Hydropower is a great source of energy that doesn’t suffer the same intermittency problems
as other renewables. But dams fail. A lot. About 95% of the existing hydropower systems in the
States were built before 1995, and over half operate using equipment designed over 80 years
ago. This aging infrastructure can be not only unreliable, but dangerous to local populations,
human and animal alike. That said, hydropower doesn’t always have to be postcard-perfect
or 67 stories high. It actually has a lot of room for growth…possibly by shrinking.
That’s because small hydropower (or SHP) has the potential to literally usher in a new generation.
Several companies are working toward integrating hydroelectric turbines on a smaller scale and with
a smaller ecological footprint. Between new designs like Vortex Hydrokinetics’
bladeless turbine and Turbulent’s snail-shaped “fish-friendly” system (say that 10 times fast),
there’s plenty of opportunity to take advantage of rivers without
having to worry about the safety of ourselves or our scaly friends.
So, how else can small hydro impact our lives? And why should we give a dam(n)?
I’m Matt Ferrell … welcome to Undecided.
This video is brought to you by Eight Sleep, but more on that later.
Several of you have shared with me some exciting developments in hydro power that
looks to combine hydroelectric efficiency and safety on a micro scale. These include the
likes of SHP bladeless turbines by Vortex Hydro (yes, bladeless) and the company,
Turbulent. This video was also inspired by my friend Ryan’s coverage on Vortex’s bladeless
design a few months back. He goes into detail when explaining the engineering side of things,
so if you’re interested in the nuts and bolts, be sure to check out his video.
We’ll be diving deep into how these turbines work…further downriver. But before we do that,
let’s talk about why there’s so much interest in small hydro and decentralization, and what’s at
stake here. With SHP, nearby communities can reap the benefits of electricity produced by
constantly-flowing water without the typical dam mainstays of high velocity, high volume of flow,
and high…heights…otherwise known as the hydraulic “head.”
The hydraulic head is an important part of our energy calculation. If you don’t know what that
is, don’t worry, I didn’t either. “Hydraulic” is … well … related to water. “Head” is the potential
energy per unit of weight, so a higher tower has a higher head. Potential energy is calculated using
this quantity, and the larger the drop, the more potential energy available, as any daredevil who
rides over the edge of a waterfall will tell you, if they can still talk after doing it.
Let’s zoom out here for an example of just how powerful these elements can be. You can’t get
a much better study of hydro anatomy than the Itaipú Dam <--e-tay-poo-->, one of the
world’s largest. Situated on the Paraná River that straddles the border between Brazil and Paraguay,
this massive monolith stretches on for nearly 8 kilometers (or about 5 miles). It stands at
a whopping 196 meters (643 feet) high. For reference, if we spin our globe a bit to the
right toward the coast of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, we can wave to the famous statue known as Christ
the Redeemer. The Itaipú Dam is about as tall as six and a half Christs stacked together.
So, to say the dam has a huge head is a bit of an understatement. And its flow
rate of 62,200 cubic meters per second is equivalent to about 985,890,099 gallons a
minute. That’s 40 times the average rate of the nearby Iguazú Falls and about oh,
you know, half a million times more than the standard flow of a faucet in the U.S.
The impressive size of these dams represents a huge capital investment, and they only work in
certain areas. Thankfully, you don’t have to go big or go home, dammit. With clever engineering,
SHP companies like Vortex Hydro and Turbulent have created turbines that can make use of shorter,
slower streams of water, which means expanded access to renewable energy
generation in a much broader spectrum of sites. In other words, there’s no need to go chasin’
waterfalls…and more remote areas can stick to the rivers and the lakes that they’re used to.
Let’s start with the Vortex Hydro approach. Vortex turbines are a form of hydroelectric generation
that has been around for some time. They weren’t even invented in this century. But even though
the technology has been around for ages, it stands to be improved with modern advancements.
Vortex Hydro is a U.S.-based company that does just that. They offer the SETUR <--see-tur-->,
a modern, bladeless turbine model that is also a form of…vortex hydro. A team
of researchers at the Czech Technical University, including Miroslav Sedláček
originally developed and patented this novel design over the course of 12 years.
How exactly do you turn a hydroelectric turbine without blades?
