WAS ONE OF THE MOST PEOPLE AT
FACEBOOK INCLUDING MYSELF
DISAGREED WITH STRONGLY WE
NEVER BRIEFED THE ENDS HE JUST
THE MEANS JOINING US NOW
DEPUTY TECH MICHAEL NUNES GO A
THE TO SEE YOU ONLY PROBLEM
WITH THIS MEMO EVEN IF MEANT
TO BE BEING PROVOCATIVE AND
RAISE A TOUGH QUESTIONS HE
INTERNALLY, IS THAT GIVEN MORE
AND MORE WHAT WE FOIP OUT
ABOUT FACEBOOK -- FOUND OUT
ABOUT FACEBOOK DOES NOT POLICE
BAD BEHAVIOR AT APP DEVELOPERS
ANYONE THAT FACEBOOK IS MAKING
MONEY OFF IT RINGS TRUE THAT
IS THAT IS FACEBOOK'S BIGGEST
PROBLEM THAT THEY HAVE LET
PEOPLE LITERALLY GET AWAY WITH
MURDER ON PLATFORM.
>> I THINK FOR PEOPLE
FOLLOWING THIS A FEW YEARS, IT
DIDN'T COME AS MUCH OF A
SURPRISE SOMETHING THAT PEOPLE
HAD SUSPECTED FOR A LONG TIME,
CRITICS VOICED THIS CONCERN,
OVER THE COURSE OF MANY YEARS,
ESPECIALLY SOMEONE MY AGE KIND
OF GREW UP WITH FACEBOOK
RIGHT, I STARTED WITH IT IN
COLLEGE, AND SINCE GROWN INTO
A MUCH BIGGER ENTITY THAN IT
ONCE WAS, AND AS ITS GROWN WE
HAVE SEEN SERVICE CHANGE
SUBSTANTIALLY, SO PEOPLE HAVE
QUESTIONED WHETHER GROWTH
WHETHER THE END JUSTIFIED THE
MEANS RIGHT?
BUT WE DIDN'T HAVE QUITE A --
AN EXPLICIT THING TO LOOK AT
DISCUSSED INTERNALLY NOW WE
KNOW FACEBOOK EMPLOYEES
ACTUALLY ARE DEALING WITH SAME
SORT OF -- THE SAME SORT OF
CONCERN WE TO SAY THE LEAST
HAVE SOME EVIDENCE THAT AT
LEAST ONE EXECUTIVE MAY HAVE
THOUGHT THAT THE ENDS JUSTIFY
MEANS.
>> I HAVE TALKED ABOUT THIS
FROM THE OUTSIDE LOOKING IN,
THE -- RECKLESS DISREGARD THAT
FACEBOOK HAS FOR ITS OWN
USERS, THEIR PRIVACY, HOW THE
SERVICES ARE USED AND I ALWAYS
GO BACK TO FACEBOOK LIVE,
BECAUSE THEIR GUT HAS ALWAYS
BEEN ROLL OUT THE SERVICE JUST
-- RECEIPT THE APP DEVELOPERS
HAVE ALL THIS INFORMATION WE
WILL WORRY ABOUT THE
CONSEQUENCES LATER.
AND THEY WERE NEVER
FORTHCOMING ENOUGH WITH ACTUAL
USERS, TWO BILLION PLUS, ABOUT
HOW HAD ACCESS TO YOUR DATA
WHAT KIND OF DATA IT WAS VERY
HARD IF YOU GO INTO CHANGE
YOUR SETTINGS IT IS NOT CLEAR
WHAT IS HANDED AWAY, WHAT IS
GIVEN AWAY, AND NOW, ABOUT NOW
YOU HEAR THIS MEA CULPA BUT I
THINK FOR SOME PEOPLE IT IS
TOO LATE, THAT INCLUDES
ADVERTISERS.
>> ABSOLUTELY, I THINK, WITH
FACEBOOK, YOU KNOW, THERE IS A
COUPLE THINGS THAT PLAY HERE
ONE IS THAT MARK ZUCKERBERG
MANTRA HAS LONG BEEN MOVE FAST
BREAK THINGS THEY BROKE A LOT
OF THINGS PAST COUPLE YEARS K
I THINK SAFE TO SAY, AT LEAST
SINCE 2016 ELECTION, SO -- SO
IN THIS CASE WE'RE SORT OF
LEFT TO SORT OF PICK 77
PIECES, MARK ZUCKERBERG A LOT
OF EXECUTIVES LONG EMPHASIZED
MONTHLY ACTIVE USERS GROWTH OF
PLATFORM SORT OF WHAT THEY
HAVE TALKED ABOUT ON EARNINGS
CALLS FOR THE PAST AT LEAST
FIVE YEARS, NOW, THAT
CONVERSATION IS CHANGING TO
TIME WELL SPENT TO HOW THEY
ARE PROTECTING YIERS
ARE PROTECTING YIER
ARE PROTECTING USER
ARE PROTECTING USER D
ARE PROTECTING USER DAT
ARE PROTECTING USER DATA
PRIVACY.
>> CONSTANTLY AS TOOK USER I
HAVE BEEN VERY CAREFUL IN HOW
I USE THE SERVICE OVER YEARS I
ONLY SIGNED UP FOR IT SO I
COULD BASICALLY SEE WHAT MY
MOM WAS UP TO PEOPLE WITH WHOM
I GREW UP HAS ALWAYS BEEN
SLEAZE
SLEAZ
BEEAZ
BEENZ
BEEN
SLEAZY ASKING FOR DATA LOG IN
WITH FACEBOOK ACCOUNT, THEY
WERE TRYING TO TRACK GATHER
EVEN MORE INFORMATION, ABOUT
YOU, AND TRACK YOUR EVERY MOVE
SO I ALWAYS WAS VERY SUSPECT
OF WHAT THEY WERE UP TO, BUT
IT WAS THAT INVESTOR IN 2007
WHERE THEY OPENED SOCIAL TO
ANY AND ALL APP DEVELOPERS NOT
ONLY PEOPLE USING APPS BUT ALL
FRIENDS IT WAS THAT IN 2007
THAT GOT THEM FOR 57 MILLION
USERS TO TWO BILLION PLUS.
