- Oh, my God. You look so hot.
I'm watching you in your new series Poker Face.
(audience applauds) And...
You guys, it is...
The best show.
It's like Matlock.
It's seventies.
It's like Agatha Christie.
It's like really hot.
You're like, you've got this wild sex appeal in it.
And you're like an old movie star,
where you cannot stop staring at you.
It's so beautifully shot, so beautifully acted.
An insane cast of like, just take a look.
- (censored) Christ, man. You two.
All that loss and you keep moving forward.
Just living your lives.
Forgive and forget, right?
- Oh, sweetie. No.
We never forgive.
(audience applauds)
- Okay. So, Maya Rudolph is the co-EP.
- Yeah.
- [Drew] You are the executive producer.
How did you guys meet and like, did you have chemistry?
Did you guys think alike?
How did that all come about?
- [Natasha] Yeah. So, Maya and I,
we met, it's gotta be like 20 years ago and we're in like a,
a fashion situation in Midtown,
and then we just walked 50 blocks together downtown
and sort, of cemented this,
what would become a permanent forever friendship.
And then she'd be on SNL and I'd be there kind of
most weekends, just in her room and then Sunday brunch,
you know, I mean, it'll be only like four hours later.
But we'd do it.
I always look back now and I,
I realize we bought the same really large sofa
at ABC Furniture,
which makes me realize like, just how tight we were,
'cause it's such a weird thing to do.
But I think we just liked doing things together
and kind of... You know what I mean, right?
- [Drew] I do. And now, switching gears a little bit.
You were with my baby.
Aubrey Plaza is my baby now, and I'm her mommy.
(audience applauds)
- Wait. But, but, but,
I'm the daddy.
- [Drew] Are you the daddy?
- I'm the daddy you guys were seeking.
- Did we make a baby?
(audience applauds)
- And that's it.
That's how babies are born.
- That's exactly, - That's,
- [Both] how babies are born.
- [Drew] Isn't our daughter doing so well?
- She thriving.
I'm so proud of her.
- [Drew] She did such a good job.
- She did such a good job.
- [Drew] She's on top of the world too.
- [Natasha] Yeah. She's a little cutie.
- [Drew] Wait!
Is it true that when you were asked to do American Pie.
Kicking it back to when we were teenagers.
Is it true that they asked you like,
multiple times to do it?
- Yeah.
- [Drew] And what were you, why?
Why did you say no at first?
And what, and eventually, made you say yes?
- [Natasha] Well, I think that
I just sort of saw it on paper
and I didn't identify with this sort of like very,
very white, very normal high school experience of...
- [Drew] Clean cut, all America.
- Kind of like, "Oh, we're gonna lose our virginity."
I was like, "Honey, it already happened." Like...
- [Drew] Yeah.
(Drew laughs)
- [Natasha] So...
- I know. It's like the whole movie.
- [Natasha] I know. I was like...
- Is a leading up.
- Guys just do it. You know?
Yeah. You know?
You'll figure it out later in life.
And...
Anyway. So yeah, I just don't think I understood the movie.
But, then they gave me money and then I began to understand.
- [Drew] Yeah.
(Drew and Natasha laugh)
(audience applauds)
- Yeah.
- [Drew] Yes!
I had such a crush on Eddie Kaye Thomas.
- Eddie Kaye Thomas was super cool.
- [Drew] Right? He was like...
- [Natasha] He's still super cool.
- [Drew] He was the...
I always went for the avant-garde one.
- [Natasha] Yeah.
- [Drew] I never went for the popular All-American.
I was like, Tom Green, Eddie Kaye Thomas, like...
- [Natasha] Yeah. The nineties were a whole thing.
- [Drew] They really, really were.
Well, Jennifer Coolidge,
who ends up getting it on with Eddie Kaye Thomas
in the movie, Stifler's Mom, is...
Talk about having a moment!
Can you believe?
She's just thriving.
(audience applauds)
And, she said in her Golden Globe speech,
that she would be game for another American Pie movie.
Would you be? Like...
- Listen, now I'm at an age where
anywhere Jennifer Coolidge goes, I go.
- [Drew] Right?
I mean it's come like, full circle.
(audience applauds)
It's like...
I think now...
I think now American Pie could be made
into a really cool indie.
- Right, right.
- With like really cool actors
because it's all come full circle.
- Uh huh. Yeah.
- And we could do this. You know?
American Pie...
- [Natasha] Other things.
- Yeah.
- [Natasha] Other projects.
- The real slice.
- Yeah.
(audience applauds)
Slice o' life.
- Slice o' life.
- I wanna see,
if there was ever to be an American Pie reboot.
I feel like everybody's in this extraordinary place too,
that like, how would that not be the coolest movie?
- Sure, why not? You know?
Get it, get it while you can.
As Janice Joplin says, "Get it while you can."
- [Drew] Yes. Yes indeed.
(audience applauds)
- All right. Well, we have to go to a quick commercial break
but we're gonna be right back with Natasha Lyonne.
(audience applauds) (theme music plays out)