Well, before I get into that, there’s another water based piece of technology that I’ve been
testing and using for the past year that’s really changed how I sleep … and that’s today’s sponsor,
Eight Sleep. I'm pretty sure I'm not alone when I say that I struggle to get a good night's
sleep every night. I either get overheated in the middle of the night and throw off covers,
or get too cold and need to pull on an extra cover. When I don't get consistent sleep,
I tend to get migraine headaches, which isn't fun. I've been using Eight Sleep's Pod Cover
for a little over a year now and have seen a huge improvement in the quality of my sleep. Our bodies
actually drop in temperature as we fall asleep, cool down even further in REM sleep, and then
warm up as we wake. The cover tracks your sleep stages and temperature and automatically adjusts
the temperature up ... or down ... to improve your sleep based on your sleep stages. Yes,
it heats and cools. It’s pumping heated and cooled water through the fitted bed pad. You
can adjust each side of the bed independently, so your partner can have their own preferences set.
My wife is absolutely loving our Eight Sleep Pod. I've seen a huge improvement in how I'm sleeping
each night and miss it when I’m traveling and staying in hotels. Use the promo code and link
in the description to get one today. I highly recommend it. Thanks to Eight Sleep and all of
you for supporting the channel. So how exactly do you turn a hydroelectric turbine without blades?
With the power of Charybdis <--ka-rib-dis-->. If that’s Greek to you, let’s frame it in terms
of the ultimate metaphor for Archimedian mathematics: personal hygiene. You know the
fun little whirlpools that we witness every time we drain a bathtub? Well,
in this case, it was whirlpools found along the Vltava River in Prague that initially
inspired Sedláček to study vortexes in hopes of harnessing their energy.
So, imagine what would happen if you stuck a rotor (stay with me here) in
these swirling waves. It would pretty much look like this...
Now that we’ve got the ball rolling…we can talk about the rolling fluid turbine,
as the SETUR was initially called. Basically, flowing water sets the rotor into two types of
motion — it rolls around the inside of the stator, and the rotor itself is rotating,
cranking the generator. It’s almost like a basketball rolling around the inside of the hoop:
the basketball is sliding around the hoop as well as rotating around its center.
Water flowing through the shape of the gap between the rotor and stator causes a vortex
that will continuously make the entire rotor roll along the edge of the stator. However,
it’s the rotation of the rotor itself that cranks the generator. Rotation-ception!
Another aspect of the SETUR that makes it really stand out — besides its lack of blades — is
that it’s not your typical micro-hydro system. It doesn’t need a dam, though you can incorporate it
in a water body that already has one. It doesn’t divert from its source, though you can route water
to it through piping. Instead, it works below the surface of your channel of choice to create its
vortex. As a reminder, if you want to learn more about the engineering behind the SETUR,
I highly recommend Ryan’s video. The inventors also published a theoretical analysis on their
design in 2022, because like all physics, there’s still a sense of mystery to it.
The SETUR comes in two models: the SETUR-M, which is rated for 500 W (with a 750 W maximum),
and the SETUR-L, rated for 5 kW (with a 7.5 kW maximum). With the former,
you can expect to produce anywhere from 4,380 kWh to 6,570 kWh per year. With the latter,
you can churn out between 43,800 kWh and 65,700 kWh per year.
The larger SETUR produces more than enough power in a year to cover the electricity consumption of
the average U.S. home, which amounted to roughly 10,791 kWh in 2022. But it’s important to note
here that those of us in the US tend to use a lot more electricity than other parts of the world,
and one of the primary conveniences of SHP is its ability to easily extend to regions
without grid access. In other words, well-sited SETUR turbines can mean more bang for your buck.
And the SETUR definitely isn’t picky. The smaller of the two models can submerge to depths of up to
50 meters (164 feet), with the larger able to operate fully submerged in 20 meters (about 66
feet) of water. The turbine needs a minimum head of only 1 meter (just over 3 feet) to function,
and it can also perform in water bodies with flows as low as 2 liters per second. You can
toss a SETUR into rivers and irrigation canals just like other SHP systems. It
also has marine applications, allowing you to harness energy from ocean currents and
tidal streams. On top of all that, the turbines can be arranged into an array
While this is an exciting development, the SETUR’s flexibility isn’t infinite. Though its models can
make use of low-flow, low-head environments in ways that previously weren’t possible with hydro,
you can’t stick these things everywhere. They won’t operate below freezing temperatures,
and their official manual recommends ice-plugging screens to protect them
under these conditions. That’s one point for dams,
which instead rely on reservoirs that are often deep enough to avoid winter work stoppages.
Then there’s of course the perils of sharing the river with natural debris and of course,
fish. It doesn’t seem that the SETUR has built-in safeguards against these — rather,
the manuals suggest using intake screens and limiting the amount of water that
flows through the system in order to protect wildlife and the device itself. Even though a
SETUR system probably has a significantly lower environmental impact than a traditional dam,
it still has the potential to negatively affect flora and fauna both in and out of the water.
How can we take small hydro a step further in the name of protecting
wildlife? Turbulent is one company aiming to answer that question. Based in Belgium,
Turbulent markets its submersible vortex turbine as an eco- and fish-friendly form of hydropower.