THEY LIMITED THAT YOU STILL
SEE EFFECTS OF WHAT HAPPENED
WITH THIS REVVINGS ABOUT
WITH THIS REVVINGS ABOU
WITH THIS REVVINGS CAOU
WITH THIS REVVINGS CAMB
WITH THIS REVVINGS CAMBRI
WITH THIS REVVINGS CAMBRIGE
ANALYTICA.
>> I AM 30 NOW GRADUATED 2009
PEOPLE THAT GREW UP WITH
FACEBOOK USING IN COLLEGE
BEFORE OPEN TO PEOPLE OUTSIDE
OF COLLEGE, WOULD MOSTLY AGREE
WITH WHAT YOU ARE SAYING, YOU
KNOW THE TENTACLES OF FACEBOOK
HAVE SLOWLY SPREAD HE GROWN HE
LONGER AND LONGER THE DATA
MING HAS BECOME MORE PERVASIVE
RIGHT NOW, THERE IS A LOT OF
DISCUSSION AROUND FACEBOOK,
BUT THERE IS NOT A LOT OF
DISCUSSION AROUND SOME OTHER
PROPERTIES, AS WELL SO
INSTAGRAM WHATSAPP.
I THINK FACEBOOK IS HOPING --
>> THAT WELL THAT PEOPLE DON'T
REALIZE THAT THEY -- THAT
INSTAGRAM IS OWNED BY
FACEBOOK, OR WHATSAPP THEY
HOPE IT IS LIKE THEY KNOW
QUIETLY PEOPLE POLITE NOT MAKE
THAT CONNECTION CROSSING
FINGERS.
>> IS THIS REALLY SILOED OR
HAPPENING ON FACEBOOK I
BELIEVE NOT RIGHT.
>> ABSOLUTELY NOT EASIEST WAY
TO TELL WOULD BE TO PRETEND TO
GO THROUGH THE PROCESS BUYING
TON INSTAGRAM OR FACEBOOK YOU
WILL NOTICE COMBINING DATA
FROM ALL PLATFORMS LETTING YOU
TARGET INDIVIDUALS, USING --
ON INSTAGRAM USING FACEBOOK
DATA.
>> I THINK WHAT WE'RE
TIP-TOEING ON THIS IT IS NOT
THE WEAPONIZATION IT IS
EXPLOITATION OF USERS DATA
PEOPLE DIDN'T UNDERSTAND
FACEBOOK BOUGHT YOUR FINANCIAL
DATA WENT TO CREDIT REPORTING
AGENCIES SO THEY KNOW YOUR IP
AADDRESS WHO YOU ARE HAVE YOUR
FINANCIAL DATA BUNDLED
TOGETHER TRACK YOU ON EVERY
WEB SITE IN OTHER YOUR FRIENDS
DOESN'T MATTER WHAT DATA YOU
GIVE THEM THEY KNOW THE DATA.
SO YOU CAN LIE TO THEM TELL
THEM A DIFFERENT AGE YOU CAN
TELL THEM YOU WENT TO
DIFFERENT SCHOOL.
>> I DID THAT MY AGE ON THERE
IS WRONG.
>> BUT A GREAT POINT
CROSS-REFERENCEING DIFFERENT
INFORMATION FOR EXAMPLE, IS
PROBABLY SAVED IN A LOT OF IN
HE MISSOURI'S PHONE A VARIETY
OF PEOPLE'S PHONES.
>> I WON'T GIVE MY PHONE
NUMBER THEY --
>> THEY HAVE -- THEY HAVE IT
REGARDLESS.
>> EVEN IF YOU DON'T THE AN
FACEBOOK ACCOUNT THEY HAVE
SHADOW PROFILE OF THEY CAN SAY
WITH HIGH DEGREE OF CERTAINTY
CERTAIN INDIVIDUAL IS LINKS
ATTITUDE PHONE NUMBER,
ADDRESS.
>> TO QUOTE THE GREAT --
>> THEY CAN KISS MY --
>> EXPOSE
>> EXPOSÉ ON HOW ADVERTISERS
ARE ALLOWED TO DISCRIMINATE
AGAINST AFRICAN-AMERICANS,
HIGH SCHOOL SKIDS EXPATS FROM
ARGENTINA, PUBLISH THE ADS GOT
THEM APPROVED THROUGH
FACEBOOK, IN FACEBOOK SAID FIX
IT DID IT AGAIN, THAT IS THE
BIGGEST PROBLEM WE HAVE TOO
HERE.
>> FOR FACEBOOK THERE IS A
HUGE MESSAGING PROBLEM
HAPPENING, I THINK YOU KNOW
LOT OF FIRE THAT ONCE --
>> SELLER SANDBERG WAS HUMPING
THAT BOOK LEAN, WHATEVER FOR
YOU COULDN'T GET AWAY FROM
HER!
>> KISS MY GRITS.
>> COULDN'T GET AWAY WHERE
WHATS HE WAS SHE MANAGING THIS
COMPANY WHERE NOW TRYING TO
REASSURE THE FACEBOOK
POPULATION.
>> A LOT OF PEOPLE ASKED THAT
QUESTION WHERE ARE ANY OF THE
EXECUTIVES RIGHT?
I THINK PREPOSTEROUS TO SAY
THIS ANDREW BOSS WORTH MEMO I