'll point it out to you,
ma'am.
>> Judge Judy: Just a second.
>> Come on, Callie!
Come on, come on, come on!
Come on, let's go!
Come on! Good girl!
Good job!
Car!
>> Sharday! Get back here!
>> You hear him say "Sharday"
very -- if you turn it up,
you'll be able to hear it
better.
>> Judge Judy: Just a second.
I can't hear it.
Byrd, do you hear a barking dog?
I hear a panting dog.
Could you play it one more time
for me?
>> Come on, Callie!
Come on, come on, come on!
Come on, let's go!
Come on! Good girl!
Good job!
Car!
>> Judge Judy: I hear in here,
Ms. Huettel, the dogs breathing.
If I hear the dogs breathing, I
should be able to hear a yapping
small dog, as you described
that didn't stop yapping.
I don't hear the dog.
>> So, his dog, as it was
running out into the street, you
hear the two barks.
>> Judge Judy: I don't hear any
bark.
All I heard was -- I heard you
continuing to go, you and your
dog take off.
Listen, you have no case.
Okay, let's go to the
counterclaim.
>> Well, ma'am, my counterclaim
is for just the amount of times
that the plaintiff had been
coming down to my house.
My fiancée was at our house with
our children, and she wasn't
gonna answer the door or
anything like that because it
was about 8:00 at night, maybe
7:30-ish, and...
>> Judge Judy: And? And? And?
I'm not hearing a crime.
I'm not hearing anything.
>> Well, no, and when she called
me and told me that it was
strangers outside of our house,
I left work to come home and see
what was going on.
>> Judge Judy: All right, she
thought you were responsible.
I mean, aside from this one time
that she came to your house, did
she come continually over a
course of time?
>> Yes, ma'am.
>> Judge Judy: How many times
did she come?
>> I would say maybe about four
or five in total.
>> Judge Judy: Okay, did you
ever speak to her?
So the first time she came to
your fiancée, you spoke to her?
>> Yes, ma'am.
>> Judge Judy: When did you
speak to her?
>> It was Saturday, July 8th.
>> Judge Judy: Okay, and tell me
the circumstances surrounding
you speaking to her.
>> She showed up at my house.
It was about 7:00 in the
morning.
After she was ringing my
doorbell, my kids come to wake
me up, you know, I go to the
door.
She's standing there with some
papers in her hand saying that
it's an estimate of this
scooter.
So I told her that "I'm not
responsible for your scooter."
So she was saying that, yes, I
am.
She tried to show me the video
that she just had right there,
but...
>> I did show it to you.
>> And I told her that I think
she should leave my property.
So she got in her car and she
left, but then she goes and
calls the police, and they wound
up coming back to my house and
saying that I harassed her.
So I was saying, "Well, how did
I harass her if she was on my
property?"
>> Judge Judy: Why did you go to
the police?
>> Ma'am...
>> Judge Judy: No, no.
My question is -- Why did you go
to the police?
>> When I went to the
defendant's house, I rang the
doorbell.
The first thing I asked him --
>> Judge Judy: What time of day
was it?
>> It was approximately 8:00,
8:30 in the morning.
>> Judge Judy: That's too early
to go to somebody's house.
Next.
>> Exactly.
>> Then the defendant answers
the door, and I asked him if his
mother was home because he
looked very young to me.
He started telling me that --
"Why are you asking for my
mother?
My mother doesn't live here," so
on and so forth.
>> Judge Judy: Okay, so you
mistook the fact that he lives
there with his children.
>> Absolutely.
>> Judge Judy: Okay. So...?
>> He comes out of the house.
I wanted to talk to him about
the scooter.
He said, "My dog didn't get
anywhere near you, it didn't
bite you, it didn't touch your
scooter, it didn't hurt your
dogs.
You got on your scooter and rode
off.
You just need get the [bleep]
off of my property."