It also happens to look like a snail when viewed from above. Or a whistle. Or maybe a noisemaker.
The golden ratio. You could probably develop a personality quiz based on what you see here:
Any way you interpret its design, Turbulent’s smallest version of its turbine only needs a
head of 1.5 meters (or about 5 feet) and a flow of 1.5 cubic meters per second (or 53
cubic feet per second). As a result, Turbulent’s scalability definitely
opens up a lot of possibilities. And like other diversionary hydro systems, Turbulent
setups involve directing flowing water through a channel to its turbine, no reservoir required.
So, how much power are we talking about? Here’s how the specs shake out. Of course, you’ve got to
fit the turbine to the job. Turbulent offers multiple impeller dimensions to size turbine
setups in line with the dimensions of the site at hand. Currently, its power outputs range from
15 to 70 kW. It’s worth noting here that you can also string together multiple Turbulent turbines
along the same body of water. And remember, we’re talking about a near-continuous energy source.
Rivers aren’t as capricious as the wind, and don’t shut down for the night the way solar panels do.
In fact, Turbulent claims that a micro power plant based on its tech can boast up to a
90% plant factor, also known as a capacity factor. Capacity factor basically boils down
to the difference between what’s planned and what actually happens — just measured in electricity.
It’s a comparison of a power plant’s actual production versus its potential production,
based on how long it’s up and running. For reference, solar’s capacity factor varies,
but on average it tends to lie somewhere between 10 and 30 percent. On a global level,
utility scale solar’s capacity factor averaged out to about 17% in 2022. And
while that sounds like a big negative, it’s still a massive amount of power produced.
That isn’t to say that Turbulent turbines are intermittency-proof. The company itself notes that
seasonality is still a concern. Water height is, well…fluid. It ebbs and flows along with rain and
heat. This means that in hotter summers, you might have a thinner stream that leaves you producing
less energy. Then there’s the problem of winter. Turbulent has added a rubber coating on their
turbines that act as a defense against ice. If the water freezes, it expands against the rubber,
squishing it without damaging the components. The ice simply stops power generation. So,
the design can’t completely defeat intermittency, but it does extend the life of the turbine.
With this in mind, you might be wondering: Why bother with multiple mini-plants when you could
pool your resources into one macro-plant? Generally speaking, as factors like flow and
head scale up, so does the amount of electricity generated…but so do the dangers involved. Going
back to the Itaipú Dam for a sec, this risk-reward ratio is very plain. Between its 20 turbines at
700 MW each, its max production capacity tops out at 14,000 MW, or 14 GW. Those specs provide
enough to cover around 90% of Paraguay’s electricity consumption and 15% of Brazil’s.
At the same time, 13 years passed from the start of construction to the start
of operations. By Itaipú’s completion, the project had destroyed the Guaíra Falls and
consequently set off an influx of more than 30 invasive species between the regions that they
had previously separated. On top of this, the governments of Brazil and Paraguay ultimately
displaced at least 65,000 people in their joint effort to establish the dam.
Meanwhile, it took the Turbulent team less than a day to install a 13 kW turbine in the Ayung
River of Bali, Indonesia. The turbine supplies power to the adjacent Green School,
serving over 700 students and staff. Better yet, the setup doesn’t impact the ability of
fish to move freely, and the river’s natural flow is left undisturbed. That’s just one of
many examples of Turbulent projects you can find all over the map, from the Philippines to Chile.
Thinking smaller rather than bigger also means avoiding the compounding environmental damage
that manifests _after_ the dust has settled. Remember how I mentioned dam failures earlier?
Since recordkeeping began, an average of 10 dam failures occur in a given year in the U.S. Most
of these happen at smaller sites, which thankfully limits the toll. But when things at a major dam go
awry, it can cost human lives, require extensive evacuations, and devastate surrounding ecosystems.
Overall, large dams can only be located in specific places and can drastically affect
the ecosystem. However, they generate a lot of power, are less influenced by seasonal variations
and are generally low maintenance, long-lasting installations. SHPs are more flexible in terms of
installation locations, since they don’t require as much hydraulic head, and are easier on the
environment. It’s good for the consumer and local power generation or off-grid needs too.
As of 2019, small hydropower systems (that is, hydro rated for less than 10 MW) had a global
installed capacity of about 78 GW, according to the United Nations Industrial Development
Organization. That’s quite a ways behind wind and solar. Small hydro is meant to work in tandem with
other renewables, though, and there’s certainly no shortage of locations available for it to expand.
But what do you think about decentralized and small hydro?
Jump into the comments and let me know. I’ll see you in the next one.